[10. ARPA SUPPORT REQUEST - SAFESPACE INC (RC): RESOLUTION No. 10-2023; A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE AWARD OF A SUBRECIPIENT AGREEMENT TO SAFESPACE, INC. FOR SUPPORT OF RESPONSE TO DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AT A TOTAL CONTRACT AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $500,000 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 2024; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER OR HIS DESIGNEE TO EXECUTE ALL DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO EXECUTE THIS TRANSACTION; APPROVING A SUPPELEMENTAL APPROPRIATION IN THE AMOUNT OF $500,000 FROM THE UNAPPROPRIATED BALANCE OF THE AMERICAN RESCUE PLAN ACT FUND TO RESPONSE TO DOMESTIC VIOLENCE/DOMESTIC VIOLENCE PREVENTION AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

WHAT THE STATUS OF THEIR THAT'S ALL I HAVE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR LISTENING. OKAY SO MOVING ON TO. I DON'T TEND TO SUPPORT REQUEST. AND WHO'S HANDLING THAT DAVE MICHAEL WITH THE RESOLUTION, AND THEN I'LL START THIS IS RESOLUTION NUMBER 10-2023, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE AWARD OF A SUB RECIPIENT AGREEMENT TO SAFE SPACE INC FOR SUPPORT OF RESPONSE TO DOMESTIC VIOLENCE. TOTAL CONTRACT AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $500,000 THROUGH DECEMBER 31ST 2024 AUTHORIZED IN THE CITY MANAGER OR HIS DESIGNEE TO EXECUTE ALL DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO EXECUTE THIS TRANSACTION. APPROVING A SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION IN THE AMOUNT OF $500,000 FROM THE UN APPROPRIATED BALANCE OF THE AMERICAN RESCUE PLAN ACT FUND TO RESPOND TO DOMESTIC VIOLENCE, DOMESTIC VIOLENCE PREVENTION AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU, MR MAYOR. ALSO JOINING ME WAS, UH, MISS JACKIE MAY OUR GRANT ADMINISTRATOR UM, SO WE HAD SET ASIDE ORIGINALLY A MILLION DOLLARS OUT OF OUR REFUNDS FOR BASICALLY COMMUNITY OUTREACH. WHERE GRANT FOR GRANT APPLICATIONS. THIS IS COMMON FOR ANYONE RECEIVING ARPAIO WHO RECEIVE OR LARGER ORGANIZATIONS , SOME OF THE SMALLER ORGANIZATIONS THAT RECEIVED A COUPLE $100. THEY DID NOT DO THAT, BUT MOST LARGER ORGANIZATIONS DID SET UP A GRANT TYPE APPLICATION PROCESS. MARTIN COUNTY'S IS AVAILABLE ON THEIR WEBSITE AND YOU CAN APPLY THROUGH THE WEBSITE. FOR FUNDING FROM FROM THEIR ARPAIO AMOUNTS THAT THEY HAVE ALLOCATED FOR WHAT I'M CALLING COMMUNITY OUTREACH. UM THE MILLION DOLLARS WE HAD SET ASIDE, NO ONE HAD APPLIED YET SAFE SPACES, THE FIRST ORGANIZATION TO COME BEFORE YOU THAT HAS APPLIED. WE HAD SET AN INTERNAL CAP OF 500,000 PER REQUEST. THIS WAS IN PART FROM THE DISCUSSIONS WE WERE HAVING PREVIOUSLY WITH HOUSING SOLUTIONS COALITION FOR, UM, A PROJECT NORTH OF TOWN THAT THAT ENDED UP NOT HAPPENING. UM SAFE SPACES APPLICATION, I BELIEVE ACTUALLY CAME IN OVER THE 500. WE HAD ASKED IF THEY WOULD BE ABLE TO FUNDRAISE OR GET THE OTHER REBALANCE OF THE FUNDS THEMSELVES, WHICH I BELIEVE THEY AGREED THAT THEY COULD SO WE KEPT HIM OUT OF THE 500 MAXIMUM REQUESTS THAT WE HAD HAD GIVEN, UM I BELIEVE THERE. UH PROJECT IS BASED AROUND, UM, SOME REMODELING AND SOME PROGRAMMING PRIMARILY FOR TRAUMA , INFORMED CARE, UM, TYPE OF ACTIVITIES WITH THEIR WITH THEIR CLIENTS. THEY ARE HERE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THEIR APPLICATION. IS ANYBODY FROM SAFE SPACE WANT TO HAVE A PRESENTATION OR ANYTHING? THE WORDS I SEE YOU GOT THE BIG GUNS OUT TODAY. YEAH. TOM IS HERE. GOOD EVENING. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH COMMISSIONERS FOR CONSIDERING THIS GRANT APPLICATION FOR SAFE SPACE. I'M ACCOMPANIED HERE TODAY BY MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF SAFE SPACE TOBACCOS DISTRICT ATTORNEY OUT I'M GOODNER COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE. SANDY JOE CROCKER, JESSICA MALYSHEV CONDIMENT RESOURCES. COOPER'S OUR

[01:40:01]

PRESIDENT AND CFO OF THE INDIAN RIVER SHARES. UM OFFICE AND JOANNE WILLIAM BARKER. FROM GOVERNMENT THROUGH DEVELOPMENT AND WE'RE VERY EXCITED TO BE HERE. AND WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR THOUGHTFUL CONSIDERATION OF THIS REQUEST. DOMESTIC VIOLENCE CONTINUES TO INCREASE WITH IT RECENTLY AMID YEAR ANALYSIS REPORT OF HOW WE WERE DURING THIS FISCAL YEAR 2023 JULY ONE THROUGH DECEMBER, 31ST AND WE FOUND THAT IN MARTIN COUNTY REQUESTS FOR SERVICES HAD INCREASED. 54% 54. IT'S STAGGERING. AND AGENCY WIDE. WE HAVE ALREADY SERVED 566 VICTIMS OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AS COMPARED LAST YEAR TO 7 76. THAT'S A 20% INCREASE YEAR OVER YEAR FOR THE SAME PERIOD. SO THIS PROJECT IS HAS BEEN VERY THOUGHTFULLY DESIGNED TO ENSURE THAT OUR EMERGENCY SHELTER HAS A TRAUMA INFORMED CARE MODEL WHERE INDIVIDUALS CAN COME IN. AND THAT WE ARE VERY THOUGHTFUL TO ENSURE THAT THEIR HEALING PROCESS AND THAT THEY COMPLY WITH ALL THE RECOMMENDATIONS THAT WE PROVIDE TO THEM TO TRANSITION TO AN INDEPENDENT LIFE FOR YOUR VIOLENCE AS THAT, AT THE SAME TIME THAT WE TAKE CARE TO ENSURE THAT THERE ARE NO TRIGGERS FOR RE VICTIMIZATION BY THE MODEL THAT WE ARE INTENDING TO IMPLEMENT. WE'VE ALREADY DONE THIS MODEL AND AN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FACILITY AND WE HAVE FOUND IT TO BE VERY EFFECTIVE IN THE PROCESS OF SERVING VICTIMS OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE. SO WE THANK YOU SO MUCH. DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? HAVE ONE IT'S GOING TO BE USED HERE IN MARTIN COUNTY. CORRECT IN OUR ONLY HOME IS, BUT YES, OUR 60 BED FACILITY IS LOCATED RIGHT HERE IN THE CITY OF START. MR. MAYOR. CAN I ASK QUESTIONS? UM, FIRST, I WANT TO SAY, UM JUST JUST JUST TO THINK OR FEDERAL GOVERNMENT FOR ALLOWING THE OPERA FUNDS WOULD BE AVAILABLE AND THEN FOR THE PAST THROUGH PROCESS AND THEN FOR IT TO BE HERE AT THE CITY FOR US TO ACTUALLY HAVE GONE THROUGH AND DECIDED THAT WE'RE GOING TO TAKE SOME OF THE MONEY OUT TO USE FOR SOME SOCIAL THINGS THAT HAS BEEN IN THE PAST WHERE OUR CITY AND COUNTY AND OTHER PLACES HAVE NOT BEEN MAKING PLANS FOR SOCIAL SERVICE PLANNING, AND I KNOW THAT THERE'S A LOT OF TALK AND ALL KINDS OF GARBAGE OFFENSIVE OR ON THE OFFENSE, WHATEVER YOU MAY WANT TO CALL IT ALL THIS STUFF ABOUT DEFUND HERE AND DEFUND THERE, BUT IT'S NOT THAT IT'S MAKING SURE THAT THERE ARE FUNDS AVAILABLE TO HELP WHERE HELP IS NEEDED, ESPECIALLY SOCIAL SERVICES, MENTAL HEALTH, ALL THESE THINGS, AND I'M SO GLAD WE DECIDED TO MAKE THAT COMMENT THAT THAT DECISION NOW IN MAKING THAT DECISION AND THEN LOOKING AT THIS VERY FORTHRIGHT APPLICATION, WHICH IS SO TRANSPARENT LOOKING AT ALL THE TAX BACKGROUND AND ALL THE PAPERWORK THAT YOU PUT IN, AND WHEN I SAW THAT, TOM BACK A DOLL WAS ON THERE. I'M LIKE, CAN WE GET THEM A COUPLE MILLION DOLLARS? PLEASE BUT, UM, YOU KNOW THE 673. WHAT HAVE BEEN GOOD, BUT WE HAVE MADE THAT DECISION AND YOU'VE HEARD THAT WE'VE TAKEN SOME OF THAT MONEY FROM SOMETHING THAT WE REALLY WANTED TO DO WITH HOUSING. AND WE STILL HAVE THIS MONEY THERE THAT WE STILL WANT TO HOPEFULLY, HAVE SOMEBODY, UH, APPLY FROM HOUSING TO TRY TO DO SOMETHING AND OTHERS, BUT IF IT WERE OTHER WAYS, I WOULD HAVE BEEN MAKING A MOTION TODAY TO SAY LET'S GIVE YOU ALL 6 73. BUT UM AS THE MOTION STANDS, AND I KNOW THAT, MISS MAY I MEAN THERE'S A PROPOSAL STANDS AS MISS MAY HAS DONE HER WORK AND MAKING SURE THAT IT'S VERY GOOD AND IT MEETS MEETS EVERYTHING, AND I SAW YOUR PAPERWORK AND HER PAPERWORK AND ALL THE HIGHLIGHTS AND EVERYTHING THAT WAS IN THE AIR. UM I LEFT ALL MY NOTES SOMEWHERE ELSE. SO I CAN'T SPEAK TO THE SPECIFIC PAGES, BUT I KNOW THAT THEY'RE THERE AND ABSOLUTELY YOUR AGENCY. WE'VE HEARD SO MUCH ABOUT AGENCIES THAT ARE USING MONEY AND WASTING MONEY AND HIDING MONEY AND STEALING MONEY. I'M JUST SEE THE TRANSPARENCY OF YOUR APPLICATION AND THE WAY YOUR AGENCY OPERATES. I STAYED UP AN EXTRA COUPLE OF HOURS JUST GOING THROUGH STUFF AND IT WAS JUST, UM I WAS JUST ALWAYS. WELL THOSE OF YOU WHO KNOW ME KNOW THAT I'VE ALWAYS BEEN A SAFE SPACE PERSON HAVE DONE. A LOT OF THINGS WOULD SAY SPACE. THROUGH SYRIA, OPTIMIST THROUGH MYSELF THROUGH CHURCH THROUGH OTHER THINGS, UH, DEPENDENCE OF COURT ALL KINDS OF STUFF, BUT IT'S JUST ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. AND I KNOW THAT WE'LL HAVE OTHER COMMENTS. BUT RIGHT NOW I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT I AM THE PERSON WHO MAKES THE MOTION TO APPROVE RESOLUTION NUMBER 10-2023. AND IF SOMEBODY WANTS TO SECOND AND THEN WE CAN GO ON WITH THE COMMENTS, OTHERWISE

[01:45:04]

I'LL WAIT. OKAY THANKS. ALRIGHT BUT I JUST THINK IT IS. IT IS SO YOUR TRANSPARENCY AND THE MAKEUP OF YOUR BOARD. YOU ARE A WORTHY ORGANIZATION TO BE THE FIRST TO RECEIVE THESE TYPE OF FUNDING FROM THE CITY OF STEWART. THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER. THANK YOU. WE HAVE A MOTION. IT WAS SECOND, ANY OTHER COMMENTS. MR COLLINS WILL BE THE SLIGHTLY LESS UM. EXCITED CONVERSATION ABOUT THIS SO. NOT THAT I'M AGAINST THIS AT ALL. BUT WHEN DOES THIS MILLION DOLLARS HAVE TO BE ALLOCATED BY . 24 ALLOCATED AND SPENT BY 26. OKAY SO 24. SO HERE HERE'S MY ONLY POINT AND I WOULD JUST SAY.

WE ONLY HAVE A MILLION DOLLARS TO OFFER UP TO HELP OUR FIVE OH ONE C THREES AND OUR COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS THAT COULD USE THIS MONEY TO HELP SERVE RESIDENTS. WE'RE LOOKING AT POTENTIALLY GIVING AWAY THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT $500,000 HALF OF THAT MONEY TO ONE ORGANIZATION THAT IS THE FIRST TO EVEN APPLY FOR IT. SO MY THOUGHT WOULD BE WHY NOT? WHY BEING A RUSH? WHY NOT WAIT JUST A LITTLE BIT. SEE WHAT APPLICATIONS COME IN. OVER THIS TIME PERIOD AS WE GET CLOSER TO NEEDING TO HAVE IT ALLOCATED WE HAVE A YEAR. POTENTIALLY RIGHT. WHY NOT? LOOK AT WHAT COMES IN OVER THE NEXT YEAR AND THEN SORT OF SEE WHERE THE NEED IS AND THEN BE RESPONSIBLE ABOUT OFFERING IT UP AND MAYBE MAYBE IT'S $500,000 TO YOU GUYS BUT MAYBE THERE ARE SOME OTHER ORGANIZATIONS LOCALLY WHO HAVE NEED, UM YOU KNOW, AND AS A COMMISSION WE HAVEN'T REALLY TALKED ABOUT HOW WE WANT TO USE THIS MILLION DOLLARS COLLECTIVELY AS A GROUP. I DON'T KNOW HOW WELL IT'S BEEN ADVERTISED. THAT THIS IS AN OPTION. SO I WOULD JUST SAY, MAYBE MAYBE IT'S REASONABLE. IT SEEMS LIKE IT'S NOT THE POLITICAL, UH CONVERSATION RIGHT NOW, THEIR SUPPORT IN THE OTHER DIRECTION, BUT MAYBE TO WAIT AND SORT OF LOOK AT WHAT COMES IN OVER THE NEXT YEAR. IN TERMS OF APPLICATIONS COMMISSIONER ACCOUNT. I ASKED THE SAME QUESTION, BUT I THINK WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO FIND GRANT FOR OVER ALMOST ABOUT A YEAR NOW.

REMEMBER WHEN WE FIRST ESTABLISHED THE APPLICATION. IT'S BEEN CLOSE TO A YEAR AGO. I THINK WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT IT FOR WELL OVER HOUSING SOLUTIONS. CAKE TAKING THAT INITIALLY. BUT NOW THAT THAT'S NOT, BUT WE STILL THAT WAS ONLY HALF OF IT. AND THAT WAS THEN THIS IS THE ONLY OTHER APPLICATION ADVERTISE IT TO OUR LOCAL FIVE. OH ONE C THREES AND SEE WHO MIGHT NEEDED AND STEWART AS WELL. HOUSING SOLUTIONS. IT'S GOING TO COME BACK OR SOMEBODY LIKE ANOTHER ORGANIZATION, FAMILY PROMISE OR SOME OTHER ORGANIZATIONS TO TWO ORGANIZATIONS GETTING ALL THAT MONEY. MAYBE THERE'S SOME OTHER ORGANIZATIONS WHO MIGHT NEED HELP LOCALLY, THEY DON'T EVEN KNOW IT'S AN OPPORTUNITY. IT COULD BE MY POINT. BECAUSE IT'S ONLY A MILLION DOLLARS. WE DIDN'T LIKE, GO OUT AND DO A MAJOR ADVERTISEMENT FOR IT. I MEAN, I CAN'T REMEMBER HOW MANY MILLIONS OF THE COUNTY WAS GIVEN AWAY THAT THEY MAYBE A CHURCH NEEDS A ROOT FOR MAYBE THEY CAN GO TO THE COUNTY COUNTY HAS A WAY TO DO THAT, TOO. HEY ANY OTHER COVERAGES? WANTED TO MAKE A COMMENT. GO AHEAD. COME. COMMISSIONER RICHARD UM, JUST TO SPEAK TO YOUR QUESTION, COMMISSIONER COLLINS I ACTUALLY DID APPROACH ANOTHER NONPROFIT HERE IN TOWN AND THE ORIGINAL AMOUNT FOR THIS GROUP WAS 3 50. THEY WERE GOING TO GET 1 50. I DON'T KNOW. IT JUST DIDN'T WORK OUT IN THIS MAY RIGHT, CORRECT. THEY DIDN'T FOLLOW THROUGH ON THAT APPLICATION FOR THE RECORD . DR JACKIE MAY GRANT ADMINISTRATOR AND YOU ARE CORRECT, SIR. COMMISSIONER, THEY DID NOT MOVE FORWARD. SO I'VE ACTUALLY I'VE SPOKEN TO OTHER GROUPS ABOUT THE AVAILABILITY THIS MONEY. PERHAPS THAT'S MY AGE EXPERIENCE. WHEN MONEY IS AVAILABLE, I'LL TRY TO FIND A GOOD PLACE FOR IT. I JUST WANT TO SAY, UM, THIS FIRST THIS GROUP FIRST CAME TO MY ATTENTION WHEN WE MADE A PROCLAMATION AND I WAS DISAPPOINTED TO HEAR THAT WE WEREN'T ACTIVELY SUPPORTING. AND THEY WERE NICE ENOUGH TO ARRANGE A TOUR. AND MISS MAY AND MYSELF WENT AND ASKED MY WIFE TO ACCOMPANY ME AND SHE SAID, OH, NO, IT'S GOING TO BE TOO DEPRESSING. UM ON THE CONTRARY, IT WAS JUST A WONDERFUL SPACE AND, UH THE SENSE OF E Z IS MAYBE RELIEF THE WOMEN AND THE CHILDREN HAD AND THE FACILITY. IT WAS VERY IMPRESSIVE. UM. AND I THINK IT IS A LOCAL ARTIST GOING TO HELP YOU, A FRIEND. IS THAT TRUE? SHE DID COMMUNICATE WITH US, AND WE'RE IN CONVERSATION. THANK YOU. FOR THE REFERRAL COMMISSIONER. LOCAL ARTIST IS GOING TO HELP THEM. THEY'RE REDOING THE INTERIORS. I'M GLAD TO SEE SOMEONE FROM THE

[01:50:03]

SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT HERE. BECAUSE IN FACT IF THIS GROUP IS AFFECTIVE, IT TAKES A LOT OF PROVIDES RELIEF FOR YOUR CALLS. IS THAT CORRECT? YEAH. SO WE ACCOMPLISHED A GREAT MANY THINGS WITH THIS AND I'M VERY HAPPY THAT WE CAN DO THIS FOR YOUR ORGANIZATION. THANK YOU. THAT'S ALL THERE ANY COMMENT ON THE ZOOM AND WE HAVE ONE PUBLIC COMMENT. UH, AUDREY CREECH.

SORRY, DIDDLY STANDING. THANK YOU ALL. I DID NOT EXPECT TO BE SPEAKING TODAY. IN FACT, I'M HERE SIMPLY BECAUSE THIS IS PART OF MY JOB. I AM A LAND USE AND ZONING ATTORNEY HERE IN STUART.

I LIVE IN PALM CITY FARMS. AND I DID NOT EXPECT TO SPEAK TODAY. HOWEVER I DO WANT TO ADDRESS MAYBE SOME OF THE THINGS THAT ARE CAUSING PEOPLE TO BE A LITTLE MORE, UM HESITANT ABOUT GIVING MONEY. THERE IS A LITTLE BIT OF A BIAS, SAYING THAT DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ONLY HAPPENS IN SCENARIOS WHERE WHITE TRASH PEOPLE OR WHATEVER OR SOME DISADVANTAGED PEOPLE DOING THESE THINGS. I'M HERE TO TELL YOU JUST FROM A PERSONAL PERSPECTIVE . UNFORTUNATELY I WAS A VICTIM OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE. I CAME OUT OF THAT RELATIONSHIP LESS THAN TWO YEARS AGO. I AM SEVENTH GENERATION FLORIDIAN, FOURTH GENERATION MARTIN COUNTY AND I GREW UP IN PALM CITY FARMS. I DID NOT COME OUT OF A TRAILER PARK. I DID NOT COME OUT OF ANYTHING. RIDICULOUS I WAS A REGULAR PERSON WHO UNFORTUNATELY CAME ACROSS AN ALCOHOLIC, NARCISSISTIC PIECE OF YOU KNOW WHAT? OH GIVEN THAT I UNDERSTAND THE CONSERVATIVE COMMENTS OF HEY , THERE'S PROBABLY QUITE A FEW FIVE OH ONE C THREE IS THAT COULD USE THIS MONEY? UM. LIKE I SAID, I DIDN'T EXPECT TO SPEAK TODAY. BUT I WOULD SUGGEST TO YOU TAKE YOUR TIME. PLEASE. WE LOVE YOU ARE JOE. OKAY UM, IT'S OKAY. OKAY? THAT THIS IS UP. APPRECIATE TO PUT YOUR MONEY. SORRY IT'S OK TO HUG. GOD BLESS HER. HELLO, MCBRIDE. TELLING MCBRIDE ELEMENTS STEWART. I WANT TO GET MY ADDRESS BECAUSE I DON'T WANT TO SAY HI. MINE'S A HOUSEKEEPING FROM BUT SINCE THEY'RE ALL RIGHT HERE, IT'S THE BEST TIME I THINK FOR ME TO SPEAK ABOUT IT. FROM THE BEGINNING BEFORE THIS. THIS WAS JUST A DREAM AND TO HER SHE WAS INVOLVED AND SHE CAME TO ME AND EXPLAINED EVERYTHING AND ASKED ME TO SPEAK. ETHNIC JUST SUPPORTED AND DESCENDANT. AND I EDUCATED MYSELF, AND I DID IT.

PROBABLY A MATTER OF THE CITY RECORD. I DID SPEAK FOR THIS PLACE THIS BUILDING TO BE BUILT IN THAT, BUT MY PROBLEM IS I DON'T KNOW HOW OR THEIR JANITOR MAYBE HE DON'T WORK WEEKENDS, BUT THE PROBLEM IS FRIDAY. THEY PUT ALL THEY DON'T HAVE A DUMPSTER. THEY PUT MAYBE FOUR OR FIVE OR MORE. THE COLORED GARBAGE. YOU CANNOT PUT THE MATTRESSES OUT BROKEN FURNITURE THAT WHOLE STREET SAY HALF A BLOCK IS GARBAGE. AND YOU KNOW WITH KIDS MET. THANK YOU, UM. IT GETS DUMPED OVER IN THAT, SO I THINK IT ALL OF THESE WONDERFUL PEOPLE ARE HERE AND IF THEY WOULD JUST DO SOMETHING AH! I DO KNOW THEIR GARBAGE PICKED UP IS ON MONDAY AND YOU PUT IT OUT ON MONDAY AND INSPECTOR PUNCH TUESDAY BUT BETWEEN THE CITY SANITATION, THEY COULD WORK WITH THE CITY SANITATION DEPARTMENT AND LIKE WHEN THEY HAVE TO GET RID OF MATTRESSES AND ALL THOSE THINGS. I THINK WE COULD WORK IT OUT. BUT I'M ALL FIRST I'VE SUPPORTED IT BEFORE IT WAS EVEN BUILT AND I'M STILL PLENTY OF YOUNG PEOPLE, YOUNG GIRLS AND THAT HAVE GONE THROUGH IT. IT'S A WONDERFUL, WONDERFUL ORGANIZATION, BUT IT'S JUST LIKE IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD FOR NEIGHBORS, NOT A GOOD NEIGHBOR WITH THEIR GARBAGE. IT UPSETS THE PEOPLE, BUT. AND THERE ARE A LOT OF CHEER YOU ORGANIZATIONS. BUT LIKE YOU SAID, I CAN NEVER SAY YOUR LAST NAME. RICH UH, I'LL SAY, RICHIE, I'LL KILL IT. AH! IT YOU KNOW, AND WE THIS IS A LITTLE TOWN. WE ALL TALK TO EACH OTHER AND THAT IF THEY WERE, YOU KNOW, THEY ALL KNOW THE MONEY'S HERE AND THEY CAN

[01:55:01]

APPLY FOR IT. BUT I THINK YOU ALL SHOULD JUST SUPPORT THIS VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.

ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT. PARDON GIVE YOU THAT ONE IS FOR I DON'T $12.10 OKAY. IT IS NUMBER 10.

OKAY? JERRY GORE. I THOUGHT I LOOKED AT SOME PLACE ELSE THAT I THOUGHT IT'S A 12. AS BEING A PASTOR OF A CHURCH WORKING PASTOR. I'M NOT JUST ONE THAT SITS THERE AND PREACH ON SUNDAY.

GRAB MY BOB AND GO HOME. UH WE DO A LOT OF WORK. MY WIFE AND I AND WE DO NOT BROADCAST SOME OF THE THINGS THAT WE DO. WE WORKED FOR, WILL WE DEAL WITH, UH, MENTAL PATIENT? WE GO GET HIM OUT OF JAIL. WE'LL BRING THEM AND PUT THEM IN A SAFE PLOTS PROSPER. GOD THIS WEEK. I WAS IN THE HOSPITAL FOR A COUPLE OF DAYS. BUT MY WIFE CALLED ME SAID SHE HADN'T GOT HOME YET BECAUSE SHE HAD TO GO PICK UP DOMESTIC TAKE CARE OF THE DOMESTIC SITUATION. PUT THEM IN A HOTEL.

MY CHURCH DON'T HAVE A LOT OF MONEY, AND WE WORK OFF MY WIFE AND MYSELF. INCOME SO THAT WE DON'T GET INTO A LOT OF GOVERNMENT STUFF. WE DO A FOOD BANK. BUT WITH SAFE SPACE IS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I'M REALLY I'M GLAD TO SEE A GROUP LIKE THAT TO 11 IS GREAT, TOO.

BECAUSE RIGHT NOW, WITH THIS ONE SITUATION THAT WE HAVE NOW WE WENT BY TODAY AND TRYING TO PUT MORE MONEY ON IT. AH IN A HOTEL SO THAT THEIR STAY SAFE AND STAY IN THE SPOT, BUT WE ALSO HAVE OUR LIMITED WITHOUT MONEY AT OUR CHURCH, AND WE'RE NOT LOOKING FOR A HANDOUT. BUT TO HAVE A GROUP AN ORGANIZATION LIKE THIS THAT COULD KEEP THINGS CONFIDENTIAL AND TAKE CARE OF THESE PEOPLE'S TWO WEEK OF FOUND ANOTHER PLACE TO RELOCATE THEM. THIS IS AWESOME. WE UP AT THREE O'CLOCK AT NIGHT, TWO O'CLOCK AT NIGHT. AH, DEALING WITH SITUATION WHERE SOMEBODY FEEL LIKE THEY CAN TRUST US. THEY WOULD GIVE US A CALL, AND WE CAN KEEP IT ANONYMOUS AND WE GO OUT AND HELP THESE PEOPLE. WE DON'T HAVE THE FUNDS, BUT SOMETIMES WE CAN MOVE THEM FROM DIFFERENT ROOMS FROM PLACES TO PLACES. AND SO THEY REALLY NEED TO FUND THIS. I WISH I HAD SOME TO GIVE THEM TO HELP THEM OUT. BUT THIS NEEDS TO BE DONE. A LOT OF LIVES CAN BE SAVED. KIDS WHEN THEY'RE THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE. I GET SOME IN SUNDAY SCHOOL. AND THEY TALKED ABOUT THE WAY THEY LIVE AT HOME. SO IT'S WITH THEIR PARENTS AND THE WAY THEY'RE BEING TREATED THE THINGS THAT THEY'RE HERE AND NOW WE GOT TO DEAL WITH THIS INDIAN. YOU KNOW , YOUR PRISON IS GETTING LOADED WITH PEOPLE THAT IT'S NOT GETTING EARLY HELP IN THESE STAGES WHEN WE SEE THESE THINGS TAKING PLACE. THAT LOVELY SONG THAT THEY SANG HER TODAY THAT YOU KNOW IT'S A MELTING POT. BUT WHEN WE GOT TO STOP BEING THIS MELTING POT WHEN WE'RE GOING TO SEE CERTAIN SITUATIONS. THAT WE CAN HELP WITH IT AND JUST TURN OUR HEAD AND WALKED PAST IT. YOU KNOW, WE DO A LOT OF PRIVATE STUFF, BUT MY HANDS ARE FULL IN OUR LITTLE COMMUNITY. AND THEY DESERVE IT. IF ANYBODY ELSE DON'T DESERVE, THEY DESERVE IT. UH I WANT TO SAY ONE OTHER THING WHILE I'M UP HERE IS THAT DAVID DIES YOU REALLY BROKE MY HEART WHEN YOU SAY YOU WERE LEAVING. SORRY REALLY? BECAUSE BEFORE.

YOU CAN. I KNOW I NEED TO CUT IT OFF BEFORE YOU CAN. OUR ONLY COME TO STEWART AND EASIER FOR BIBLE STUDY AND EASE OUT AT THE BIBLE STUDY. BUT WHEN YOU CAME TO BE THE CHIEF UH, WHEN WE HAVE EVENTS, I SEE YOU'RE WELCOME. PHASE CHURCH INTIMACY ANYWHERE. YOU HAD A WELCOME FACE EVERYBODY IN THE COMMUNITY ANY. Y'ALL COULD WALK THROUGH THE COMMUNITY IN A HOWARD, BUT HE COULDN'T BECAUSE EVERYBODY RECOGNIZED HIM . HE BROUGHT SUNSHINE IN OUR COMMUNITY. HE DID THAT. WE ALL KNOW HIM. YOU CAN COME TO JUNEAU WITH MOVING SO YOU REALLY HAVE MADE MY HEART SAD. BUT I'M NOT GOING TO STAND IN THE WAY OF PROSPERITY. THAT'S RIGHT. OKAY BUT YOU REALLY MADE MY HEART SAD . SOME OF THE THINGS THAT ARE MIXED UP WITH. I SEE YOU DO IT AND WE'RE VERY SUCCESSFUL WITH IT. I SAID I CAN FOLLOW IN HER FOOTSTEPS. SO WE'RE GONNA MISS YOU WHEN I GO BACK HOME AND TELL MY WIFE BUT YOU SAID TONIGHT IT'S NOT GONNA BE GOOD, BUT I'M GONNA HAVE DINNER FIRST. THANK YOU. THANK YOU DO DESERVE THIS. FUNNY YOU OKAY? SEEING NO OTHER PUBLIC COMMENTS OF A WOULD YOU CALL THE ROLL? PLEASE? LET'S TAKE A VOTE. COMMISSIONER COLLINS YES, COMMISSIONER CLARK ? YES VICE MAYOR BRUNER. YES MAYOR. MCDONALD COMMISSIONER RICH. CONGRATULATIONS COMMISSIONER RATIONS. I JUST DID FEEL TO VOTE. YES I'M ALWAYS LAST ANYWAY. NO PUBLIC COMMENT

[02:00:07]

IS OVER. IF YOU JUST TOLD ME FOR ONE MOMENT, WE WILL ENDURE LONG AS IT'S NOT ABOUT DAVID. WELL RIGHT. WE'VE HAD ENOUGH OF DAVID KNIGHT, RIGHT? AND I'VE HEARD ABOUT BLOWING UP THINGS AND IT'S BEEN VERY ENLIGHTENING MEETING. I WILL TELL YOU, BUT I WANT TO SAY JUST TO ADDRESS COMMISSIONER COLLINS YOUR CONCERNS GOING TO TELL YOU THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS I'M A FISCAL CONSERVATIVE AS WELL. THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS YOU CAN DO WITH OUR MONEY , OUR TAX PAYING DOLLARS THAT DO GOOD IN THE COMMUNITY. BUT I'M TELLING YOU, THERE IS THERE ARE VERY FEW THINGS YOU CAN DO THAT I GUARANTEE WILL SAVE LIVES. THIS ORGANIZATION SAVES LIVES. I'M DEDICATED TO THIS ORGANIZATION AS A PROSECUTOR OF 33 YEARS, DAVID, I GOTTA TOUCH ON DAVID A LITTLE BIT. HE AND I RAN TOGETHER WHEN HE WAS JUST A LOWLY PATROLMEN AND I WAS PROSECUTING TO US. HE IS A JEWEL FOR THE CITY OF STORE. WE'RE GOING TO MISS YOU, DAVID. IT'S BEEN AN HONOR TO WORK WITH YOU FOR 33 YEARS. YOU'RE A DECENT MAN, AND THANK YOU ALL VERY MUCH . THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT SET UP A ROADBLOCK SO WE CAN'T LEAVE THE COUNTY. WE'LL WORK ON THAT. WELL, HE'S STILL GOING TO BE IN THE COUNTY, WHICH PUTS THEM IN MY JURISDICTION. DOWN SOUTH IN PALM BEACH COUNTY. NO, NOBODY LIVES HERE. WORK ALRIGHT. THANK YOU ALL VERY MUCH. GOOD NIGHT. THANK YOU. GOOD NIGHT. THANK

[11. GREEN REUSE AREA DESIGNATION (RC): RESOLUTION No. 09-2023; A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS AND DESIGNATING THE REAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT 980, 1050, AND 1120 SE MONTEREY ROAD EXTENSION, STUART, FLORIDA, IDENTIFIED BY MARTIN COUNTY FOLIO NUMBERS 16-38-41-000-000-00013-0, 16-38-41-000-000-00014-0, AND 16-38-41-000- 000-00016-0 (COLLECTIVELY, THE “SUBJECT PROPERTY”), AS FURTHER IDENTIFIED BY THE ATTACHED MAPS, COMMONLY REFERRED TO AS “THE LANDFILL”, PURSUANT TO SECTION 376.80, FLORIDA STATUTES OF FLORIDA’S BROWNFIELD DEVELOPMENT ACT FOR THE PURPOSE OF ENVIRONMENTAL REHABILITATION, JOB CREATION AND PROMOTING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT; AUTHORIZING THE CITY CLERK TO NOTIFY THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION OF SAID DESIGNATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

YOU, TOM. OKAY, MOVING ON TO ITEM NUMBER 11. OKAY GREEN REUSE DESIGNATION AREA ERA. MIKE, WOULD YOU READ THE RESOLUTION TITLE. THIS IS RESOLUTION NUMBER OH, 9-20 TO 3, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, MAKING CERTAIN FINDINGS AND DESIGNATING THE REAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT 980. 10 5 10 50 11 20 SOUTHEAST MONTEREY ROAD EXTENSION STUART, FLORIDA, IDENTIFIED BY MARTIN COUNTY FOLIO NUMBERS 16 38 41 000-000-0. AND 16 38 41 000-000 . AND ONLY 17 MORE. 16-38 DASH 41 DASH 000-000-0. 16-0 COLLECTIVELY, THE SUBJECT PROPERTY. AS FURTHER IDENTIFIED BY THE ATTACHED MAPS COMMONLY REFERRED TO AS THE LANDFILL PURSUANT TO SECTION 376.80, FLORIDA STATUTES OF FLORIDA'S BROWNFIELD DEVELOPMENT ACT FOR THE PURPOSE OF ENVIRONMENTAL REHABILITATION, JOB CREATION AND PROMOTING ECONOMIC REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORIZING THE CITY CLERK TO NOTIFY THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION OF SAID DESIGNATION. PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. MR MAYOR. UM SO THIS ITEM COMES TO BEFORE YOU AND I KNOW WE HAVE SOME NEW COMMISSIONERS THAT WEREN'T HERE. WHEN WE FIRST PAST THIS ITEM TO ENGAGE WITH JUST GOING TO CALL THE GOLDSTEIN GROUP, ALTHOUGH THERE IS MORE PARTNERS THAN THAN JUST MR GOLDSTEIN'S GROUP. UM SO WE THIS IS PART OF THAT CONTRACT THAT WE ENTERED INTO THEM TO DECLARE THIS PROPERTY OF GREEN REUSE. SOME OFLOVE REFER TO IT AS A BROWNFIELD. THE DECLARATION OF THIS PROPERTY ALLOWS THE ORGANIZATIONS TO THEN, UM, SECRET MEDIATION ACTION AND GRANT FUNDING FOR THE REMEDIATION ACTION. IT'S PART OF, UM THE LANDFILL THAT'S OVER ON MONTEREY ROAD BEHIND FIRE STATION, TOO. AND WILL ULTIMATELY ALLOW FOR THAT. SOME ODD. 50 ACRES THERE TO BE REDEVELOPED INTO SOMETHING FOR TAX BASE PURPOSES. OKAY GREAT. WELL ONE THING JUST WANT TO SAY A QUICK QUICK QUESTIONS. MIKE IS IF I RECALL IT IN A WHILE SINCE WE APPROVED THE CONTRACT WITH THE GOLDSTEINS GROUP, BUT THIS IS ONE OF OUR CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS. YES IT'S WHAT THE CONTRACT SAID, IS THAT WE WOULD COOPERATE WITH THEM AND ASSIST AND SEEKING ANY FUNDING, GRANT MONEY AND DESIGNATIONS AND ESSENTIALLY WHAT THIS IS. IS US. ASSISTING IN PASSING A RESOLUTION TO SEEK THE DESIGNATION NECESSARY FOR THEM TO APPLY FOR THE CLEANUP. OKAY ONE OF THE THINGS I WOULD HAVE HAD A COUPLE OF PHONE CALLS FROM FOLKS ON THIS THAT I DON'T COMPLETELY UNDERSTAND IT. UM SO THE CITY HAS A LANDFILL. THAT IS A APPROXIMATELY 50 ACRES.

SOMETHING LIKE SOMETHING LIKE THAT. LET'S JUST SAY 50, BUT IT'S PROBABLY A LITTLE BIT LESS THAN THAT. IT'S CONTAMINATED. UH, WITH TRASH. THERE'S A I BELIEVE. I BELIEVE WE'RE IN A CONSENT ORDER WITH THE EP FURTHER. CENTER WITH THE DP IS NOT RELATED TO THE LANDFILL AS MUCH AS IT IS A PLUME OF PEOPLE PEOPLE DON'T KNOW T C T FROM THE T C, BUT IT'S ON THAT PROPERTY.

THE PART OF IT THE WAR THE NORTH . BE WHATEVER IT'S CALLED TO TREAT IT. BUT WILL THAT WORK AT

[02:05:09]

A CLOSURE ON THAT? OKAY WE JUST GOT LIKE, THREE MONTHS AGO. THEY APPLIED FOR, UM, A AN END TO THAT. PLAN THAT WAS TAKING PLACE. ESSENTIALLY THEY'VE BEEN PUMPING WATER BECAUSE THE CHEMICALS THAT WERE USED TO PUT OUT FOR THE T, C T OR WHATEVER IN THAT PLUME HAVE BEEN MONITORED AND SHIFTED FOR LONG ENOUGH THAT IT HAS BEEN DETERMINED THAT IT'S NOT ACTUALLY MOVING ON IN PLACE. WELL, THAT'S AWESOME. GOOD TO HEAR. BUT MR ROMAN HERE FROM THE GOLDSTEIN'S ORGANIZATION PERFECT AND COME ON UP TO THE PODIUM, WE'LL GET TO YOU IN A SECOND HERE, UH, ONE OF THE THINGS I WAS GOING TO SAY, IS, REGARDLESS OF THE PLUME. WE HAVE THIS BROWNFIELD SITE THAT NEEDS TO BE CLEANED UP AND UNLINED LANDFILL IN HERE, UNLIKE LANDFILL FROM BEFORE THEY LINED LANDFILL, AND THIS IS THE WAY THAT NOT ONLY IF THEY'RE NOT GONNA COST US MONEY IF YOU CLEAN IT UP, BUT IT'S GOING TO PUT THE PROPERTY BACK ON THE TAX ROLLS. UH IF I RECALL FROM OUR MEETING WHEN WE APPROVED THIS, THERE WAS A COUPLE OF THINGS ONE IS. I GUESS THERE WERE DIFFERENT LEVELS OF CLEANUP THAT THEY COULD DO. AND WE WANTED THEM TO GO FOR THE LEVEL. WE DID NOT WANT ANY RESIDENTIAL EVER A ON THE TOP OF THE HOLD LANDFILL, SO WE AGREED TO THE CLEAN UP FOR COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL, UH AND THAT'S ULTIMATELY THE GOAL IS TO PUT IT BACK ON THE TAX ROLLS, PRODUCING A TAX BASE FOR THE CITY OF STEWART SOMETIME IN THE FUTURE, WITHOUT CAUSING OF WITHOUT US HAVING TO GO AND SPEND THE MONEY. CLEANING IT. AND, UH AND IF I RECALL FROM THE CONTRACT THAT THERE'S EITHER A BONDED INSURANCE REQUIREMENT THAT GUARANTEES ONCE ONCE THEY CLOSED ON THE PROPERTY BECAUSE THEY'RE IN THE DUE DILIGENCE PERIOD THINK THE DUE DILIGENCE PERIOD WAS JUST SHY OF A YEAR. OH THEY WERE GOING. WHAT'S THAT 170 DAYS? 270 DAYS, SO THREE QUARTERS OF A YEAR AND BECAUSE THEY WERE GOING TO DO BORING SAMPLES AND OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES TO MAKE SURE THAT IT WAS FEASIBLE TO DO THE CLEANUP. AND I THINK THIS IS AS WE AGAIN THIS KIND OF GOES BACK TO THE PROACTIVE THINGS THAT THE CITY OF STEWART HAS BEEN DOING ENVIRONMENTALLY. THIS IS DIFFERENT THAN THE OTHER STUFF, BUT BY GETTING THIS CLEANED UP AND FINDING A WAY TO PAY FOR IT, BECAUSE WAS THIS THE LANDFILL FOR THE ENTIRE COUNTY AT ONE TIME? AS A MATTER OF FACT, IT WAS AND I DON'T KNOW THE HISTORY . SPEAKING OF ONE OF THE OTHER COMMISSIONERS LAST WEEK ABOUT IT, THE CITY ACQUIRED IT AFTER STOPPED USING OR THE COUNTY STOPPED USING IT AS LANDFILL TO THIS DAY. I CAN'T IMAGINE THAT PUBLIC HEARING WHERE THE COMMISSION BOARD VOTED. YEAH WE'D LOVE TO HAVE A TOXIC SITE LIKE I DON'T KNOW HOW THAT HAPPENED. WHATEVER REASON, WE HAVE A MESS TO CLEAN UP AND THIS IS A WAY TO GET IT DONE. UM, WE HAVE SOMEONE HERE FROM THE GOLDSTEIN GROUP. ARE YOU MR REESE? MY NAME IS BRETT BREMOND. OKAY OKAY. COMMENT CARD YET. OKAY WELL, GOOD. YOU'RE ACTUALLY NEED ONE. SO OKAY, SO DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING YOU'D LIKE TO ADDRESS? CERTAINLY, THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION THAT HE STAFF I'M BRETT BRAHMAN WITH THE GOLDSTEIN ENVIRONMENTAL LAW FIRM OR OFFICER AT £2100 STEEL ON BOULEVARD AND CORAL GABLES. AND WE REPRESENT THE CONTRACT PURCHASER. GOLDSTEIN KATE REDEVELOPMENT PARTNERS TWO OR ONE LLC, AND MORE THAN THAT OUR FIRM WORKS WITH LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNERS ACROSS THE STATE TO ADDRESS AS YOU JUST LIKE THIS TO BRING SITES THAT ARE CURRENTLY UNUSED. THEY HAVE A HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLICATIONS, ADDRESS THOSE COMPLICATIONS THROUGH THE RESOURCES PROVIDED BY THE STATE IN FLORIDA BROWN BECAUSE REDEVELOPMENT PROGRAM AND PUT THEM BACK INTO PRODUCTIVE REUSE. AND IF I MAY GIVE A VERY BROAD OVERVIEW OF THE PROGRAM AND HOW IT'S AVAILABLE HERE AND A LITTLE ABOUT THE PROCESS IF YOU DON'T MIND, SO THE FLORIDA BROWNFIELDS REDEVELOPMENT PROGRAM WAS ESTABLISHED IN 1997, AS AS A TOOL FOR BOTH LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND DEVELOPERS TO OVERCOME THOSE COMPLICATIONS TO PROPERTY REUSE , ESPECIALLY WHERE THERE IS ENVIRONMENTAL CONTAMINATION INVOLVED, AND IT ALLOWS FOR REDEVELOPMENT OF FOCUS ON ALREADY DISTURBED SITES RATHER THAN EXPANDING OUT INTO OUR GREEN FIELDS OR ARE PREVIOUSLY UNDISTURBED LAND SO IT FOCUSES DEVELOPMENT ON OUR DATE.

DEVELOPED OR IN ALREADY DEVELOPED AREAS EXACTLY LIKE WHERE OUR PROPERTY IS LOCATED HERE. HAS THE ADDED BENEFIT OF CREATING A MECHANISM FOR PROPERTY OWNERS WHETHER THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT OR PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNER, THE PROGRAM IS EQUALLY AVAILABLE TO ALL TO ACTUALLY ADDRESS THOSE COMPLICATIONS AND, UH, REUSE THE SITE AND IN THIS INSTANCE IN THIS CASE, UH, ALTHOUGH SOME OF THE OLDER ISSUES HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED THE LANDFILL THERE HAVE BEEN NEW ISSUES DISCOVERED WITH THIS GOVERNMENT OF THE FELLA PLUME BENEATH THE LANDFILL AND SURROUNDING SITES. SO WHAT THIS PROGRAM DOES IS IT ALLOWS THOSE ISSUES TO BE ADDRESSED COST EFFECTIVELY AND EFFICIENTLY WITH FUNDS PROVIDED BY THE STATE. AS WELL AS FROM PRIVATE

[02:10:02]

PROPERTY OWNERS FROM FROM THE PRIVATE SECTOR RATHER THAN DIPPING INTO THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS FUNDS TO ADDRESS THE CONTAMINATION THERE. AND IT DOES THIS THROUGH THREE CATEGORIES OF INCENTIVES, REGULATORY INCENTIVES. FLORIDA HAS A DEDICATED BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT PROGRAM, WHICH MEANS THEY HAVE DEDICATED BROWNFIELD STAFF WHO REVIEW ENVIRONMENTAL REPORTS. THIS IS ALL DONE UNDER THE OVERSIGHT OF THE STATE. AND THEY CAN DO THAT QUICKLY AND EFFICIENTLY, AND THESE REVIEWS ARE STREAMLINED BECAUSE THEY ARE BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS. ANOTHER CATEGORY ARE THE LEGAL INCENTIVES, MUCH LIKE WE HAVE AVAILABLE UNDER FEDERAL LAW PURCHASE THE INNOCENT PURCHASER OF CONTAMINATED PROPERTY IS JOYCE SOME PROTECTIONS FROM LIABILITY BY ENTERING INTO A CONTRACTUAL AGREEMENT WITH THE STATE COLLEGE BROWNFIELD SITE REHABILITATION AGREEMENT IN ANY PARTY TO THAT AGREEMENT IS ABLE TO ENJOY THE SAME LIABILITY PROTECTIONS AS WELL AS PROJECT LENDERS. AND THE FINAL CATEGORY OF INCENTIVES AVAILABLE ARE THE FINANCIAL INCENTIVES AND THOSE ARE FUNDED THROUGH FLORIDA CORPORATE INCOME TAX, AND THEY PRIMARILY CONSISTS OF FLORIDA CORPORATE INCOME TAX CREDITS THAT ULTIMATELY REDUCE THEY DON'T COMPLETELY ELIMINATE THE COST OF CLEANUP, BUT THEY REDUCE THE COST OF CLEANUP. THE PROCESS . WE ARE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE PROCESS. NOW THERE ARE TWO MAJOR STEPS TO GET TO THE ULTIMATE CLEANUP OF THE PROPERTY. THE FIRST IS THE BROWNFIELD AREA DESIGNATION. OR WE LIKE TO CALL IT A GREEN REUSE AREA DESIGNATION BECAUSE THE END RESULT DOES NOT REFLECT HOW THE PROPERTY CURRENTLY IS NOW. SO THE BROWNFIELD AREA DESIGNATION IS THAT HAS DONE BY RESOLUTION BY THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT. THE SECOND STEP IS EXECUTION OF BROWNFIELD SITE REHABILITATION AGREEMENT WITH THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION. AND THAT IS IN ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS THAT TAKES PLACE ONLY ONCE AN AREA IS DESIGNATED. THERE ARE DIFFERENT ROUTES FOR DESIGNATION. SOME AVAILABLE TO PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNERS. THE ROUTE HERE IS UNDER SUBSECTION TWO A OF THE STATUTE AND IT'S AVAILABLE FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT HAS THE AUTHORITY TO DESIGNATE ANY PROPERTY WITHIN THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT AS A BROWNFIELD AREA OR GREEN REUSE AREA AT ITS DISCRETION. THE PROCESS IS RELATIVELY SIMPLE, REQUIRES PUBLICATION OF NOTICE AND POSTING A NOTICE THAT THE PROPERTY AS WELL AS TWO ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS. THIS IS THE FIRST OF THOSE TWO PUBLIC HEARINGS. WE ALSO WORKED WITH CITY STAFF AND THE CITY CLERK WHO STAYED LATE ONE EVENING TO HELP US HOLD A COMMUNITY MEETING RIGHT HERE IN THE CHAMBERS. WE DID NOT HAVE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC ATTEND, BUT WE DID MAKE A PRESENTATION. UM AND AFTER THAT THE SECOND OF THOSE TWO PUBLIC HEARINGS, THE CITY COMMISSION WILL BE ASKED TO CONSIDER FOUR FACTORS. UM SET BY STATUTE, AND THE FIRST IS WHETHER THE AREA WARRANTS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT HAS A REGIONAL POTENTIAL FOR SUCH ACTIVITIES. THE SECOND IS WHETHER THE AREAS REASONABLY FOCUSED AND NOT OVERLY LARGE, LARGE AND COVERAGE. THE THIRD IS WHETHER THE PRIVATE SECTOR IS INTERESTED IN PARTICIPATING IN THE REDEVELOPMENT AND REHABILITATION. AND FINALLY, IF THERE ARE ANY PARTS OF THE SITE SUITABLE FOR LIMITED RECREATIONAL, OPEN SPACE, CULTURAL OR HISTORICAL PRESERVATION PURPOSES. AND THESE FACTORS ARE YOURS FOR CONSIDERATION AND WE RESPECTFULLY SUBMIT THAT THIS PROPERTY IS A PRIME CANDIDATE FOR THIS DESIGNATION BASED ON ITS CURRENT CONDITION, THE AMOUNT OF WORK THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE AS WELL AS THE STRONG INTEREST IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR AND COMING IN AND PICKING UP THE BATON FROM THE CITY TO BRING THIS SITE ULTIMATELY TO CLOSURE AND THAT I'M AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY OF YOUR QUESTIONS. THANK YOU QUESTIONS. UM I DON'T KNOW.

BETWEEN YOURSELF AND MR UM DIET SKIN. TELL US, SO. WHEN IS THAT SCHEDULED NOW THAT YOU DO THIS TO MEETINGS UM, WHAT IS YOUR SCHEDULE TO TRY TO ACTUALLY DO SOMETHING LIKE THE START ALL THAT PHYSICAL STUFF TO RETEST AND TO REWORK AND TO DO THINGS IN THE AREA. THANK YOU, MR CLARK . THAT IS STILL UP IN THE AIR. HOWEVER THE BY CONTRACT, WE HAVE AGREED TO ENTER INTO THAT BROWNFIELD OR SUBMIT THAT BROWNFIELD SITE REHABILITATION AGREEMENT TO THE STATE WITHIN 30 DAYS OF APPROVAL OF THE RESOLUTION. SO THAT PROCESS WILL BEGIN RIGHT AWAY. UH THE STATE WOULD REVIEW THAT AGREEMENT PROVIDE COMMENTS ULTIMATELY WOULD BE EXECUTED. AND THEN, UH , 270 DAYS FROM EXECUTION OF THAT AGREEMENT, THE STATE WOULD REQUIRE A SITE ASSESSMENT REPORT BE FILED, PREPARED AND FILED AND THAT LOOKS AT WHAT THE CURRENT CONDITIONS THERE ARE. UH, AND THIS IS ALL IN PREPARATION FOR DEVELOPMENT OF A REMEDIAL ACTION PLAN. THAT REMEDIAL ACTION PLAN WILL LIKELY BE A LITTLE CLOSER TO THE END OF THE YEAR, MAYBE INTO NEXT YEAR, BASED ON THE AMOUNT OF TIME IT TAKES TO GATHER ALL THE REQUIRED DATA, SO THERE IS A LITTLE BIT OF A LEAD TIME HERE, BUT IT'S ALL TO MAKE SURE THAT WE GATHER ALL THE APPROPRIATE DATA. WE CAN ADDRESS ALL THE IMPACTS, UM TO CLEAN UP THE PROPERTY VOTES TO THE SATISFACTION OF FDP AND THE COMMUNITY. NO I'M SURE THAT THEY'LL BE BACK TO US AGAIN SO WE CAN FIGURE OUT WHERE YOU'RE GONNA PUT STUFF WHEN YOU DIG IT UP OR YOU'RE GONNA HIDE IT OR OF COURSE YOU HAVE. THIS PROCESS IS THE REDEVELOPMENT PROCESS WILL BE BACK TO THE CITY TO ENSURE ALL OF THOSE APPROVALS. NOTHING WILL BE HIDDEN IN THIS WHERE REDUCE VERY TRANSPARENTLY. IN ADDITION, WE HAVE STRONG OVERSIGHT OF THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT, ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AND THERE THERE'S ALSO THE REQUIRED MINISTRATIONS OF BROWNFIELD ADVISORY COMMITTEE AS PART OF THAT BROWNFIELD SITE

[02:15:01]

REHABILITATION AGREEMENT. WE UNDERSTAND IT'S AN UPHILL BATTLE , AND IT'S A LOT OF THINGS TO TAKE CARE OF. YEAH. IT WOULD HELP MR COLLEGE. WHAT'S THE PLAN TO DO YOU WANT TO DO WITH THE LAND? WE YEAH. THANK YOU. WE ARE NOT SURE YET THAT WILL BE SUBJECT TO ADDITIONAL STUDIES AND REVIEWS TO SEE EXACTLY WHAT COULD GO THERE WITH THE HIGHEST AND BEST USE OF THAT LAND IS DISCUSSIONS WITH THE COMMUNITY TO SEE WHAT IS A GOOD FIT FOR THAT AREA, AS WELL AS DISCUSSIONS WITH CITY STAFF BECAUSE JUST VERY EARLY IN THE PROCESS, SO THIS IS WHAT THIS DESIGNATION WOULD DO WOULD PROVIDE THAT SECURITY AND COMFORT THAT SO THAT WE KNOW WE CAN MOVE FORWARD TO THOSE, UH, THOSE FOLLOWING STEPS. WHAT LEVEL OF REMEDIATION? THIS IS NEW TO ME. I'M NOT AN ENVIRONMENTALIST. WHAT LEVEL OF REMEDIATION, DO YOU PLAN ON DOING TO THAT LAND BECAUSE I'M I'M ASSUMING. THERE ARE DIFFERENT. DIFFERENT USES ARE GOING TO REQUIRE DIFFERENT LEVELS OF CLEANUP. YES, SIR. YES IN FLORIDA. WE HAVE THREE CATEGORIES OF CLEANUP. IT'S ALL RISK BASED CORRECTIVE ACTION. THE FIRST CATEGORY IS TO CLEAN UP EVERY MOLECULE OF CONTAMINATION OUT THERE. THAT'S NOT REALLY REALISTIC SCENARIO.

IN THIS CASE, OUR SECOND OPTION IS CALLED RISK MANAGEMENT OPTION LEVEL TWO, AND THAT'S WHERE SOME CONTAMINATION REMAINS, WHETHER IN SOIL OR GROUNDWATER. BUT ACCESS TO THE CONTAMINATED SOIL MIGHT BE PREVENTED BY AN IMPERVIOUS ENGINEERING CONTROL CAP. SAY PARKING AREAS. CONCRETE SLABS, LANDSCAPING, TWO FT OF CLEAN SOIL AND AREAS WHERE YOU'RE NOT CONCERNED ABOUT CONTAMINANTS LEACHING OUT FROM RAINWATER. AS WELL AS A RESPECTED CONTAMINATED GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATED GROUNDWATER. PLUME CAN STAY AS LONG AS IT DOES NOT EXTEND BEYOND THE PROPERTY BOUNDARIES, AND IT'S NOT SHOWN TO BE MIGRATING IF THAT IF IT DOES EXPAND BEYOND THE PROPERTY BOUNDARIES YOU NEED TO, WE WILL HAVE TO EXPAND TO THE NEIGHBORING PROPERTIES AND WORK WITH THEM TO IMPOSE RESTRICTIONS ON THE GROUNDWATER USE THERE TO PREVENT THAT PLUME FROM BEING IMPACTED ANY FURTHER REMEDIATION TAKES PLACE AND THERE'S ANOTHER LEVEL RISK MANAGEMENT OPTION. LEVEL THREE WHERE THOSE SAME CONTROLS CAN BE PUT IN PLACE.

BUT WE CAN ALSO ADDED THE ADDITION OF THAT LAND USE RESTRICTION OR INSTEAD OF CLEANING THE PROPERTY TO THE RESIDENTIAL STANDARD. THE PROPERTY SOILED ON THE PROPERTY CAN BE REMEDIATED TO THE COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL STANDARD. BUT THERE IS A LAND USE RESTRICTIONS. PREVENT RESIDENTIAL USE DAYCARE USE ANYTHING WITH SENSITIVE OR SENSITIVE PERSONS MIGHT BE ON THE PROPERTY FOR STANDARD PERIOD INTEND TO DO MANAGEMENT OPTION LEVEL TWO WOULD BE OUR APPROACH HERE AND THAT WOULD BE CONTROLLING THE GROUNDWATER IN THE PROPERTY, PREVENTING ITS USE AS WELL AS CAPPING THE SITE, TOO. MAKE SURE THAT CONTAMINATED SOILS ARE NOT EXPOSED. PEOPLE WILL NOT BE EXPOSED TO ANY OF THOSE CONTAMINANTS THAT LIMIT YOUR USE. ON THE PROPERTY. AH IT WOULD. AND I'M SORRY. I THINK WE MIGHT BE GOING. I THINK MR MAYOR MENTIONED WE MIGHT BE GOING WITH THE LANDINGS RESTRICTION OPTION. SO IN THAT CASE THE RISK MANAGEMENT OPTION TWO DOES NOT LIMIT YOUR USE IS YOU CAN PUT WHATEVER YOU LIKE THERE AS LONG AS PREDICTED BY ADEQUATE ENGINEERING CONTROL, SO LEVEL THREE WHERE YOU PLACE THOSE ENGINEERING CONTROLS, AND YOU DO THAT HAVE THAT LANDED RESTRICTION, SO WE'RE GOING FOR THAT LAND USE RESTRICTION HERE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TWO AND THREE BEYOND WHAT YOU'RE RESTRICTED FROM DOING IN TERMS OF THE ACTUAL CLEANUP. THE MAJOR DIFFERENCE IS THE LAND USE RESTRICTION THAT IS PLACED ON THE PROPERTY BECAUSE CONTAMINATION IS NOT REDUCED TO THE LEVEL APPROPRIATE FOR RESIDENTIAL USE. THE SOILS ON THE PROPERTY CAN HAVE CONTAMINANTS UP TO THE COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL LEVEL , WHICH IS DETERMINED BY THE STATE BASED ON THE RISK OF ENCOUNTERING ANY OF THAT CONTAMINATION. BASED ON A TYPICAL PERSON OUT OF BUSINESS VERSUS A TYPICAL PERSON AT THEIR HOME, AND IT'S COST PROHIBITIVE FOR YOU TO HAVE IT TO LEVEL TOO COST PROHIBITIVE TO GO TO LEVEL ONE, LEVEL TWO AND LEVEL THREE.

WE COULD DO EITHER OF THOSE OPTIONS BY INSTALLING THOSE ENGINEERING CONTROLS THAT IS FINE, BUT DUE TO ANY CONCERNS ABOUT POSSIBLE RESIDENTIAL USES THE PROPERTY LEVEL THREE WOULD BE THE PREFERRED OPTION JUST TO ENSURE THAT THE PROPERTY IS NOT USED FOR RESIDENTIAL UNLESS WE HAD YOU CLEAN INTO LEVEL TWO, AND THEN WE RESTRICTED WHAT WENT ON THERE. THAT'S VERY THAT'S VERY YEAH, THERE ARE THERE'S THE ABILITY TO RESTRICT THE USE THROUGH LOCAL GOVERNMENT RESOLUTION REGULATION. THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION THEY ARE OPEN TO EITHER OF THOSE THREE OPTIONS OR ANY ONE OF THOSE THREE OPTIONS, SO THAT WHICH CERTAINLY WILLING TO WORK WITH THE CITY TO MAKE SURE THAT THE REMEDIATION IS DONE IN A WAY THAT THE COMMUNITY FEELS COMFORTABLE. WHAT MECHANISM COULD WE USE TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S CLEAN TO THE HIGHEST LEVEL POSSIBLE WITHIN THAT LEVEL, TOO? UH I CAN'T SPEAK TO WHAT TOOLS THE CITY HAS AVAILABLE TO ENSURE THAT I KNOW THAT THAT THE STATE UH WE DO HAVE THE OPTION AT LEAST AS FAR AS STATE REGULATION GOES, UM BUT I CAN'T SPEAK TO WHAT THE CITY CAN DO THERE TO LIMIT THAT OR OR DEFINE WHAT RISK MANAGEMENT OPTION IS A IS APPLICABLE HERE. AND DO WE HAVE ANY SORRY? DO WE HAVE ANY PLANS TO LIMIT IT? IN THE PIPELINE TO INDUSTRIAL OR COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT SIDE.

ONCE THEY'RE DONE, AND THEY COME BACK, YOU HAVE TO FOLLOW THE STANDARD DEVELOPMENT PROCESS, SO THIS PARTICULAR PROCESS IS GOING TO NEED A FUTURE LAND USE ASSIGNMENT AND ZONING ASSIGNMENTS ABOUT SOMETHING THAT YOU HAVE DECISION OVER. THAT'S THE QUESTION FISHER COUNTRY DID.

YES COMMISSIONER CLARK. THANK YOU. I'M NOT SURE. UM MR CITY MANAGER OR OR OR ATTORNEY WHEN

[02:20:08]

WE WERE LOOKING AT THIS WITH MR GOLDSTEIN BEFORE. I KNOW THAT THAT GENERAL AREA YOU KNOW, WE'VE HAD THE MARTIN COUNTY HIGH SCHOOL, WHICH IS ACROSS THE OTHER SIDE OF THE ROAD AND, OF COURSE, MORE MORE RECENTLY, ALTHOUGH IT'S NOT THAT RECENT IS PROBABLY 20 YEARS OR MORE WITH THE BUILDING OF THE SHERIFF DEPARTMENT, AND SO ON. HAVE WE EVER LOOKED AT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THIS 50 ACRES WHICH IS STILL WITH WHERE WE ARE. WE SAW THE GOLF COURSE HERE. NOW WE HAVE THE. THE FUNERAL HOME AND THE NORTH SIDE AND THEN WE HAVE THIS LARGE, EMPTY SPACE THERE. I MEAN, AS FAR AS PLUMES AND UH, HOW THINGS TRAVEL UNDERGROUND. I THINK THE PLACE WHERE THE COUNTY BUILT THE SHERIFF DEPARTMENT. I'M NOT SURE HOW MUCH DIFFERENT OR DISTINCTIVE THIS PARTICULAR SITE IS FROM THAT OR WHAT THEY WENT THROUGH. UM OR IF THERE'S SOMETHING I HEARD THAT THERE WAS A PLUME THAT HAD TRAVELED ALL THE WAY OVER TO EVEN WERE THE HIGH SCHOOL REBUILD SOME THINGS IN THE PAST. I'M NOT SURE LET ME BE VERY CLEAR THAT THERE HAS BEEN NO PLUME OF THE CITY'S TRAVELING ANYWHERE. THERE'S NOTHING BUT I KNOW THAT THERE'S BEEN PEOPLE ALWAYS SAY THAT THEY'RE NOT EVEN PACKING THEIR BAGS GOING. OKAY SO THE LANDFILL I KNOW THAT THERE'S BEEN LANDFILL ISSUES. THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE PROPERTY DOES NOT HAVE THE ACTUAL TRASH. OKAY YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT PLUME. YOU'RE TALKING MOSTLY ABOUT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT WATER. OKAY, MOVEMENT. SO THIS THIS PIECE OF PROPERTY THAT WERE UNDER CONTRACT WITH THEM WITH HIS ACTUALLY, YOU KNOW, TRASH THERE. THERE'S MEDICAL THERE AND THERE'S NON MEDICAL THERE. SO THAT THAT'S A PRIMARY. THE PLUME AND WATER REALLY IS AFFECTIVE. THERE'S A THERE'S THE PEOPLE WAS AND THERE'S ANOTHER CHEMICAL THAT HAVE BEEN SEEN IN SOMETHING ELSE. BUT THE THOSE ARE, YOU KNOW, REMEDIAL ATION ACTION BY BY THE ORGANIZATION, BUT THERE'S NOTHING THAT IS OUT BY THE HIGH SCHOOL OR ANY PLACE TO MAKE SURE THAT BECAUSE I GET PEOPLE TALKING ABOUT IT ALL THE TIME.

IT'S USED TO BE A DUMP, AND THEY USED. MY WIFE THINKS THAT THE MARTIN COUNTY HIGH SCHOOL WAS WHERE THE WHERE THE LAST LITTLE WAS SAID THAT IT'S NOT BUT SHE WAS MY WIFE IS FROM HERE. SHE WAS THERE BEFORE THE HIGH SCHOOL INSTALLMENTS, THE HIGH SCHOOL AND THE COSTCO LIKE PROPERTY.

CANTOR CPU D, HISTORICALLY FROM PEOPLE THAT I HAVE TALKED TO HAVE HAVE SAID THAT THAT WAS A DUMPING SITE LIKE IT WASN'T OFFICIAL. IT WAS GARBAGE DUMP. IT WAS A IT WAS OUT OF TOWN.

YEAH YEAH. YES IT WAS LITERALLY A SIGN OF DIXIE HIGHWAY WHERE YOU DROP YOUR VOLKSWAGEN OFF AFTER STOPS WORKING. AND BURY IT , THE CURRENT THE CURRENT FUTURE LAND USE ON THE PROPERTY IS PUBLIC. SO TECHNICALLY OTHER THAN A PARK, THERE IS NO OTHER USE AVAILABLE OTHER THAN YOU KNOW, I GUESS THE GOVERNMENT BUT FOR NO MATTER WHAT HAPPENS, THEY WILL HAVE TO COME BACK BEFORE THE COMMISSION AND GET A FUTURE LAND USE ASSIGNMENT BEFORE IT CAN BE USED FOR ANY INSTITUTION OR INDUSTRIAL COMMERCIAL. WHATEVER YOU SO THE COMMISSION HAS RESTRAINTS AND HAS THE ABILITY TO ASSIGN WHAT IT DEEMS TO BE THE MOST APPROPRIATE LAND USE FOR THAT AREA, AND I THINK YOU'RE PROBABLY GOING TO BE IT MADE IT VERY CLEAR TO ME DURING THE DISCUSSIONS WITH THEM THAT THE LIKELIHOOD THAT IT WOULD EVER BE CLEANED TO A LEVEL THAT WOULD ALLOW FOR RESIDENTIAL USE.

WAS WAS OFF THE SCALES. I DIDN'T GET THE IMPRESSION THAT THAT WAS GOING TO BE THE CASE, BUT YOU KNOW YOU COULD SPEAK TO THEM IN THE MAP. YOU'LL SEE THE MAP. THERE'S CERTAIN SECTIONS LIKE WHATEVER THREE ACRE PARCEL OR WHATEVER, BEHIND THE FUNERAL HOME NOW THAT WE'LL BE CARVED OFF AND WILL RETAIN TO USE FOR VEGETATION. UH, PROGRAM. WE CURRENTLY DO THAT NOW, BUT A DIFFERENT PART OF THAT SITE, AND THERE WAS ALSO, UM, WE'RE KEEPING THE ANTENNA. IT'S NOT ON THE MAP, BUT THERE WAS ALSO AN AGREEMENT DURING THE CONTRACT PART ABOUT YOU KNOW WHAT I CALL IT? ART FOREST GREEN SPACE, BASICALLY, REPLANTING OF TREES AND STUFF ALONG THAT ON THE DEBRIS IS LIKE A MULCH PILE TYPE THING. IT'S INTERESTING. YEAH, WE DO OUR MULCHING OUT THERE FOR ESSENTIALLY WHEN WE DO HAVE A YARD PICKUP GOES THERE FIRST TO GROW FOOD. I LOVE WHAT YOU'RE SAYING. I NEED MUCH SEPARATE FIVE ACRES. THAT'S A PARK THAT'S GOING TO BE GREEN SPACE AND A RE PLANTING OR REFORESTATION. IT WILL NOT BE A PARK THAT ENDS UP BEING OPEN TO THE PUBLIC BECAUSE THE CLEANUP WON'T ALLOW. I MEAN , IF IT'S ONLY A FIVE ACRE OUT OF THE 50 YEARS OF POSSIBLE TO ASK OR REQUIRE WHATEVER MECHANISM WE CAN DO TO HAVE THAT BE CLEAN TO A LEVEL THAT PEOPLE CAN USE IT AS A PART RIGHT? WE'RE OPEN TO DISCUSSION WITH THE CITY ON THAT. I WOULD BE HAPPY TO REACH OUT AND SPEAK MORE ON THAT. AND THAT WOULD HAPPEN. WE START TALKING ABOUT LAND USE OR WHAT? THEY'RE PROBABLY DOING THIS PROCESS ALSO DURING THEIR CLEANUP PROCESS

[02:25:02]

WHEN THEY BECAUSE ONE OF THE ONE OF THE REASONS WHY THERE'S SUCH A LONG DUE DILIGENCE IS BECAUSE THEY'RE DOING BORING SAMPLES, AND THERE'S ALSO THERE'S A LOT OF THERE'S A LOT OF MOVING PARTS. JUST TO FIND OUT WHAT THE CLEANUP WILL TAKE BECAUSE TO DETERMINE CLEAN UP AND THEN THEY NEED TO QUALIFY THE GRANTS AND TAX CREDITS TO DO THAT CLEANUP AND DEPENDING WHAT THE QUALIFIED FOREIGN THE LEVEL OF CLEAN UP THAT THEY CAN DO BASED UPON THE MONEY THEY RECEIVED, DIRECTS EXACTLY WHAT THEY'RE GOING TO DO YOU GUYS WOULD BE WILLING TO TAKE MR BREMER COMMISSIONER COLLINS ALREADY HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO ASK QUESTIONS AND I HAVE NOT, AND BEFORE HE IS ALLOWED TO CONTINUE HIS LIFE, BUT HE DID CALL ON HIM AND I HAVEN'T SEEN YOU. YOU KNOW, I HAVEN'T SEEN YOU RAISE YOUR HAND BABY HAVE BUT I JUST HAVEN'T SEEN IT, BUT WE'LL GET TO YOU SURE, DON'T WORRY. BUT YOU WOULD BE WILLING TO CARVE OUT OUT OF THAT FIVE ACRES. MAYBE THE CLEANER PART. THE LESS CONTAMINATED AREA AND BRING IT TO A LEVEL TO HAVE IT BE A PARK THAT'S ACCESSIBLE AND WE'RE HAPPY TO DISCUSS THAT, BECAUSE, AS I MENTIONED, WE'RE NOT SURE THE EXACT LOCATION YET THERE'S STILL A LOT OF WORK THAT NEEDS TO GO INTO THE PLANNING, BUT IT'S DEFINITELY SOMETHING WE'RE HAPPY TO DISCUSS. YES, SIR. MR RICH. UM SO THE CLOCK IS STARTED TICKING CORRECT ON THE 270 DAYS. THE CLOCK ON THE ON THE CONTRACT SIDE OF THE FEASIBILITY STUDY.

PERIOD YES, YES, SIR. I BELIEVE IT EXPIRES IN MARCH. MARCH 2023 SO YOU HAVE VERY FEW DAYS LEFT.

REALLY? I THOUGHT IT WAS NEAR HALF DO WE HAVE ANY IDEA HOW MANY DAYS ARE LEFT, THEN? I DON'T. SO THE MAYOR INDICATED THAT 270 DAYS WAS SO YOU HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO DRILL CORE SAMPLES. HAVE YOU IN FACT, DRILLED ANY CORE SAMPLES YOURSELF? I AM NOT AWARE OF.

WE'VE DRILLED ANY CORE SAMPLES. WE RELIED A LOT ON PUBLIC DATA AND DATA ARTISTS SUBMITTED TO THE STATE THAT'S PUBLICLY AVAILABLE. AND I'M ALSO JOINED BY REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE CONTRACT PURCHASER, MR KELLY CLAYTON AND COLD COAST. UM THEY MAY KNOW BETTER THAN I HAVE EVER DONE ANY INVASIVE SAMPLING THERE YET. YES, PLEASE. KELLY KITE BEACH, FLORIDA 2055. U. S ONE.

UM ON THE LESSER HALF OF GOLDSTEIN KITE ENVIRONMENTAL? UM, BUT AS FAR AS CORE SAMPLES, NO, WE HAVE NOT DRILLED THEM. WE'VE DONE FOR SURVEYS. PHASE ONE TESTING. SO FAR, WE'VE PROBABLY SPENT THE WATER ABOUT $50,000 OR DUE DILIGENCE AND SECOND PHASE. WE'RE GOING TO GO UNDER GEOTECHNICAL TESTING. UM WILL BE DOING OUR PHASE TWO TESTING SO BUT LOOKING AT YOU KNOW, THE IMPACTS OF THE GROUND WAS SERVING HOW WE CAN DEVELOP THE SITE. TO THE EXTENT THAT THERE'S YOU KNOW. GAPS UNDERNEATH THE GROUND THAT MIGHT NEED TO BE COMPACTED SOIL REMOVED VERY, VERY EARLY IN THE PROCESS TO BE ABLE TO DETERMINE WHICH CONTAMINATION EXACTLY WHERE WHICH IS GEO, TECHNICALLY FEASIBLE TO DEVELOP, UM BUT THAT'S THE NEXT PHASE OF THE TESTING THAT WE'RE GETTING READY TO START. UM BUT THAT'S A PRETTY HEAVY LIFT, SO WE'LL PROBABLY HAVE ANOTHER, YOU KNOW 3 $400,000 IN JUST THE TESTING. TO EVEN GET TO A POINT WHERE WE CAN EVEN START TALKING ABOUT THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN. IN FACT, YOU'RE RELYING ON THE TESTING THAT THE CITY DID IN 2018. IS THAT CORRECT? THAT'S PRIMARILY AT THIS POINT IN TERMS OF CORE SAMPLES. HISTORICAL DATA UP TO THIS POINT, YES. SO WHAT? WHAT DATE? IS IT IN MARCH? I MEAN, FEBRUARY 13TH, IS IT MARCH? 1ST IS IT ARE WE NOT? MARCH 15TH? I DON'T HAVE A CONTRACT IN FRONT OF ME. SO LIKE RIGHT, SO30 DAYS. AND WE'RE DEALING WITH SOME MATERIALS WERE THE ACCEPTABLE STANDARD IS ONE PART PER MILLION , AND IN SOME CASES, 10.4. PARTS PER BILLION. IS THAT CORRECT? THAT'S ABSOLUTELY CORRECT. AND THAT MOSTLY COMES DOWN TO WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT PARTS OF THAT LEVEL. PREFER MP FOSS. THAT'S BOTH ON OUR SITE AND THE FIRE DEPARTMENT SITE NEXT DOOR.

AND IF DURING YOUR DUE DILIGENCE YOU FIND THAT. THE EFFORT REQUIRED TO BRING IT TO THE LEVEL YOU'RE SEEKING. TO LEVEL TWO IS TOO MUCH THAT YOU CAN TERMINATE THE CONTRACT. THAT'S CORRECT. OKAY. THANK YOU. OKAY. DO YOU HAVE ANY EMOTIONS? I. IF THEY'RE NOT THE QUESTION. WERE YOU GOING TO MAKE A MOTION? MR RICHARD ALL MAKE A MOTION REGARDING RESOLUTION NUMBER 09 2023. WITH REGARD TO THIS PROPERTY LOCATED ON MONTEREY ROAD. THAT WE APPROVED THE STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND. MOVE FORWARD IN IN THIS PSALM GREEN REUSE AREA PLAN. AND CONTRACT WITH THE

[02:30:02]

CURRENT PERSON COMMENT, MR MAX SECOND. YEAH I GOT YOUR CARD RIGHT HERE. WE HAVE A MOTION.

FIRST WE GET THE MOTION. WE'LL GET TO YOU. DON'T WORRY. OKAY. WE HAVE A MOTION BY COMMISSIONER CLARK, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER BRUNER. GO AHEAD AND GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT. MR. IS IT REESE? IS IT, OTIS. OKAY. OATS WELCOME. HI MY NAME IS OWED. SSRIS STILL RESIDENT AT 900 NORTHWEST WATERLILY PLACE, ALSO CIVIL ENGINEER WITH THE LOCAL FIRM BOWMAN CONSULTING. PREVIOUSLY CREATURE ENGINEERS, PHOTOGRAPHERS DAD FOR MANY YEARS. I MEAN, I'M SPEAKING HERE MYSELF. I CAN'T REMEMBER IF YOU'RE GOING THROUGH. UM AND I'VE HAD SOME EXPERIENCE WORKING WITH BROWNFIELD. PROJECTS AND RECLAMATION UNDERSTAND THE PROCESS, BUT REALLY, I'M HERE TO TALK ABOUT MY JOB AS A VOLUNTEER. AFTER HOURS. MY WIFE AND I RUN A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION CALLED TENT CITY HELPERS. WE CATER TO THE. HOMELESS PEOPLE IN MARTIN COUNTY AND SEE YOUR STEWART. AND PROBABLY ON A YEARLY BASIS. WE SERVED. 2 300 HOMELESS PEOPLE THAT LIVE IN THIS AREA. AND ORGANIZATIONS LIKE SAFE SPACES ARE GREAT. WE HAVE SOME OF THE WOMEN THAT WE SEE THAT HAVE BEEN THROUGH THEIR ORGANIZATION AND COME OUT THE OTHER END MUCH BETTER OFF. BUT REALLY, FOR A LOT OF OUR HOMELESS PEOPLE, MAN , THE VETERANS THAT WE HONOR TODAY. THERE IS NO LEGAL PLACE FOR THEM TO STAY. IF YOU DON'T YOU CAN'T AFFORD A $2000.01 BEDROOM APARTMENT, WHICH IS WHAT PARENTS NOW. IN CITY STEWART. THERE'S NO PLACE FOR YOU TO LEGALLY STAY. SPEND A NIGHT IN ON A PARK BENCH. ARE YOU FIND YOURSELF PITCHING A TENT IN THE SWAMP. HANEY CREEK. UM. OR EVEN ON A WOODED PRIVATE PROPERTY. YOU'LL GET A TRESPASSING THOSE AT ONE POINT AND THEN THE SECOND TIME YOU GO TO JAIL AT THAT POINT, ALL YOUR BELONGINGS GET TAKEN AWAY. YOU COME BACK WITH NOTHING AND YOU START THE PROCESS AGAIN. WE'VE BEEN LOOKING NOW FOR A WHILE. TO IDENTIFY. THEY CAN PROPERTIES. THAT WOULD BE AVAILABLE FOR A CAMPGROUND OF SOME SORT FOR THE HOMELESS PEOPLE SOMEWHERE THAT'S LEGAL FOR THEM TO GO. WE'RE NOT GONNA BE KICKED OUT. KIND OF ALL THEIR BELONGINGS TAKEN. WE GET PHONE CALLS WEEKLY PEOPLE. GOING TO WORK AND THEY PITCHED A TENT AND THERE'S NOWHERE MAN CAN. THERE IS NO SHELTERS, MARIN COUNTY OTHER THAN IF THERE'S A HURRICANE TO OPEN UP A SHELTER. BECAUSE OF FREEZING OPEN UP A SHELTER OVERNIGHT. THERE'S REALLY NO PLACE FOR THE HOMELESS HERE IN MARTIN COUNTY. AND SERIOUSLY, STEWART. I DON'T THINK THERE'S EVEN A CODE ALLOWANCE THAT ALLOWS US TO A PRIVATE OWNER TO TAKE HIS PROPERTY AND OPEN UP A CAMP FOR HOMELESS PEOPLE. THAT LANDFILL PROPERTY HAS ALWAYS BEEN ON OUR RADAR. IT'S BEEN VACANT FOR A LONG TIME. UNDERSTAND THE ISSUES WITH THE ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES OUT THERE, BUT IF THERE IS NO OPPORTUNITY TO CARVE OUT A LITTLE PIECE OF THAT DOESN'T MEAN A LOT TO ESTABLISH A CAMPGROUND. I MEAN, ONE OF THE CONDITIONS THAT THEY BROWNFIELDS TO HAVE SPACE FOR RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE. SUCH LIKE A CAMPING GROUND. WE'RE ALL WE NEED IS A RESTROOM AND MAYBE SOME COOKING FACILITIES. WE CAN'T HOUSE A FEW HOMELESS PEOPLE IN THE CIA. STEWART RIGHT NOW WE HAVE NO PLACE TO HOUSE THEM. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT ENGINEERING CONTROLS. SOMETHING SIMPLE TO PETER. FILL ON. THAT WOULD BE AN ENGINEERING CONTROL THAT WOULD ALLOW SOMEONE TO LIVE THERE. UNDER THE ASKS OF THE CITY WITHOUT BEING HARASSED. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU WANTED TO ASK, UH, OTIS, OR YOU MARRIED TO GAIL? THAT'S MY WIFE. 30 YEARS? YES. YEAH I READ THE AWESOME THINGS THAT YOU DO, AND HER HUMMINGBIRDS FROM ONE OF THE HOMELESS. YES GET HUMMINGBIRDS. AND NOW SHE WOULD BE HERE TONIGHT, BUT SHE'S MEETING HER CLIENTS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THERE'S A ANOTHER 500,000.

THAT'S RIGHT. CLAIMED YOU GET YOUR APPLICATION AND YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO BUILD A SHELTER. IT'S JUST ME AND MY WIFE, SO WE DON'T HAVE THAT ABILITY. BUT IF YOU KNOW IF THE CITY CAN USE THAT MONEY TO WELL, IT'S FOR GROUPS. IT'S THAT'S AVAILABLE. THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING. YOU CAN PUT IN AN APPLICATION. OKAY THANK YOU FOR THANK YOU VERY MUCH. OKAY, WE HAVE EMOTION, AND WE HAVE A SECOND ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT IN THE TITLE. VERY DONE. WHAT YOU CALL THE ROLL, PLEASE.

COMMISSIONER RICH YES, VICE MAYOR BRUNA. YES COMMISSIONER CLARK? YES. MCDONALD'S

[02:35:03]

COMMISSIONER COLLINS. YES. OKAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. OKAY LET'S MOVE ON TO ITEM NUMBER 12, I

[12. EAST STUART HISTORICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE (RC): RESOLUTION No. 11-2023; A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, RATIFYING AND REINSTATING THE EAST STUART HISTORICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE; MAKING FINDINGS OF NECESSITY; APPROVING BY-LAWS; PROVIDNG FOR CONFLICTS; SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.]

BELIEVE ARE EAST STEWART HISTORICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE. MIKE WOULD YOU READ THE RESOLUTION TITLE? THIS IS RESOLUTION NUMBER 11-20 TO 3 IS A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, RATIFYING AND REINSTATING THE EAST STEWART HISTORICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE MAKING FINDINGS OF NECESSITY, APPROVING BYLAWS. PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT SEVERABILITY AND INEFFECTIVE DATE. UM I'LL BE HAPPY TO DISCUSS THE ITEM BECAUSE FOLLOWING THE WORKSHOP OR I BELIEVE IT WAS A WORKSHOP. OR THE JOINT MEETING. I MEAN, THE CITY MANAGER. ASKED ME TO PUT TOGETHER THE BYLAWS AND THIS RESOLUTION BASED UPON THE DIRECTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION. I WASN'T. SPECIFICALLY SURE. WHAT? UM. THE COMMISSION HAD IN MIND FOR THE ROLE OF THE COMMITTEE IT HAD SERVED. ON BEHALF OF THE CR ORIGINALLY AS A ADVISORY BOARD TO PROVIDE HISTORICAL DATA TO THE SIERRA DIRECTOR WHEN PUTTING TOGETHER THE ORIGINAL PROPOSAL FOR THE 10 STREET REC CENTER. AND AS A RESULT, YOU HAD HEARD A REQUEST. TO CONTINUE THE BOARD. MY RECOMMENDED BYLAWS THAT I PRESENTED TO YOU TONIGHT WHERE THAT THE BOARD WOULD MEET. FOUR TIMES A YEAR OR AS NECESSARY, MEANING QUARTERLY. AND THEN IF THERE WAS ACTUALLY A PROJECT, MAYBE MORE OR OR ACCORDINGLY. BECAUSE IT WAS A C R A BOARD ESSENTIALLY BECAUSE IT WAS RECOMMENDING EAST STEWART HISTORICAL ISSUES RELATED TO THE C R. A I PROPOSE THAT THE BYLAWS MADE UP AND THAT THE BOARD BE APPOINTED BY THE SEVEN C R A MEMBERS EACH APPOINTING ONE REPRESENTATIVE TO THAT BOARD. I RESTRICTED THE LIMITATIONS. UM TO I THINK THE SAME AS KIND OF THE L P A. AND THAT IS THAT YOU HAVE TO EITHER LIVE OR WORK IN THE CITY OF STEWART. UM I DID NOT LIMITED TO EAST STEWART AND THE REASON WHY WAS BECAUSE THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT ARE FROM E. STEWART THAT DON'T STILL LIVE IN EAST STEWART, OR THAT HAVE RELATIONSHIPS WITH EAST STUART THAT DON'T NECESSARILY MEAN THEY LIVE IN EAST STEWART, BUT THAT COULD PROVIDE A LOT OF INFORMATION AND HELP AND WHAT I THOUGHT IS THAT THE SEVEN MEMBERS THAT THE COMMISSION OR THE BOARD MEMBERS OF THE SIERRA THEY WOULD. OBVIOUSLY THEIR PERSONAL APPOINTEE WOULD BE SOMEONE THAT THEY KNEW WOULD BENEFIT THAT. THAT HISTORICAL DATA OR SOMEBODY THAT WOULD BE ABLE TO CONTRIBUTE TO IT. I JUST POINT THAT OUT BECAUSE THERE WAS NO BASIS FOR THE APPOINTMENT PROCESS. I WAS JUST TRYING TO PUT SOMETHING TOGETHER FOR YOU GUYS. JERRY BE MY APPOINTEE. HE IS ALREADY ASKING FOR APPOINTEES . NONE OF THIS COUNTS. THERE'S NO THERE'S NO, THEY HAVEN'T VOTED ON IT YET. THE BOARD DOESN'T EXIST YET, YOU KNOW. MM OKAY. SO DO WE HAVE ANY COMMENTS OR EMOTIONS OR ANYTHING FROM THE COMMISSION COMMENTS? COMMISSIONER? I READ IT AND MIKE. THANK YOU FOR WATCHING PREPARED. AND I HAD ASKED, UH, WANTED THIS. AND I'M SO GLAD THAT, MISS UM MISS FAY JAMES HAD SAID HAD WHEN SHE HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO COME UP AND SPEAK. WE WOULD ASK THEM TO COME AND SPEAK THAT DAY WHEN THEY COMMITTEE WAS GOING TO BE DISBANDED AND SHE CAME UP AND SHE SPOKE, AND I HAD THE SAME IDEA AND TALK TO TALK TO THE CITY MANAGER ABOUT IT. BUT THE THING IS THAT AND I, MIKE, I COMPLETELY UNDERSTAND BECAUSE SOME OF THE PEOPLE WHO ARE ON THE COMMITTEE OR WHO ATTENDED THOSE MEETINGS AND WE HAD TO PUSH BACK EVERYTHING IN ORDER TO MAKE SURE WE HAVE GOOD COMMUNITY INPUT THROUGH THE C R A PROCESS AND PANEL WAS VERY INSTRUMENTAL IN WORKING WITH THAT SOME OF THOSE PEOPLE HAVE RELATIVES OR GREW UP IN THE AREA WHERE THEY DON'T NECESSARILY LIVE RIGHT THERE IN EAST STEWART, SO IT'S GOOD THAT WE KEEP IT THAT WAY. BUT WE ALSO NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT WHEN WE APPOINT SOMEBODY THAT SOMEBODY WHO'S GOING TO HAVE THE BEST INTEREST OF THAT COMMUNITY BECAUSE THE WHOLE PART OF IT IS THE EAST STEWART ADVISORY COMMITTEE. THE ONE THING THAT I WOULD ASK FOR THIS BOARD TO THINK ABOUT IT, THE CITY COMMISSION NOT NECESSARILY AS A C R A BECAUSE WE'RE NOT MEETING AS A CRE AT THIS POINT. IS THAT IF WE'RE GOING TO BE APPROVING THIS OR UNLESS IT'S GOING TO BE EVERYTHING HAS TO GO TO THE C R A IN ORDER TO DO THEM NOT SURE WHAT THE PROCESSES MIGHT BECAUSE IT'S HERE FOR US AS A CITY COMMISSION, I GUESS TO CREATE THIS ADVISORY BOARD, BUT THE APPOINTMENT WOULD IT BE FROM THE CITY COMMISSION PERSPECTIVE, OR WOULD IT BE FROM A CRE? MEMBER PERSPECTIVE, BUT I'LL LEAVE THAT. THAT'S JUST A

[02:40:06]

QUESTION. OK FROM THE CRE. OKAY I THOUGHT THAT WOULD BE IT. THE THING IS THAT BECAUSE I UNDERSTAND THE NATURE AND I WAS AWARE WHEN PANEL WAS HAVING THESE MEETINGS, SOMETIMES PEOPLE DIDN'T COME TO MEETINGS. IT'S NOT A FORCE MEETING. IT'S NOT A BOARD WHERE YOU HAVE TO COME TO THE BOARD MEETING AND IF YOU DON'T COME, YOU'RE GOING TO BE THAT'S PUNISHED OR SOMETHING.

I'M NOT GOING TO SAY ANYTHING BECAUSE I DON'T WANT TO BLOW UP ANYTHING. OKAY BUT YOU'RE GONNA BE PUNISHED. IT'S NOT ANYTHING LIKE THAT. BUT AT THE SAME TIME , I WOULD SUGGEST THAT EITHER WE AGREE TO HAVE SOMETHING LIKE AND THIS IS KIND OF TOUGH BECAUSE SOMETIMES WE HAVE GET PEOPLE HARD TO PARTICIPATE. TO EITHER HAVE NINE MEMBERS, OR AT LEAST HAVE THE SEVEN MEMBERS AS SUGGESTED. BUT HAVE AT LEAST 2 TO 4. UM ALTERNATE MEMBERS SO THAT WE CAN REALLY HAVE SOME CONTINUITY AND WE CAN HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE ACTIVELY ENGAGE. AND IF SOMEBODY IS NOT COMMON, OR IS THAT GOING TO BE PARTICIPATING IN THE MEETING THAT WE MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S ENOUGH PEOPLE THERE PARTICIPATE IN AN ADVISORY CAPACITY. OTHERWISE WE'RE GOING TO BE HAVING THREE PEOPLE WHO MAY BE AVAILABLE IN THE MONTH OF JULY, BUT FOUR PEOPLE IN SEPTEMBER AND WE THE YEAR GOES BY AND WE JUST HAVE A MISHMASH OF, UM ATTENDANCE AND PARTICIPATION, SO I WANTED TO EITHER EXTENDED TO HAVE ENOUGH PEOPLE WHERE WE CAN HAVE GOOD CONVERSATIONS AMONG A REASONABLE NUMBER OF PEOPLE OR IF WE KEEP IT AT SEVEN THAT WE AT LEAST HAVE 2 TO 4 PEOPLE IN THE ALTERNATE POSITIONS SO THAT WE KNOW THAT THOSE PEOPLE ARE THERE READY TO BE INVOLVED AND TO BECOME A PART OF IT. AND I WOULD WELCOME ANY COMMENTS FROM , UM SOMEBODY LIKE MISS JAMES, WHO HAS BEEN INVOLVED IN ONE UNDERSTANDS THE WORKINGS OF THE COMMITTEE BECAUSE SOMETIMES PEOPLE HAVE THEIR NAME ON THE COMMITTEE, AND THEY DON'T SHOW UP TO THE MEETINGS OR THEY DON'T COME ON TIME. AND I KNOW THAT IF SHE EVER GETS INVOLVED, WE EVER GET THERE. WE IN STATED THAT IT WOULD BE SOMETHING THAT WE AT LEAST WANT TO KNOW THAT. HEY IF SUZY'S NOT COMING, WE CAN CALL JAMIE OR WHATEVER. UM I JUST THINK IT'S SO IMPORTANT TO HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE INVOLVEMENT SO THAT WE DON'T HAVE LESS INVOLVEMENT. WHEN UM PEOPLE DON'T ARE NOT AVAILABLE. THAT'S THAT'S MY THING. SO I DON'T KNOW IF WE NEED IF I WERE GOING TO MAKE A MOTION AND MAKE A MOTION, AND IF IT FALLS, IT FALLS, BUT WE APPROVED THE RESOLUTION. 11 2023 WITH EITHER THE. SEVEN OR NINE MEMBERS OR SEVEN MEMBERS WITH AT LEAST I'D SAY THREE ALTERNATES, UM, AVAILABLE TO SPECIFIC MOTION. OKAY I'M JUST SAYING I'M PUTTING IT OUT THERE FOR DISCUSSIONS. SO, YEAH, UH, I UNDERSTAND. I WANTED TO PARTICIPATION, BUT I THINK I THINK THAT AND I UNDERSTAND YOUR GOAL. BUT I DO THINK THAT IF WE GO WITH LIKE A SYSTEM WITH ALTERNATES YOU KNOW THE ALTERNATES. IF YOU KNOW THEY ARE PROBABLY NOT GOING TO BE SHOWING UP UNLESS THEY'RE CALLED AND ASKED TO SHOW UP, SO THEN THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE PARTICIPATING. NOT GONNA BE READY. YEAH, THEY'RE NOT GONNA HAVE THAT CONTINUITY OF EACH MEETING WON'T EVEN KNOW THE MEETING. IT'S LIKE IF SOMEBODY CALLED IT A BIG NUMBER, THEN I THINK WE SHOULD MAKE IT. NINE PEOPLE THINK SEVEN IS PLENTY. BY THE WAY. I DON'T JUST FOR WHAT? IT'S YOU GUYS CAN MAKE IT AS MANY AS YOU WANT. BUT IF YOU'RE GOING TO MAKE IT MORE, I WOULD ALSO ASK YOU WHO THE APPOINT, LIKE RIGHT NOW IT'S EACH MEMBER OF THE SIERRA HAS ONE APPOINTMENT. THERE'S EXTRAS JUST GIVE ME WHO'S GOING TO BE THOSE POINTERS LIKE THE CITY MANAGER GOING TO MAKE IT AS A DIRECTOR, OR WHATEVER I THINK WITH THE SEVEN IS A GOOD STRONG NUMBER I REALLY DO. AND THE REASON I SAY THAT IT'S JUST, UH IS THAT WE START GETTING MORE PEOPLE THAN JUST MORE PEOPLE THAT THEN WE NEED MORE PEOPLE FOR A QUARREL. THEY NEED MORE PEOPLE FOR YOU. I JUST THINK YOU KNOW MY REASON WHY I'M SAYING THIS BECAUSE I JUST KNOW THAT SOMETIMES WE GET REALLY BUGGED ON WITH LACK OF PARTICIPATION, AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO HAVE PEOPLE THERE IT IS TRUE PATE BOARD MEMBERS PEOPLE CAN COME AND I THINK THAT AND I THINK THAT THE BETTER BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT BOARD THE MORE MEMBERS WE HAD UNLESS PEOPLE WERE TO SHOW UP, SO THAT'S THAT'S WHAT I JUST SEE THAT ALL THE TIME AND I THINK THAT I'D RATHER HAVE A SMALL GROUP OF DEDICATED PEOPLE THAT A LARGE GROUP OR A LARGER GROUP OF PEOPLE, I THINK THAT YOU'LL HAVE A BETTER OUTCOME. I UNDERSTAND YOUR GOAL BECAUSE IT IS. IT'S A CHALLENGE. JUST GETTING, YOU KNOW, GETTING OUR APPOINTEES FOR THE DIFFERENT BOARDS THAT WE HAVE TO CONSISTENTLY SHOW UP AS A CHALLENGE, AND I THINK THAT AND DO WE HAVE IN THERE THAT IF THEY MISSED THREE, LIKE THREE MEETINGS THAT I DON'T I THINK THAT I DIDN'T DO THAT. I MEAN, WE CAN. I DON'T KNOW THAT I IT'S NOT NECESSARY. THAT'S FOR THIS

[02:45:07]

COMMITTEE THIS ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOUR TIMES A YEAR, AND ESPECIALLY FOR THE PROJECT RANGE. IT'S NOT. IT'S NOT NECESSARY, BUT, UM UH, I DON'T KNOW. I MEAN, I THINK, MISS MISS JAMES AND MISS, UM GANDHI SERVICE OR THE TWO PEOPLE WHO KNOW THE NATURE OF ESPECIALLY HOW THIS COMMITTEE WORK TOGETHER OR WORKED IF IT WORKED, AND THEY . MAYBE AS LONG AS PEOPLE ARE NOTIFIED AND ASK AND REMINDED, WILL HAVE PARTICIPATION AND AS LONG AS THERE'S ACTIVITY GOING ON FOR THEM TO BE INVOLVED WITH SOMETHING TO MAKE TO HELP PROVIDE INFORMATION AND INPUT, IT WILL BE FINE. SO WELL, I DO KNOW THAT THE CLERK HAS BEEN VERY ACTIVE RECENTLY IN GIVING THE BOARD UH, LIKE THE ATTENDANCE OF PEOPLE THAT ARE NOT COMING IN COMING, SO YOU'LL KNOW IF YOU'RE A BOARD MEMBER OR YOUR APPOINTEE IS NOT COMING, AND I DID IT THE SAME WAY AS THE OTHER BOARDS THAT IT'S JUST A ONE YEAR APPOINTMENT. WE'RE GOING TO DO REORG EATING EVERY DECEMBER AND IF YOU'RE A MEMBER DOESN'T GO, OBVIOUSLY. YOU CAN ADDRESS IT WITH THEM DIRECTLY, BUT THE CLERK CAN NOTIFY EACH PERSON NOTIFY YOU GUYS AFTER EACH MEETING. MAYBE THIS IS A QUESTION FOR PANEL. WHAT? WHAT EXACTLY IS THIS? BOARD COMMITTEE DOING. PANEL DENISE ODYSSEY AREA DIRECTOR. CURRENTLY WE'RE WORKING ON THE DESIGNATION OF EASTERN AS HISTORIC DISTRICT, SO THERE IS A PROCESS THAT WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO GO THROUGH A CONSULTANT THAT'S HELPING WITH THAT PROCESS, SO WHEN WE'RE READY TO PRESENT WE WILL COME TO THE BOARD FIRST AND GET THEIR FEEDBACK BEFORE WE GO OUT TO THE COMMUNITY. WE'RE STILL WORKING ON THE MASTER PLAN FOR THE ARTS, ARTS AND PUBLIC PLACES FOR THE GUY DAVIS PARK. THAT'S GOING TO CONTINUE FOR THE NEXT FEW YEARS BECAUSE WE HAVE TO IDENTIFY PEOPLE THAT WE WANT TO RECOGNIZE FROM THE COMMUNITY FOR THE ART PIECES, SO THERE IS GOING TO BE SOME WORK THAT'S GOING TO COME ALONG PROJECTS. IS THERE ANY SUNSET ON THIS IS IT REALLY ISN'T BOARD. IT'S SPECIFIC TO THESE TWO PROJECTS DOES IT JUST RIGHT NOW? YES UM, IT COULD, BUT RIGHT NOW THERE'S NOT NOT HAVE ANY SUNSET AND IT IS NOT SPECIFIC TO THESE TWO. IT WILL NOT SUNSET UNTIL THE CITY COMMISSION TERMINATES TETHER IT TO END IN RESPONSE TO THE MAYOR DOES HAVE THE THREE ABSENCES LANGUAGE BECAUSE OTHERWISE IT'S THAT THAT COMMITTEE IS REVIEWING EVERY HAD HAD A SUNSET PROVISION IN IT. AND AT SUNSET. AND THAT'S WHAT HAPPENED. AND THEN MISS JAMES CAME TO THE JOINT MEETING AND SPOKE TO THE BOARD AND SAID THAT SHE WANTED THE BOARD REINSTATED IN THE COMMISSION MOVED IN UNANIMOUSLY DIRECTED US TO REINSTATE IT. NOT AGAINST THE BIRDS JUST SAYING THAT, BUT IT DIDN'T HAVE A SUNSET IN THE IN THE REINSTATEMENT, SO THE BOARD WOULD OTHER THAN THOSE TWO PROJECTS, SEE. EVERY QUARTERLY MEETINGS PROJECT THAT IS IN THE C R. A IN THE CRM HISTORIC IT'S AN EAST STEWART HISTORIC BOARD.

SO RIGHT IF THERE WAS A PROJECT IN EVAN LEAH HAD NO HISTORIC ANYTHING RELATED TO IT. THERE WOULD BE NO REASON TO CALL THEM ON TOP OF THAT. HE IS ALREADY IN OUR CODE, THE CITY OF STEWARDS, STEWARDS HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD, RIGHT. CRB IS IN EXISTENCE AS HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD. I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IS THIS. WHAT IS THIS COMMITTEE DOING DIFFERENTLY THIS YEAR? THE SECTION ONE AND ARTICLE FIVE, SAID IT IS THE INTENTION FOR THE COMMITTEE TO HOLD FOUR QUARTERLY MEETINGS DURING WHICH IT WILL GENERATE RECOMMENDATIONS RELATED TO ART AND PUBLIC PLACES CONCEPTS TO CELEBRATE AND COMMEMORATE THE HISTORY OF EAST STEWART COMMUNITY GOT IT. IF YOU WANT TO EXPAND THAT OR SHRINK FAT, I WAS KIND OF DOING THE SAME THING AND I WASN'T SURE EXACTLY WHAT THE INTENTION WAS, EITHER. THAT SOUNDS GOOD. OKAY DO YOU HAVE EMOTION? CAN I JUST SAY SOMETHING, FOR EXAMPLE? I KNOW THAT I'M PERSONALLY WORKING ON GETTING THE PLAQUE FOR THE, UM HOPEFULLY FOR MOUNT CALVARY THIS YEAR IN MAY, WHEN WE HAVE HISTORIC PRESERVATION MONTH. I HAVEN'T EVEN REALLY GONE BACK AND REVISITED THIS WITH THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION FOLKS. WHEN WE STARTED THIS A FEW YEARS AGO, WE NEVER DID GET MOUNT CALVARY IN. I THINK WE GOT ST MONICA'S SAINT PAUL. WE HAVE MOUNT CALVARY AND WE HAVE THE OLD STEWART. UM UM. IT'S BEST TO GORE'S CHURCH NOW, BUT IT WAS. WHAT WAS THE NAME OF THAT CHURCH? UM MACEDONIA BAPTIST CHURCH, AND WE NEVER DID GET A PLAQUE PUT ON THAT PROPERTY AND DISCUSS THAT WITH PASSABLE, BUT THOSE ARE THINGS THAT'S NOT EVEN SOMETHING THAT THIS COMMITTEE

[02:50:05]

HAS EVEN STARTED. SO OTHER THAN IF YOU'RE LOOKING TO TALK ABOUT TWO PROJECTS. THERE ARE LOTS OF OTHER THINGS THAT NEED TO BE DONE THE IDEA OF THE FORM BASED CODE THAT WE TALKED ABOUT THE MCCARTHY PROPERTY AND THE TAILOR PROPERTY AND SOME OF THE THINGS THAT NEED TO BE DONE. THERE'S A LOT OF WORK THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE TO GET THE PROPER INPUT WHEN THE PROPER INPUT IS REQUIRED AT DIFFERENT POINTS IN TIME, AND THIS COMMITTEE IS ESSENTIAL TO KEEP IN AND TO GET IN THAT DESIGNATION, AND TO WORKING ON SOME THINGS AND TO DEAL WITH THE NUN.

GENTRIFICATION OF EAST STEWART AND TO MAKE ENSURE THAT THAT AREA GETS DEVELOPED AND REDEVELOPED PROPERLY WITH A PROPER HISTORIC TONE, AND IT'S VERY HARD TO REALLY PUT SOME FINITE THINGS TO IT NOW, BUT I THINK IT IS. I THINK THAT, UM MISS, UH JAMES HAD HER HEART IN THE RIGHT PLACE WHEN SHE ASKED FOR THIS, AND THERE'S A LOT OF THINGS THAT PANEL DOESN'T KNOW AND HASN'T COME TO YET BECAUSE THOSE OPPORTUNITIES HAVEN'T COME YET, AND IF SHE NEEDS IT, IT'S GONNA HAPPEN. THERE MIGHT BE SOMETHING THAT WE HAVE TO READ VIEW THE WHOLE IDEA OF THE PUBLIC HOUSING IN THE AREA, WHICH I'M GOING TO BRING UP WHEN WE COME TO OUR EAST STEWART CODE. SO THERE IS ENOUGH WORK AND ENOUGH IDEAS AND PROSPECTS. FOR THIS GROUP TO WORK ON, SO THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE TO ANY OF THEY'LL AND THEY'RE NOT GOING TO, UM, TAKE UP ANY OPPORTUNITIES THAT THE CRB OR SOMEBODY ELSE HAS. THEY WILL SERVE THEIR PART AND DO A GOOD JOB IN MAKING SURE THAT OR COMMUNITY MOVE FORWARD. OKAY SO DO WE HAVE A MOTION? THERE'S A MOTION. I CAN'T SEE ANYTHING RIGHT NOW. MY BRAIN IS SOMEWHERE ELSE. RESOLUTION I'VE MADE IT YET. BUT THANKS FOR THE SECOND RESOLUTION NUMBER 11-2023 CITY COMMISSION READY FLYING AND REINSTATING THE E. STEWART HISTORICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE. THERE'S A MOTION FOR THAT.

SECOND OKAY. THANK YOU. WITHOUT ANY CHANGES OF THE YEAH, OR DRAFT. UM I BROUGHT UP MY NINE AND 10 AND TWO AND THREE WILL JUST KEEP IT THE WAY THAT IT IS WILL WORK WITH WHOM WE HAVE.

OKAY. OKAY I'M GONNA BRING A RED LIGHT FROM NOW. YEAH WE'LL ALWAYS LOOK FOR YOU AMERICANS.

IT'S HARD. I HAVE A BIG DOWN THERE ONCE. COMMISSIONER COLLINS HAS A BIG HEAD. NO I WOULD JUST, YOU KNOW. YEAH THIS IS A PROBLEM AS YOU KNOW YOU I WAS ON THE OPA AND YEAH, THIS IS A PROBLEM WE HAVE WITH OUR COMMITTEES. IF YOU WANT PEOPLE TO INTEND THE COMMITTEE'S THAN THEY NEED TO FEEL THAT THEIR DISCUSSIONS AND THEIR DELIBERATIONS AND THEIR DECISIONS ARE OF IMPORTANCE TO THE CITY COMMISSION. THESE ARE THESE ARE ONLY FOUR MEETINGS A YEAR. UM I WOULD HAVE I WOULD IMAGINE YOU WOULD PROBABLY ATTEND PANEL AND I WOULD HOPE THAT AT LEAST ONE OF THE COMMISSIONERS COULD ATTEND AS WELL. AND TWO MAKE THEM UNDERSTAND THAT WE APPRECIATE THE TIME YOU'RE GIVING AND THAT THE DECISIONS THEY MAKE CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE IN THEIR COMMUNITIES. SO RIGHT. RATHER THAN IMPOSE HUGE NUMBER. I AGREE WITH THE MAYOR. IT'S AN INVERSE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NUMBER AND ATTENDANCE. SO. CAN I MAKE A COMMENT FOLLOWING UP ON THAT? AND SO I HOPE THAT MS CANDICE SERVED US WILL PROVIDE TO THE COMMISSIONERS, OR I DON'T KNOW IF MISS UM MISS SEUSS. AH! I FORGOT. WOMAN SUES HIS LAST NAME IS NOW BUT, UM, WHAT OUR CITY CLERK ALSO HAS THE NAMES OF THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE CURRENTLY SERVED ON THE COMMITTEE. AND I DON'T THINK IT'S AN AUTOMATIC CAKEWALK TO BE PRESENTED AGAIN. BUT AT LEAST IF THEY COMMISSION COULD BE FAMILIAR, AND THIS THIS SCIARRA OR THE FOR THE SEVEN POINT IN THE SEVENTH, BE FAMILIAR WITH SOME OF THE PEOPLE WHO ARE CURRENTLY WHO HAD SERVED PREVIOUSLY. AND IF THOSE PEOPLE OR ACTIVE AND WOULD WANT TO BE INVOLVED AGAIN. I AM SURE THAT THEY PROBABLY ALL HAVE A APPLICATION AT THE THING, BUT THE OPPORTUNITY WOULD BE GIVEN TO EITHER HAVE THEM MAKE SURE THEY FILL OUT APPLICATIONS OR HAVE THE PEOPLE WHO ARE GOING TO BE APPOINTED COMPLETE APPLICATIONS WHEN OUR CITY WHEN OUR WHEN WE ASKED FOR PEOPLE TO BE INVOLVED, HOW DOES CURRENTLY UM THE OTHER BOARDS DON'T HAVE AN OFFICIAL APPLICATION. UH, PROCESS, IF THE COMMISSION WANTED. THE CLERK TO CREATE AN APPLICATION PROCESS FOR THE BOARDS TO WHERE WE HELD APPLICATIONS. AND THE ONLY PROBLEM WITH THAT IS THAT IF A PERSON SUBMITS AN APPLICATION,

[02:55:02]

AND THEY'RE THE ONLY APPLICATIONS SUBMITTED AND VACANCY COMES UP, AND A BOARD MEMBER DOESN'T KNOW THEM OR HAS ALREADY CHOSEN SOMEONE ELSE. IT MAKES THE PERSON THAT SUBMITTED THAT APPLICATION FEEL KIND OF NEGLECTED AND AS A RESULT IN THE PAST, WE KIND OF HAVEN'T GONE DOWN THAT PATH BECAUSE WE DIDN'T WANT TO. ALIENATE ANYBODY UNINTENTIONALLY, BUT WE DON'T CURRENTLY HAVE A SITUATION WHERE THE SIERRA DIRECTOR IS. RECEIVING APPLICATIONS OR WOULD BE RECEIVING UNLESS YOU PROVIDE THAT DIRECTION. OKAY MR MARSHALL. THE ONLY REASON I BROUGHT THAT IT WAS BECAUSE I DON'T WANT TO SAY THAT I GAVE THE NAME OF TROY MCDONALD AND THEN I HEAR THAT HE HAS A CRIMINAL RECORD. WELL DID I GET WHERE YOU'RE GOING? COMMISSIONER CLARK AND I AGREE THAT OBVIOUSLY THE RESOURCE OF THE PEOPLE THAT PARTICIPATED WOULD BE THE BEST PLACE TO LOOK FOR. FOR NEW APPOINTEES BUT MOVING FORWARD AFTER THAT, I THINK IT'S PROBABLY BE AT THE WILL OF THE BOARD MEMBERS GOING TO GO AHEAD AND GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT. I HAVE FAITH, JAMES TELL ME READY TO GO. YOU HAVE ONE FOR GOOD EVENING. THIS IS BEEN A VERY INTERESTING MEETING ALONG. I ALWAYS LOVE IT. I LOVE LEARNING , UM GREAT DAY TO THE CITY OF STEWART. UM MANAGER MAYOR BY SMEAR COMMISSIONERS AND CITY OFFICIALS. I'M A LITTLE THROWN OFF BY THE NEWS OF OUR CITY MANAGER AND I WILL MISS YOU AS WELL. I HOPE YOU WILL STILL BE JUST A PHONE CALL AWAY. UM, I MET MR DAVID AS OUR CITY OF STEWART, CHIEF OF POLICE WHEN HE RANG MY DOORBELL, AND I LOOKED AROUND AT MY CHILDREN AND SAY THAT YOU ALL DO ANYTHING AT LEAST OUT HERE, RIGHT? SCARED THE HECK OUT OF ME, BUT ACTUALLY, HE WAS COMING TO INTRODUCE HIMSELF TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD, WHICH I'VE NEVER HAD THAT HAPPEN BEFORE. AND THAT WARM MY HEART. IT REALLY MADE ME LOOK AT LAW ENFORCEMENT FORCE MINT DIFFERENTLY. SO THANK YOU FOR DOING THAT, AND HE WAS VERY GOOD ABOUT COMING BACK TO CHECK ON ME. CHECK ON SEE IF WE NEEDED ANYTHING. THE NEIGHBORHOOD FELT SAFER. UM I SAW THE OFFICERS KIND OF CRUISING THROUGH ON THEIR LITTLE MACHINES. AND I THOUGHT THAT WAS REALLY COOL. SO YOU WILL BE MISSED. AND THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING THAT YOU'VE DONE IS OUR CHIEF OF POLICE AND OUR CITY MANAGER. SO I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT, UM MY AGAIN I DIDN'T GIVE MY ADDRESS SOME 5 14 SOUTHEAST FLORIDA STREET. AND JUST LISTENING HERE FOR UM, ITEM 12. THANK YOU, ALL OF YOU FOR LISTENING. THANK YOU FOR ACTING UPON IT AS WELL. I THINK THERE IS A NEED AS WE'VE ALWAYS HAD A NEED. WE'VE BEEN KIND OF A MISSED, YOU KNOW, WITHOUT THINGS HAPPENING WHERE WE HAVE TO COME UP WITH DRAMA AND EVERYBODY'S ANGRY AND UPSET, BUT I THINK THIS IS A GREAT WAY TO HELP MEND THOSE FENCES THAT HAVE BEEN BROKEN AND TRUST THAT HAVE NOT BEEN GAINED IN OUR COMMUNITY. IS TO HAVE SUCH A OPPORTUNITY TO CONTINUE THIS BOARD AND I THINK THIS PANEL AND MISS JORDAN'S AND THAT, UM, COMING OUT TO THIS TO THE EAST STORE AREA AND MEETING WITH US AND HEARING US NOT JUST COMING BUT LISTENING AND STOPPING SO AGAIN. I APOLOGIZE THAT WE HELD UP SOME PROGRESS, BUT I THINK WE MADE MORE PROGRESS BY GOING BACK TO THE BOARD AND BRINGING IN INCLUSION AND THAT'S WHAT HAPPENED SO I APPRECIATE EVERYONE THAT HAS BEEN INVOLVED ON THE RESOLUTION FOR 11-2023. AS VOTED, UM, WHATEVER YOU ALL ARE GOING TO DO, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW MORE ABOUT, UM, THE PROCESS FOR SELECTING THE BOARD MEMBERS OR. WHATEVER THAT'S GOING TO LOOK LIKE, UM I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU'RE GOING TO LET US KNOW. UM HOW THAT WILL TURN OUT WHAT THAT WILL LOOK LIKE I'M AVAILABLE.

YOU HAVE MY PHONE NUMBER AND MY EMAIL ADDRESS. SO FEEL FREE TO CALL ME OR LET ME KNOW IF YOU NEED ME TO COME DOWN HERE. UH MANAGERS THAT I WILL SHOW UP AS LONG AS I HAVE TO. PLEASE EXCUSE ME. I'M A LITTLE BIT OVER MY TIME, BUT I WANTED TO SAY A SPECIAL THANKSGIVING AND SINCERE GRATITUDE TO ALL OF YOU, INCLUDING THE, UM MR PANNELLA, MISS JORDAN'S WE SAW THEM, UM QUITE FREQUENTLY FOR THEIR SUPPORT AND INCLUSION OF THE EAST STEWART STAKEHOLDERS IN OUR COMMUNITIES, AND I DO APPRECIATE THAT VERY MUCH. ALSO LIKE TO SHARE. UM A QUOTE BY ANY ERA KNOCKS IN ANY ERA. KNOX WON THE 2022 NOBEL PRIZE IN LITERATURE FOR THE COURAGE AND CLINICAL, ACTUALLY, UM, ACUITY. THIS FRENCH AUTHOR HAS MADE A CAREER OF WRITING WITH INSIGHTFUL

[03:00:07]

PRECISION. THE COMMONPLACE HAPPENINGS OF LIFE. I FEEL THIS IS AN IMPORTANT APPOINTED TIME IN THE CITY OF STEWART, AND NOT JUST NOW, BUT I'LL GO BACK A LITTLE BIT FURTHER LAST YEAR. UM FOR THE CITY OF STEWART, EAST STEWART AND OUR COMMUNITIES. HER QUOTE IS WHAT COUNTS IS NOT THE THINGS THAT HAPPENED, BUT WHAT WE DO WITH THEM, SO I DO APPRECIATE EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOU. I THINK THIS IS AN APPOINTED TIME HERE IN THE CITY OF STEWART AND EAST OR AND I'M GLAD TO BE PART OF THIS COMMUNITY AND THIS IS MY HOME. BORN HERE, RAISED YOUR HAVE TAUGHT HERE FOR 33 YEARS, RETIRED TEACHER SO THIS IS MY COMMUNITY, AND I'M HERE AND I LOVE BEING PART OF OUR BEAUTIFUL CITY. SO THANK EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOU SINCERELY APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATIONS. THANK YOU ANY ADDITIONAL PUBLIC? HAVE IT? SALAD? THANK YOU FOR YIELDING MOST OF YOUR TIME TO MISS JAMES VERY SHORT GAMES. HELENA RIGHT FLAMINGO AVENUE. POINT FOR CLARIFICATION. THIS COMMITTEE WOULD BE RESIDENTS OF THE CITY OF STEWART. YOU DIDN'T SAY THAT . UH I DON'T KNOW. I THOUGHT IT DID. RESIDENTS OF THE CITY. I MEAN, THIS IS OUR PART OF OUR PART AND THAT HOLD ON. I CAN PULL IT RIGHT. YOU KNOW, I SAY STEWART NEVER IN GLORY, AND I DON'T AGREE ON THAT. I SAY PALM BEACH THROUGH TO MONTEREY. FRODE THAT'S THE WAY BUT I THINK LIKE YOU'RE SAYING THE HISTORY I MEAN, SINCE I MOVED HERE, EVERYONE TOLD ME MARTIN COUNTY HIGH SCHOOL BECAUSE YOU'D BE DIGGING UP STUFF WAS A LANDFILL RESTRICTION IS MEMBER SHALL HAVE BEEN RESIDENTS OF THE CITY OF STEWART FOR AT LEAST SIX MONTHS PRIOR TO APPOINTMENT. THANK YOU THOUGHT SO, BECAUSE IT'S OUR IT'S OUR HOMETOWN. AND I MEAN, I HAVE NOTHING AGAINST THEM IMPACT REVEREND COURT, BUT HE'S IMPORTS ST LUCIE. SO IT AND REALLY, IT'S GOING TO BE A FOR EVERYONE. I MEAN PEOPLE FROM ROYAL. THEY OFTEN COME INTO THE PARK. BUT THIS IS THIS HISTORICAL PART TWO. WE'RE HOPING TO KEEP IT THAT WAY. SO I THAT'S THAT'S THAT'S MINE. WE COME. THANK YOU, JERRY. LOOKS LIKE YOU'RE RIGHT. SHE'S IN. YES, ABSOLUTELY. THANK YOU, JULIE. AND IF YOU JUST FILL OUT A GREEN CARD WHEN YOU'RE DONE, THANK YOU DIDN'T REALLY INTEND TO SPEAK. BUT RYO WAS MENTIONED. I'M JULIE PRIEST FROM RYO AND I AM HISTORICAL RESEARCH VOLUNTEER. I HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH THE BLACK COMMUNITY AND BANNER LAKE, UH, PUT THE BANNER LATE CLUB ON THE HISTORIC REGISTER IN MARTIN COUNTY. I'M CURRENTLY DOING THE SALERNO COLORED SCHOOL BUILT IN 1934 BY THE CIVIL WORKS ADMINISTRATION. VERY GOOD HISTORY. AND AS I GO THROUGH THESE HISTORIES AND DO THE RESEARCH, I FIND A LOT ABOUT EAST STEWART. OF COURSE, UH, HOW THE PEOPLE IN EAST STEWART HAVE A RICH HISTORY. AND I HAVE BEEN AT MEETINGS WHERE MISS PAY HAS RUN THE MEETINGS BEAUTIFULLY, AND I HAVE BEEN TO THE MEETINGS ON GUY DAVIS THAT WAS JUST HELD HELD RECENTLY AT THE REC CENTER.

AND THERE ARE OTHER PEOPLE THERE THAT WANT TO RELAY THAT HISTORY. AND UNLESS YOU HAVE THIS COMMITTEE WORKING TOGETHER TO PROVIDE VOICE TO THIS HISTORY. YOU'LL NEVER KNOW ABOUT IT. THE OTHER FEATURE THAT HAS BEEN HAPPENING BECAUSE I'M ALSO HELPING THE MARTIN COUNTY BLACK HERITAGE INITIATIVES IS ARE THE ELDERS AND THE BLACK COMMUNITY ARE PASSING. I'M NOT A YOUNG PERSON, EITHER, AS YOU CAN TELL , AND THAT IS A HUGE CONCERN. THEY ARE BEING INTERVIEWED WITH 50 INTERVIEWS HAVE TAKEN PLACE. MANY OF THEM GREW UP IN EAST STEWART. AND UH, IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE GET THE WORD OUT ABOUT THIS RICH HISTORY. AND THESE ARE THE PEOPLE THAT CAN HELP YOU DO IT, AND I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE ONE. I DIDN'T READ THE BYLAWS OR WHAT HAS BEEN PUT TOGETHER FOR THIS GROUP. BUT I MIGHT I SUGGEST BECAUSE I'VE BEEN WORKING WITH VOLUNTEERS FOR DECADES, IF YOU COULD, INSTEAD OF BEING SOMEONE THAT HAS LIVED IN THE CITY OF STEWART FOR THE LAST SIX MONTHS. IF THEY COULD JUST BE PROPERTY OWNERS. THIS IS WHAT WE HAVE IN OUR C. R A IN THE COUNTY. THAT YOU COULD BE BUSINESS OWNERS OR PROPERTY OWNERS NOT NECESSARILY LIVE THERE BECAUSE YOU NARROW YOUR POOL OF INDIVIDUALS WHEN YOU HAVE WHEN THEY HAVE TO LIVE IN THE CITY OF STEWART LIVING. DOES ANYBODY WANT TO MODIFY THEIR MOTION ON THE VERSUS MY MOTION? YEAH, BECAUSE WE'VE DONE THAT BEFORE WITH THE L. P M OF PEOPLE WANT A BUSINESS AND THEY CAN BECOME A PART OF THE COMMITTEE. SO YES, TO AMEND YOUR USE THE LANGUAGE? YEAH. AMEND MY SECOND WAIT. EATING ON OKAY, ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT? GREEN LIGHT. THAT'S IT. ONE OKAY? SHE IS IMPORTANT. HIGHER SETTING. BECAUSE SHE CAN'T FIND AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND GOOD

[03:05:02]

EVENING. GOOD EVENING. HI YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD. OKAY MY NAME IS BRINKLEY AT PRESIDENT.

LUCY AND THE POOREST BY THE WAY OF. ACTUALLY BY THE WORK. I'M JUST CALLING. COMMENT ON WORK. I DID HEAR THAT. AND IF I MISSED IT AFTER I HEARD IT, I'M SICK GAS CORRECT. THAT THE BOARD MAY BE A RESPECTED OF STUPID SIX BUCKS. I SAID, I DISAGREE WITH BECAUSE. THOSE OF US THAT LIVE IN EAST SUPER? NOT NECESSARILY BECAUSE I DON'T LIVE IN STORE. THE CANDLE'S STEWART, BUT I THINK THAT IF YOU HAVE ONE SNICKERS STEWART THAT YOU SHOULD BE A MEMBER ABLE TO BE A MEMBER OF THAT BOARD FOR OUR HISTORY. MY FAMILY IS ONE OF THE OLDEST FAMILIES. IT IS STUART MY UNCLE WAS THE FIRST BLACK MAYOR. IN THE CITY OF STEWART. AH WE HAVE RICH HISTORY THERE. NO ONE CAN TELL OUR HISTORY LIKE WE CAN TELL OUR HISTORY. I HEAR YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THE TAILOR PROPERTY. BUT BEFORE IT WAS A TAILOR PROPERTY THAT PROPERTY WAS OWNED BY A LITTLE WHITE MAN OUT OPINION TOWN. THAT'S ALL WE KNEW. I WAS MR ROGER. AND IF I AM NOT MISSING, UM SPEAKING IT THOSE HOMES. THOSE LITTLE HOMES THAT WAS TORN DOWN WAS WHAT THE HOMES THAT THE RAILROAD WORKERS WOULD LIVE IN WHEN THEY WERE COMING THROUGH WORKING ON THE FLORIDA EAST COAST RAILROAD, SO THERE'S A LOT OF HISTORY THERE AND ALL OF US THAT HAVE DIFFERENT NO DIFFERENT THINGS CAN BE HELPFUL TO THAT COMMITTEE , SO I DON'T THINK IT HAS. IT SHOULD BE LIMITED. PEOPLE LIVING IN THE STEWART, BUT IT ENSURES INCLUDE PAST FORMER RESIDENTS OF EAST STEWART AS WELL, THAT WAS ALL I HAD TO SAY. GOOD WITH THAT, TOO. OKAY. THANK YOU. OKAY SO ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT? OKAY? OKAY. WHAT'S YOUR NAME? RONNIE NELSON, OKAY? RONNIE, YOU THERE? OKAY SO ON THAT NOTE, WE'LL GO AHEAD AND THERE'S NO OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT, SHE SAID. YOU CALL THE ROLL. JUST ONE.

CLEARLY THE MOTION IS TO APPROVE HIS WRITTEN WITH THE ADDITION OF IT WOULD BE A RESIDENT OF THE CITY OF STEWART FOR SIX MONTHS OR OWN PROPERTY. AND STUART YES , CORRECT. WE DON'T GET THAT WE DON'T GET MISS BRINKLEY, THEN. NO SHE SAID IT WASN'T LIMITED TO EAST STUART. THIS ISN'T LIMITED TO E. STEWART THIS IS ALL OF STEWART OR A PROPERTY OWNER IN ALL OF STEWART. OKAY PEOPLE WHO HAVE CONNECTIONS IS STUART TRANSFERRED, WHICH YOU CAN BE INVOLVED IN. YOU'RE JUST NOT GOING TO BE APPOINTED. FIRST PROVIDE INPUT CAN BE A SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE CAN GO TO THE MEETINGS AND MAKEUP COMMENTS SO THE BOARD CAN SEE FROM ANYONE THEY WANT COMMITTEE. OKAY. WOULD YOU CALL THE ROLL? OKAY. VICE MAYOR BRUNA YES, COMMISSIONER. RICH YES,

[13. EAST STUART NEIGHBORHOOD - ZONING MAP AMENDMENT (RC): ORDINANCE No. 2499-2023; AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY’S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO ASSIGN “EAST STUART NEIGHBORHOOD” ZONING AND MAKE CHANGES FOR CONSISTENCY WITH FUTURE LAND USE MAP; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

COMMISSIONER CLARK? YES MCDONALD AND COMMISSIONER COLLINS? YES OKAY, MOVING ON TO THE STUART NEIGHBORHOODS. ZONING MAP AMENDMENT. MIKE WOULD YOU READ THE RESOLUTION, AND I'M GONNA STICK ABLE TO VICE MAYOR FOR A MOMENT. THIS IS ORDINANCE NUMBER 2499-20 TO 3, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY'S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO ASSIGN EAST STEWART NEIGHBORHOOD ZONING AND MAKE CHANGES FOR CONSISTENCY WITH LAND USE MAP.

WRITING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES AND CONFLICT, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE BAIT AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. WE DON'T REALLY HAVE A PRESENTATION BECAUSE THERE HASN'T BEEN ANY CHANGES TO THE MAP EXCEPT THE COLOR. WE HAD TO CHANGE THE COLOR AS RECOMMENDED BY COMMISSIONER CLARK. UH, AND SO NO CHANGES TO THE BOUNDARY OR ZONING DESIGNATION. OKAY WELL, THAT'S GREAT. I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO PROOF SECOND IT BUT I HAVE A QUESTION, BUT I'LL TALK. THIS IS OUR SECOND READING, RIGHT. THAT'S IT IS, IT IS. IT WILL COME UP IN THE FUTURE. THAT'S OKAY. WHAT TO DO WITH PUBLIC HOUSING, BUT THEY'RE UNDER THE DESIGNATION OF MULTIFAMILY. AND ANY REDEVELOPMENT WILL GO ACCORDING TO WHATEVER HAPPENS WITH THE P U D OR WHATEVER. SO I'M FINE UNLESS YOU HAVE SOMETHING TO ADD TO THAT. WELL WE HAVE THE NEXT PRESENTATION FOR THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE SO YOU CAN TALK ABOUT IT THEN. OKAY

[03:10:07]

WHAT WAS THE MOTION ON THE COLOR? WHAT COLOR? IT WAS LIKE THE GREENISH BLUISH GREEN THAT WE CHANGED. IT WAS YEAH, BUT. JESSICA THE PINK OR TO EXACTLY THE, UM YOU JESSICA SEYMOUR FROM TREASURE COAST REGIONAL PLANNING COUNCIL INSTRUCTOR IS VERY CONCERNED ABOUT THIS BECAUSE THE COLORS THAT SHE HAD OUR COLOR SEGMENT IS SET FOR FUTURE LAND USE AND ZONING. SO IF YOUR COLORS OFF THE COLOR IS GOING TO BE WHAT OUR GIS HAS. RIGHT SO WHAT WE CAN DO IS PROVIDE THE ART B G COLORS TO THAT SO THAT THEY MATCH COLORS PRECISELY TO SO WE DIDN'T WANT TO CHANGE ANY DESIGNATIONS THAT ARE NO, NO, NO, SHE'S NOT GOING TO CHANGE. THE COLORS ARE GOING TO LET YOU PICK THE COLOR TO MAKE IT MATCH. JUST NOT THIS COLOR. SO THE SO YOU YOU'LL SEE THE LIGHTER PINK COLOR. THAT'S THE CPU D COLOR. UM, WE DIDN'T WANT TO TOUCH THAT COLOR BECAUSE THAT'S USED THROUGHOUT THE CITY, RIGHT? UM THE B M U SECTION. WHICH IS THE MORE PURPLE COLOR THAT ONE WAS TOO CLOSE AND SHADE TO SOME OF YOUR OTHER SOME OF THAT EXISTING COLOR. SO WE TRIED TO SLICE AND FIND A COLOR THAT WOULD BE DISTINGUISHING A LITTLE BIT MORE FROM THAT CPU. IS THAT AN EXISTING USE NOW OR IS THAT THE EMU IN THE B M U EXISTS NOW? SO CAN WE WORKED PREVIOUSLY WITH UM , WITH MICHELLE ON LOOKING AT IDENTIFYING MAKING CONSISTENT COLORS SO WE CAN WORK? WITH YOU OR WHOEVER WHATEVER MICHELLE HAD IS THE B M. YOU, ALTHOUGH I DO IS CHANGE FROM WHATEVER IT IS TO BE EMU, AND IT SELECTS THE COLOR AUTOMATICALLY HAS THE COLOR. IT IS OKAY. THAT'S SOUNDS GOOD, BUT THERE WILL BE NEW COLORS. WELL, WE CAN TALK ABOUT THAT IN THE CREEK BECAUSE WITH THE CREEK DISTRICT WILL CREATE NEW DISTRICTS. SO THERE'LL BE NO. SO MAYBE WHEN ZONING DISTRICTS WOULD BE YES. MAYBE AT THAT TIME WE CAN LOOK AT MATCHING THE COLORS THAT ARE HERE. SO THERE'S A LITTLE MORE DISTINGUISHING. I'M SURE THE NEXT MANAGER WILL HAVE PLENTY OF GRES KNOWLEDGE PRESSURE. THIS CREATES. DON'T WANT TWO SETS OF COLOR AGAIN. YEAH, YOU KNOW, IT'S LIKE, AS YOU KNOW, IT'S VERY DIFFICULT WHEN YOU HAVE SO MANY, YOU KNOW , NOT SO MANY DESIGNATIONS, BUT YOU HAVE A LOT OF DESIGNATIONS. YOU WANT TO MAKE THEM DISTINGUISHING FROM EACH OTHER, BUT ALSO KIND OF TELL THE STORY OF WHAT WHAT'S WHAT'S THERE, RIGHT. THERE'S GENERAL RULES OF THE KIND OF PURPLE PAINT GLOSS FOR COMMERCIAL AS IT DOES. RED YELLOWS TEND TO BE YOUR MORE DENSITY PARKS OR PARKS AND GREENS ARE ALSO YOUR MIXED USE LIKE LOW IN IMPACT INGREDIENTS, SO THERE'S TRENDS. WE TRY TO STICK WITH THOSE, UM WHEN LOOKING AT THE COLORS AND CHANGES FEW OF THEM AS POSSIBLE. MR MAYOR. WHATEVER YOU SAY WE MAKE A MOTION. UM MR BRUNO. DID SHE MAKE A MOTION MOTION YET TO MAKE A MOTION AND ORDINANCE NUMBER 25? I'M SORRY. MR THOUGHT SHE DID, BUT SHE HAD THE GAVEL GAVEL SO SHE COULDN'T MAKE A MOTION. OH SO I COULD TAKE BACK THE GAMBLING. LET HER MAKE CAN WE DISCUSS A LITTLE BIT MORE BEFORE WE GET INTO MOTIONS? YES SURE. HOLD OFF ON MOTIONS FROM ONE MOMENT. I JUST WANTED TO TALK ABOUT THE 80 US. I FEEL GOOD WITH EVERYTHING ON THIS EXCEPT JUST A MAP APPROVAL. THIS IS NOT THIS IS NOT THE TEXT AMENDMENT. I'LL WAIT FOR 14. YEAH, OKAY. AND WE HAVE A MOTION. YOU CAN MAKE IT NOW.

GIVE IT BACK TO HIM HAVE THE GAVEL. YOU CAN MAKE YOUR MOTION AND MAKE A MOTION FOR APPROVAL.

A 2ND 24 ORDINANCE SUMMER 24 99 . THAT'S 2023. I'D LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT WITH MY SECOND OF THAT. I NOTICED THAT IN THE AUDIENCE WAS MR TOM LANAHAN, THE DIRECTOR OF THE REGIONAL PLANNING COUNCIL DIDN'T GET A CHANCE TO RECOGNIZE HIM. COULD YOU PLEASE GIVE HIM MY REGARDS AND RESPECT AND THANK HIM FOR THE WORK? OF THE REGIONAL PLANNING COUNCIL. ABSOLUTELY HE HAD A TIME CERTAIN TO BE OUT OF HERE, SO UNFORTUNATELY, HE SENDS HIS BEST REGARDS. HE WAS HAPPY TO BE HERE, THOUGH. OKAY SO THE MOTION BY COMMISSIONER VICE MAYOR BURNER SECOND BY COMMISSIONER CLARK ANY COMMENTS FROM THE COMMISSIONERS? SAYING NONE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT. SAYING NONE TO SAY WHAT YOU CALL THE ROLL. COMMISSIONER COLLINS YES, COMMISSIONER RICH BRUDER. YES, COMMISSIONER CLARK. YES, MACDONALD. OKAY WE'LL GO AHEAD AND TO ITEM NUMBER 14 EAST

[14. EAST STUART NEIGHBORHOOD - LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AMENDMENT (RC): ORDINANCE No. 2507-2023; AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING AND RESTATING THE CITY’S LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING CHAPTER III SPECIAL ZONING CODES FOR THE “EAST STUART NEIGHBORHOOD”; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTING PROVISIONS; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

STEWART NEIGHBORHOOD LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AMENDMENT. MIKE, WOULD YOU READ THE PRESIDENT LEE ORDINANCE TITLE. YES, THIS IS ORDINANCE 2507-20 TO 3, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING AND RESTATING THE CITY'S LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING CHAPTER THREE SPECIAL ZONING CODES FOR

[03:15:01]

THE EAST STEWART NEIGHBORHOOD, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT NG PROVISIONS PROVIDING FOR CONVOCATION, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. AND THIS IS A LEGISLATIVE TEXT AMENDMENT ON BEHALF OF THE COMMISSION. HI SO GOOD EVENING AGAIN. JESSICA SEYMOUR FROM TREASURE COAST REGIONAL PLANNING COUNCIL, UM, BRINGING UP THIS SLIDE AGAIN, JUST TO REMIND ANYBODY WHO'S WATCHING OR LISTENING THAT WE'VE BEEN WORKING ON THIS WITH CITY STAFF FOR OVER A YEAR, SO I'VE ONLY BROUGHT UM FIVE OF MY 50 SLIDES TONIGHT, SO HOPEFULLY I WILL BE ABLE TO ADDRESS ANY QUESTIONS THAT COME UP. UM WE WERE TASKED WITH UPDATING THE CODE SO THAT IT COULD BE MORE PREDICTABLE FOR APPLICANTS FOR THE RESIDENTS AND A PRODUCER BETTER, UH, PUBLIC FORUM FOR THE FOR THE CITY. UM, AND SO FIRST NEIGHBORHOOD WE LOOKED AT WAS THE EAST STEWART NEIGHBORHOOD TO UPDATE THOSE CODES AND IMPLEMENT , UM NEW STRATEGIES AND AGAIN. MAKE SURE THAT EXISTING CHARACTER THAT NEIGHBORHOOD IS PROTECTED. UM AT THE LAST HOUR AT THE FIRST READING AT OUR MEETING IN JANUARY, 17TH WE HAD SOME NOTES OF CLARIFICATION, AND SO REALLY, WE'RE JUST BRINGING BACK BEFORE YOU THE ITEMS THAT WE ADJUSTED WITH THE FEEDBACK FROM THE BOARD AT THAT MEETING, SO WE ADDRESS SOME OF THE LANGUAGE THAT WAS A BIT CONFUSING IN THE APPLICABILITY. WE ADJUSTED THE COLORS AS MENTIONED FOR THE B M U SO THAT THAT WAS DIFFERENTIATING FROM THE CPU D COLOR, WHICH IS COMMERCIAL PLANNED UNIT. UM THE EMU HAS BUSINESS MIXED USE. WE ADDED SOME INFORMATION TO CLARIFY THE REPLICATION OF HISTORIC BUILDINGS POLICY, SO WE UNDERSTOOD THAT WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE SAME BUILDINGS. UM WE ALSO ADDED THAT, UM, THE SIDE YARD WAS IN A PERMISSION ALLOWS PLACE FOR THE STORAGE OF CAMPERS AND RECREATIONAL VEHICLES. UM AND WE TURNED UP ANY LANGUAGE AROUND WHERE FEASIBLE SO THAT IT WAS CLEAR WHAT WAS REQUIRED OF AN APPLICANT AND WHAT THE CONSTRAINTS THAT AN APPLICANT COULD BE, UM, BRING UP HIS CONSTRAINING LIMITATIONS FOR ANY ADJUSTMENTS. UM SO THAT'S THAT BRINGS UP THE VAST THE ALL THE CHANGES THAT WE'VE MADE SINCE THE FIRST READING IF I CAN ADDRESS ANY QUESTIONS THAT ARE OUT THERE, UM, I'M HAPPY TO DO SO. OKAY DO YOU HAVE ANY EMOTIONS ARE COMING TO MAKE A MOTION TO HOLD UP FAMILIES. SO THE A D U S. I LIKE EVERYTHING IN HERE. THAT'S FORM BASED CODE RELATED, BUT THE 80 US, UM I'M NOT COMFORTABLE WITH WE HAVE A STABLE NEIGHBORHOOD THAT HAS BEEN THAT WAY FOR DECADES, AND THE STEWART AND EVEN WITHIN YOUR GOALS WERE PROTECTING THE NEIGHBORHOOD, RIGHT. THAT'S WHY WE'RE DOING THIS. I LIKE ALL THE FORM BASED CODE. RELATED YOU KNOW, SETBACKS AND FRONTAGE IS AND BUT I THINK THERE'S LIABILITY AND POTENTIALLY TRANSFORMING THE NEIGHBORHOOD FROM A SINGLE FAMILY HOME NEIGHBORHOOD. TO WHAT IS EFFECTIVELY A DETACHED DUPLEX ARE THREE MULTI FAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD. THAT'S A HUGE AND IF IT WAS MY NEIGHBORHOOD THAT WOULD MAKE ME VERY UNCOMFORTABLE, SO HEAR ME OUT. I MENTIONED THIS LAST TIME, BUT I REALLY WANT TO HIT IT AGAIN IS WHAT YOU'RE DOING IS EFFECTIVELY. CLOSE TO DOUBLING THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY. BY DOUBLING THE PERMISSIBLE DENSITY. WITH THE A D US IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD. IF YOU ARE CHANGING ALL THE SETBACK, AND I'M NOT AGAINST THIS, I DON'T MEAN TO COME UP LIKE A AGAINST THIS AT ALL. BUT WHAT WHAT I DO THINK WE NEED TO DO IS REALLY TALK ABOUT THIS BECAUSE I THINK THIS COULD HAVE SERIOUS IMPLICATIONS FOR E. STEWART AND I'M NOT AGAINST IT, BUT I WOULD LIKE TO TAKE IT OUT OF FORM THIS FORM BASED CODE. APPROVAL AND REALLY SIT DOWN AND LOOK AT. ARE THERE OTHER MUNICIPALITIES WHERE THIS HAS HAPPENED? HAS IT CHANGED THE TONE OF THAT NEIGHBORHOOD? I GET THE IDEA OF WANTING TO CREATE A REVENUE STREAM FOR THE FOLKS IN THE STEWART COOL. BUT WHAT IF SOMEBODY IS BUYING THAT PROPERTY THAT IS NOW LOOKING AT THAT, LOOKING AT THE ABILITY TO DEVELOP IT AND HAVE A DUPLEX ON IT, AND DOUBLE THE DENSITY. A THAT IT'S SOMEBODY THAT HAS TO OWN. IT'S GOING TO LIVE IN IT, BUT WE DON'T HAVE THE RESOURCES TO CHECK THAT. NOBODY IS GOING TO BE DOING THAT. TRULY SO IT IS THERE AND I'M NOT. I'M NOT, YOU KNOW, LYING IN THE SAND, BUT IF THERE'S EVEN THAT POTENTIAL LIABILITY. I THINK WE SHOULD TALK ABOUT IT AND REALLY DIG OUT. EXAMPLES OF BECAUSE HE STUART IS SO IMPORTANT. ARE WE SURE THAT HE STEWART IS GOING TO BE PROTECTED BY MAKING THAT CHANGE WOULD BE MY POINT RIGHT SO TO JUST TO CLARIFY FOR EVERYONE, THE ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS, THE A, D U, AND THEY ARE ONLY PERMITTED ON THE SINGLE FAMILY DETACHED HOMES. THAT WAS SOMETHING THAT EARLIER DRAFTS OF THIS WE SPENT A STAFF AND WITH THE COMMUNITY A LOT OF TIME

[03:20:05]

TALKING ABOUT THIS POLICY. THERE WAS A LOT OF SUPPORT FOR THIS POLICY EARLY ON IN THE VISIONING. UM EARLIER ITERATIONS OF IT DID INCLUDE, UM MORE ALLOWANCES FOR IT LIKE THE ALLOWANCE TO HAVE IT WITH JUST ANY SINGLE FAMILY HOME. WHEN WE STEPPED BACK FROM THAT WE SAID, NO. IT NEEDS TO BE AN OWNER OCCUPIED SINGLE FAMILY HOME. RIGHT? AND YOU CAN'T HAVE, UM YOU KNOW ABSENTEE LANDLORDS, RIGHT? THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE DON'T WANT TO REALLY GOING TO POLICE THAT WELL, WHEN YOU GO FOR, UH, DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION . I MEAN, THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WILL BE PART OF THE CONVERSATION, RIGHT? YOU KNOW, AT SOME POINT GOING TO CONTINUOUSLY BE CHECKING UP ON THAT, PROBABLY NOT. I MEAN, IT'S IN THERE, THOUGH, THAT IF THERE IS AN ISSUE THAT THERE'S A MECHANISM FOR CODE ENFORCEMENT TO GET INVOLVED, RIGHT, UM THE OTHER ISSUE IS THAT WE'VE LIMIT THE SQUARE FOOTAGE OF IT. SO THAT'S WHY IT'S NOT JUST LIKE A DUPLEX, RIGHT DUPLEXES OR TWO PRIMARY STRUCTURES OF EQUAL IMPORTANCE AND 80 YOU AS OF LESSER IMPORTANCE. THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE BECAUSE OF THAT SIZE LIMITATIONS, SO THAT'S ONE ISSUE THAT MAKES IT DIFFERENT THAN IN THAN A DUPLEX TRADITIONALLY, RIGHT. UM, SO THAT'S ANOTHER, UM, LIMITATION THAT WE PUT IN THERE. WE ALSO IN PARTICULAR, WE CLARIFY THAT IF THAT UNIT GETS BIGGER THAN THAT, IT'S GOING TO BE COUNTED TOWARDS YOUR DENSITY RIGHT SO THAT SPACE LIMITATION IS REALLY IMPORTANT. UM THE OWNER OCCUPIED AND THEN ALSO THE FACT THAT IT'S ATTACHED TO A SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING UNIT, WHICH IS AGAIN TYPICALLY OR YOU KNOW, THAT WOULD TYPICALLY BE YOUR OWNER OCCUPIED UNITS, BUT HEAR ME OUT FROM A FINANCIAL STANDPOINT, RIGHT? I LISTENED TO THE LAST MEETING THAT WE HAD. THAT WAS THE JOINT MEETING. I'VE HEARD IT FROM JIMMY SMITH TO THE PEOPLE AND THAT NEIGHBORHOOD SPECIFICALLY ARE LIKE TRYING TO HAVE THEIR ROOF GET FIXED. THEY NEED AN A C UNIT. THEY ARE TRYING TO KEEP THEIR HOUSE. UM, AFLOAT, RIGHT? WHEN YOU.

DRAMATICALLY CHANGED THE VALUE OF THAT PROPERTY BY SAYING YOU CAN LIKE YOU'RE NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO BASICALLY TURNED THIS INTO SEMI COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE . DOES THAT PUT THE PEOPLE WHO LIVE THERE AT RISK OR INCENTIVIZE THEM TO SELL AND POTENTIALLY GENTRIFY THE NEIGHBORHOOD BECAUSE YOU TOOK IT FROM? WHAT WAS NOW RIGHT NOW YOU CAN HAVE ANYBODY YOU AND IF WE WANT TO TALK ABOUT HOLD ON THE SETBACKS AND DOING THE SETBACKS . THAT'S FINE. BUT NOW YOU'RE TAKING IT FROM BEING SOMETHING WHERE IT'S THEIR FAMILY MEMBER TO THIS EXTRA HOOKUP, RIGHT? THEY'RE GONNA THEY'RE GONNA HAVE A SEPARATE HOOKUP. WELL, THEY COULD HAVE AN EXTRA HOOK UP TODAY. THAT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT'S UM, REGULATED TODAY, BUT HISTORICALLY, THE US HAVE NOT HAD THAT SAME IMPACT IS UP. ZONING DOES SO UP. ZONING IS WHEN YOU ZONE A PROPERTY FOR MORE THAN WHAT IT CAN REALLY FINANCIALLY SUSTAIN, AND THEN YOU END UP WITH VACANT PARCELS.

SO AN EXAMPLE OF THAT IS ACTUALLY WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN PARTS OF WHAT IS THE BIG BUSINESSMEN MIXED USE AREA WHERE THEY REQUIRE COMMERCIAL TO BE A COMPONENT OF THAT RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT. THAT WAS TOO TOO INTENSE OF A ZONING DISTRICT FOR THOSE AREAS, SO WE'VE BEEN VERY CAREFUL TO NOT CONSIDER AREAS WHERE YOU UP ZONE ABOUT THAT PROPERTY SO THAT IT'S NOT EASILY , UM, BUILD OCCUPIED. UM YOU HAVE EXAMPLES FOR THIS IS WORKED IN OTHER MUNICIPALITIES AND NOT HAD UNINTENDED UP. IN THE MARKET . MARTIN HONEY SIERRAS HAVE A VERY SIMILAR POLICY IN EXISTENCE THAT CHANGED THE EU RULES. AND IT HAS NOT MEAN THERE'S UM, THOSE WERE ADAPTED IN SCHOOL 2020. 20 THERE IS SERIES OF THEM BETWEEN 2019 AND 2020. MARTIN COUNTY. WIDER SPECIFIC. ER, A SPECIFIC TO SEE ARE SPECIFIC TO WHERE YOU'VE GOT SMALLER, HISTORIC LOTS WHERE THIS IS ACTUALLY BEEN A PART OF THE BUILDING FABRIC. HISTORICALLY, THAT UM SMALL UNITS, DETACHED UNITS OR SOMETHING THAT'S VERY CHARACTERISTIC OF THESE HISTORICALLY PLANTED NEIGHBORHOODS. MARTIN COUNTY WAVE MINIMUM LOT SIZE. YES SINCE I'M AREAS THEY HAVE SMALLER LOT SIZES SIMILAR TO THIS. YEAH IN THAT AREA. THE U. S. SOME OF THEM. YES I MEAN, THERE'S A LOT OF TALKING ABOUT A LOT OF ZONING DESIGNATIONS. BUT YES. FOR ME. I JUST I DON'T I DON'T FEEL COMFORTABLE. VOTING FOR THIS WITH THE A. D. U S IN IT FOR NOW. I'D LIKE TO SEE IT SEPARATE WOULD BE MINE. CAN I TAKE AWAY AND I APPRECIATE YOUR GOING BACK AND FORTH WITH ME. IF IT'S NOT AS MUCH AS I CAN, YOU KNOW, ADDRESS THE CONCERNS THAT YOU HAVE AND LEGITIMATE CONCERNS THAT SOMETHING IS STAFF AND AS A YOU KNOW, DOING INTERVIEWS WITH FOLKS IN THE COMMUNITY THAT WAS ALWAYS AT THE FOREFRONT OF OUR MINDS, SO I ABSOLUTELY UNDERSTAND THAT THAT WOULD MAKE ME NERVOUS IF IT WAS MINE. COMMISSIONER CLARK. THANK YOU. YOU'RE OKAY. ALRIGHT. SO I'M GLAD THAT YOU BROUGHT THAT UP, SO I WENT BACK TO LOOK AT THE ACCESS FOR DARLING. YOU AND SAID JUST IN THIS ONE LITTLE SECTION HERE, BUT I WANTED YOU TO WANT TO ASK YOU TO TALK ABOUT DENSITY AND WHY, AND A D U IS NOT COUNTED AS DENSITY AND WHEN SOMETHING IS COMPLETELY CHANGE,

[03:25:05]

AND THEN A DENSITY, IS THAT IT? I WANT YOU TO EXPLAIN THAT CLEARLY FROM MR MARTEL'S PURPOSES AND THE FACT THAT I TRUSTED MISS PANEL AND EVERYBODY THAT EVERYTHING WAS OKAY. AND I LOOKED AT THINGS IN GENERAL. BUT SINCE YOU BRING IT UP SECTION THREE POINT OH, TWO OR FOUR SECTION F. FOR IN THIS BOOK HERE. I HAVE IT ON PAGE 18 OF 78 . I DON'T KNOW IT'S THIS LIKE 1000 AND SOMETHING PAGES IN THE AGENDA, BUT IT DOESN'T ON THIS PARTICULAR THING. IT'S GIVEN ME SOMETHING ELSE. IT'S NOT GIVING ME THE ENTIRE AGENDA. SO THAT'S A PAGE NUMBER THAT I'M WORKING WITH. BUT FOR SECTION WISE, IT'S SECTION THREE POINT OR TWO POINT OH FOUR SECTION F PART FOR MR MORTAL PART B. UM, EITHER THE PRIMARY DWELLING UNIT OR A D YOU SHALL BE OWNER OCCUPIED THE A. D YOU SHALL NOT BE SOLD. OR IT SHOULD BE TITLED, I THINK TITLED THERE, TOO. AND THEN THERE'S ANOTHER. THESE ARE JUST TWO TYPOS THAT I JUST FOUND THEIR TWO TRANSFERRED SEPARATE AND APART FROM INSTEAD OF FORM. FROM THE REST OF THE PROPERTY. I JUST FOUND THAT THAT, UM, JUSTICE MINUTE WHEN I WAS JUST TRYING TO CHECK ON SOMETHING, SO I JUST WANTED TO BRING OUT THOSE TWO LITTLE THINGS. THEY'RE JUST TOO LITTLE TOO LITTLE TYPOS. NOT ANYTHING BIG, BUT UH HUH? NO THEY CANNOT TITLED SEPARATELY. OKAY YEAH. SO JUST BETWEEN YOU AND MR MARTEL, AND I'LL MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S JUST TOO LITTLE TYPOS. PLEASE GO AGAIN. EXPLAIN DENSITY AND WHY THE CERTAIN THINGS IN HAVING THE BACK OF THE HOME SIMILAR TO WHAT MR SMITH AND SEVERAL OTHER PEOPLE HAVE OTHER DWELLING UNITS OR OTHER THINGS DIFFERENT PEOPLE , WHICH HASN'T BEEN UNTO THE CODE, BUT THEY'RE DIFFERENT PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT UNITS, AND IT HAS WORKED FOR THEM AND THEIR FAMILY AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THINGS ARE LEGAL AND OKAY. EXPLAIN IT AGAIN ONE MORE TIME BEFORE WE MOVE FORWARD AND VOTING ON THIS PARTICULAR AREA, SO THE PROVISIONS THAT IT DOES NOT COUNT TOWARDS DENSITY TIES BACK TO THE FACT THAT IT IS A SECONDARY UNIT TO THE MAIN STRUCTURE. IT'S LIMITED BY SIZE . IT'S LIMITED BY 107 100 SQUARE FEET, WHICH IS TIED BACK TO THE SIZE OF A TWO CAR GARAGE. SO AGAIN, A UNIT ABOVE A GARAGE, WHICH IS A TYPICAL BUILDING TYPE FOR HISTORICALLY PLANTED NEIGHBORHOODS. UM IT DOESN'T HAVE THE SAME KIND OF IMPACT DUE TO ITS SIZE, AND THEN IT'S ALSO OWNER OCCUPIED. IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT IS ADOPTED BY THE COMMUNITY WHOLESALE. IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT IS IMPLEMENTED BY A LARGE SCALE DEVELOPER RIGHT THAT CAN COME IN AND DO SEVERAL OF THESE ALL AT ONCE, RIGHT SO THAT IT'S ALL ON AN INDIVIDUAL PROCESS VERSUS SOMETHING LIKE A MULTI FAMILY PROJECT WHERE MULTI FAMILY PROJECT HAS A MUCH MORE.

IMMEDIATE, UM. IMPACT INTO A NEIGHBORHOOD. LET'S SAY, WHEREAS THIS IS SOMETHING THAT HAS BEEN INCREMENTALLY OR SMALL SCALE, UM AND ONLY WHERE PEOPLE WANT TO DO THIS KIND OF A PROJECT. IT ALSO INTERJECT SMALL, AFFORDABLE UNITS INSIDE THE NEIGHBORHOOD CONTEXT RATHER THAN AGAIN DOING SOMETHING THAT'S OF A OF A DIFFERENT SCALE THAN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. SO THOSE ARE IMPACTS ON WHAT MAKES THE 80 YOU DIFFERENTLY WORK DIFFERENTLY, ALSO OF NOTE THAT THERE ARE 80 US TODAY. PERMISSIBLE IN, UM IN THE RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS. UM, SO AGAIN, WE'RE JUST IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT ALLOWING THEM TO BE RENTAL UNITS, WHICH FRANKLY OCCURS IN SOME PLACES OF STEWART ALREADY AND UM, AND THEN AGAIN, ALLOWING THOSE TO BE UNITS THAT ARE, UM, PERMISSIBLE UNDER THE CODE, WHICH IS JUST BECAUSE NOBODY'S NOBODY'S POLICING THAT RIGHT NOW, BUT ONCE YOU MAKE IT ALLOWED IN THE CODE. IT DOES OPEN THE DOOR FOR A DEVELOPER TO COME IN. AND FROM MY UNDERSTANDING ANDY STEWART. THERE'S LIKE A HANDFUL OF FAMILIES THAT OWNED MOST OF THE PROPERTIES THERE, RIGHT. SO WHEN YOU SAY IT WOULDN'T BE LARGE SWATS, IT COULD BE SO LET'S LET'S SAY, LET'S SAY SOMEBODY DOES OWN SEVERAL SINGLE FAMILY HOME PLOTS WANT TO BUILD ON THEM, THEY COULD GO AHEAD AND BUILD THE SINGLE FAMILY HOMES WITH AN 80 YOU SAY GARAGE UNIT OR OR JUST A SMALL UNIT IN THE BACK. UM WE'RE TALKING ABOUT AGAIN, NOT A LARGE SCALE DEVELOPMENT. THAT'S SOMETHING THAT FITS WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF WHAT'S HAPPENED NEXT DOOR TO THEM, UM AND AGAIN, IF JUST TO PUT NOTE IN THERE. THE SINGLE FAMILY DUPLEX DISTRICT ALLOWS FOR DUPLEXES. SO AGAIN, WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TWO UNITS ON A PARCEL. SO EVEN THOUGH WE'RE NOT ASSISTANT WITH THE NEIGHBORS WERE NOT COUNTING IT AS AS INCREASED DENSITY. BUT WE'RE WE ARE MAKING IT. WE'RE JUST NOT COUNTING. IT IS MORE DENSITY

[03:30:06]

BECAUSE THEY'RE SAYING IT'S A SECONDARY UNIT. BUT WE ARE, IN FACT. INCREASING THE DENSITY AND MAKING ALLOWANCE FOR SOMEBODY TO IF THEY DID BUY THAT PARCEL, AND THEY WANTED TO RENT IT OUT.

RENTED OUT TO MORE PEOPLE WERE EFFECTIVELY MAKING IT OR THREE. IT'S NOT SINGLE FAMILY ANYMORE.

IT'S A DETACHED DUPLEX. I FEEL LIKE WE HAVE TO BE HONEST ABOUT WHAT WE'RE DOING. AND I JUST SAY IT'S SINGLE FAMILY WITH IT. WE ARE MAKING IT MORE DENSE, AND THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT OF DOING . THIS IS TO MAKE IT A COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE. BUT HOW DO YOU REALLY GOVERNED FOR WHO THINK THAT I HAVE A HARD TIME IMAGINING? I MEAN, IF YOU'RE OF COURSE, ENTITLED TO THAT OPINION , AND IF THAT'S THE BOARD'S DIRECTION, WE WILL MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT DIRECTION. UM, AGAIN.

THIS IS A VERY SMALL, INCREMENTAL WAY OF ALLOWING THE SINGLE FAMILY HOME. CONTEXT TO CONTINUE AND ALLOW FOR A UNIT IN THE BACK THAT'S DETACHED OR ATTACHED, UM, WITH LIMITATIONS, YOU KNOW, AGAIN A LOT PROVIDING FOR THAT ON SITE PARKING SPACE FOR THAT 80 YOU LIMITED BY THE SIZE AND LIMITED, UM, IN THE TO THOSE OWNER OCCUPIED SINGLE FAMILY HOMES. THEY CAN'T BE. YOU KNOW, YOU CAN'T ADD ONE TO A DUPLEX. YOU CAN'T ADD ONE TO A TOWNHOUSE THAT'S ATTACHED. WE CALL OUT AGAIN FOR THE DETACHED UNITS. AGAIN SO THAT THERE'S MORE LIMITATIONS ON HOW THIS COULD BE IMPLEMENTED SO THAT IT DOESN'T BECOME THE LARGE SCALE COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE THAT I THINK MANY OF US WOULD BE CONCERNED ABOUT. YOU KNOW THAT YOU PAINTED A PICTURE OF RIGHT? COMMISSION RICH DID YOU HAVE ANYTHING? UM. I MEAN, THEY CAN BUILD A TO US NOW. RIGHT, MISS SEYMOUR? THEY ABSOLUTELY CAN. OF COURSE, THE DIFFERENCE HERE AND BETWEEN BECAUSE I'M BUILDING A D U IS I CAN'T EXCEED 50% OF THE SIZE OF MY PRIMARY STRUCTURE. SO THIS IS THE ONLY VARIANCE I'M SEEING THERE. UM YEAH. HE'S A D USER. I SEE THEM AS VERY VALUE ELEMENTS ELEMENTS OF OUR CITY PROVIDE FOR EXTENDED FAMILIES CARING FOR OLDER PARENTS. AH, A LOT WAS YOUNGER CHILDREN AND YOU KNOW TO GET ON THEIR FEET SO JUST JUST, YOU KNOW THE LANGUAGE HERE THAT FACILITATES THAT IS VERY VALUABLE. AND I APPRECIATE I KNOW THAT CONCERN YOU'VE TAKEN TO ACCOMPLISH THIS AND I APPRECIATE THAT. DO WE HAVE A MOTION OR ANYTHING? MOTION FOR APPROVAL MOTION BY VICE MAYOR BRUDER OR SECOND BY COMMISSIONER CLARK. DO WE HAVE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT? I WOULD JUST LIKE TO ADD IF I MAY. OF ALL THE HARD WORK THAT JESSICA IS DONE AND OUR STAFF OVER HERE. WE'VE WORKED REALLY YOU GUYS ARE VIRTUALLY HARD. UM, GETTING US HERE AND IT'S TAKEN A LONG TIME.

AND, UM VERY PROUD OF IT, TAKING A LONG TIME AND TRYING TO SATISFY EVERYONE. I DON'T SEE IT THE WAY COMMISSIONER COLLINS DOES. SOMETIMES HE'LL USE HIS WORDS AND TWIST IT LIKE IT'S MY WORD, AND IT'S NOT WE'RE REALLY I'M PROUD OF WHAT YOU'VE DONE IN PANEL. ANY OTHER ANY PUBLIC COMMENT. COME ON UP AND COME ON UP WITH THE COLOR OF THE CARD FROM HIS JOB. JAMES, PLEASE THREE MINUTES AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD AND THEN FILL OUT A GREEN CARBON YOU'VE DONE OKAY. THANK YOU. BEIJING'S BY 14 SOUTHEAST FLORIDA STREET STORE FLORIDA 34994. AGAIN I LIKE TO SAY THANK YOU ALSO TO, UM MISS JESSICA AND EVERYONE THAT'S COME OUT AND INCLUDED, UM STAKEHOLDERS. UM IN THE STORY, UM, IN THE PROCESS, AND WE WENT BACK AND FORTH QUITE A BIT AT THE TABLE. UM I GUESS WHAT BROUGHT THIS TO MY MIND WAS WHAT COMMISSIONER COLLINS WAS SAYING.

BECAUSE I HAVE A VISION OF WHEN YOU KEPT SAYING WHO'S GONNA BE POLICING IT, AND I UNDERSTAND THAT AND I DON'T KNOW. JUST. FROM MY OWN PERSONAL KNOWLEDGE. UM, I KNOW OF HOMES THERE IN EAST STEWART. THAT'S BEEN THERE , AND IT'S BEEN PASSED ON TO GENERATIONS, AND THEY DON'T LIVE HERE ANYMORE. BUT THEY THEY HAVE THE PROPERTY. AND MY CONCERNS ARE THAT THEY ARE NOT ALLOWED, AND I DON'T KNOW HOW THEY HAVE IT REGISTERED. AS A HOMEOWNER OR RENTAL. SO MY CONCERNS ARE FOR PEOPLE THAT DON'T LIVE IN OUR COMMUNITY BUT HAVE PROPERTY THAT THEY HAVE GAINED OR PURCHASED IN SOME WAY, AND THEY ARE LOOKING TO MAKE PROFIT RIGHT AND I'M VERY CONCERNED ABOUT THAT. I BROUGHT THAT OUT. IT'S DUE TO MY HEART. I DON'T LIKE THAT. THAT'S THE STEP TO GENTRIFICATION,

[03:35:04]

RIGHT? SO I LIKE THE FACT THAT YOU BROUGHT THAT UP AND I HOPE WE CAN CONSIDER THAT WE HAVE THOSE PROTECTIONS IN THERE BECAUSE AGAIN WHO'S POLICING BECAUSE WE DON'T KNOW. I DON'T EVEN KNOW IF IT'S REGISTERED AS A IT WAS A SINGLE FAMILY HOME. BUT THE ACQUIRED PERSONALITY DOESN'T LIVE HERE AND THEIR BUSINESS PERSON AND I DON'T KNOW IF THEY'RE REGISTERED. THAT PERSON DOESN'T LIVE IN HOME, BUT IT'S A RENTAL PROPERTY, AND I KNOW THAT PERSON WANTS TO DO THAT. BACK PART ON THAT PROPERTY FOR RENTAL PURPOSES. SO I THANK YOU FOR SAYING THAT BECAUSE IT IS ABOUT THE PRESERVATION OF OUR HISTORICAL COMMUNITY. BIG DOLLARS THAT WANT TO COME IN, BECAUSE THAT'S ALL THEY SEE. AND DON'T THINK ABOUT US THAT REALLY STARTED FROM SCRATCH AND OUR PARENTS AND PARENTS GENERATIONS. AND I DO REALLY HOPE THAT IS CONSIDERED. GREATLY THAT THERE ARE THOSE TYPE OF CODE ENFORCEMENT OR TYPE OF RULES SOMEWHERE THAT THESE PEOPLE CAN'T DO THAT. THANK YOU. OKAY PUBLIC COMMENTS, SHE SAID. YOU CALLED THE WRONG PLACE. MR. AMERICA, JUST MAKE IT ADDITIONAL COMMENTS. OKAY? YEAH, UM. I'D LIKE TO ECHO BY SMEAR BRUNNER'S REMARK REGARDING THIS, SEYMOUR. I'VE MET WITH HER FOUR TIMES. AND SHE WAS VERY HELPFUL TO ME.

SHE HAS A GREAT DEAL OF KNOWLEDGE ON THIS SUBJECT. AH THAT WAS INVALUABLE. AS FAR AS WHO'S GOING TO ENFORCE THIS. I THINK THE PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD ARE GOING TO WIN.

FORCE THIS THEY'RE GOING TO SEE A SOMEBODY'S UP TO SOMETHING THAT THEY SHOULDN'T BE. WE JUST HAD A SITUATION ON FIFTH. OR A NEW STRUCTURE WAS BEING BUILT AND ONE OF THE NEIGHBORS MENTIONED IT TO ME AND I MENTIONED IT TO MR DIOCESE AND THE CITY WENT BY. AND I KNOW FOR A FACT THAT WHAT THEY HAD ORIGINALLY INTENDED TO TAKE PLACE. THERE WAS NOT ALLOWED BECAUSE OF OUR UM YOU KNOW, BECAUSE OF OUR CODE ENFORCEMENT , SO I APPRECIATE MR THE COMMISSIONER COLLEGE REMARKS. I MET WITH JESSE ON FRIDAY, MISS SEYMOUR FOR AN HOUR AND A HALF.

AND I TALKED ABOUT IN A YEAR. YOU KNOW WHAT ARE THE METRICS WE'RE GOING TO USE TO MEASURE THE SUCCESS OF THIS. AND WE HAVE TO EVALUATE ACCOUNTS SUCCESS, BUT THE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCE THAT IS A DISASTROUS WHICH IS YOUR THAT'S A, YOU KNOW A LITTLE LEGITIMATE CONCERN, SO WE SHOULDN'T FEEL THAT IF WE PASS THIS, WE'RE JUST GOING TO TURN OUR BACK AT IT AND SAY GOOD LUCK E. STEWART. THAT'S NOT THE CASE AT ALL. I KNOW FOR A FACT IN ONE YEAR I WILL HAVE ON THE AGENDA AND EVALUATION OF THIS CODE AND HAS IT ACHIEVED WHAT WE STARTED. WOULD ACHIEVE. ARE WE SEEING DEVELOPMENT AND THE VACANT AREAS IN THE STEWART? DO WE HAVE A RASH OF YOU KNOW, IT SAYS OWNER OCCUPIED THAT'S VERY SPECIFIC. IF SOMEBODY WHO HAS OWNS FIVE HOME THEY CAN'T OCCUPY FIVE DIFFERENT HOMES. SO YOU KNOW, I APPRECIATE YOUR CONCERN, BUT I THINK THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S GOING TO DO A GOOD JOB OF UNDERSTANDING WHAT THE OBLIGATIONS ARE IN KEEPING TRACK. GOOD POINT. THANK YOU, SUSAN. COMMISSIONER CLARK. YES COMMISSIONER COLLINS YES, MCDONALD. COMMISSIONER RICH YES, YES. OKAY MOVING ON TO UNDER 15 DECREE, DISTRICT ZONING. HERE

[15. THE CREEK DISTRICT - ZONING MAP AMENDMENT (RC): ORDINANCE No. 2501-2023; AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY’S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO ASSIGN “THE CREEK DISTRICT” ZONING AND MAKE CHANGES FOR CONSISTENCY WITH THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

WITH ME. I'M PLAYING IT UP. THIS IS 18 15 OR 17. I'M SORRY. 15 MINUTES. JEEZ I'M UP THE WAY OFF COORDINATES TO 501 TO 023 IN ORDER TO THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY'S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO ASSIGN THE CREEK DISTRICT ZONING AND MAKE CHANGES FOR CONSISTENCY WITH THE FUTURE LAND USE MAPS PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES AND CONFLICT, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY, PROVIDING EFFECTIVE DATE UNDER THE PURPOSES. RECOGNIZE AGAIN. THIS IS THE MAP AMENDMENT, NOT THE TEXT AMENDMENT. OKAY NO CHANGE TO THE MAP WILL COORDINATE WITH THE GI SPECIALIST SLASH CITY MANAGER WITH THE COLOR QUESTION . UM STAFF IS RECOMMENDING A FULL MOTION APPROVED A MOTION TO IF YOU HAVE A 2ND 2ND SECOND.

OKAY WE HAVE MOTION BY COMMISSIONER COLIN'S SECOND BY COMMISSIONER RICH ANY PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ITEM? DONE TO SEE WHAT YOU CALL THE ROLL, MR BRUNER. YES, MACDONALD.

COMMISSIONER CLARK. COMMISSIONER COLLINS. YES COMMISSIONER RICH, COMMISSIONER. CLARK HAD STEPPED

[16. THE CREEK DISTRICT - LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AMENDMENT (RC): ORDINANCE No. 2498-2023; AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING AND RESTATING THE CITY’S LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING CHAPTER II ZONING DISTRICTS USES ALLOWED, DENSITY, INTENSITY; CHAPTER III SPECIAL ZONING CODES FOR “THE CREEK DISTRICT”; AND CHAPTER XII DEFINITIONS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTING PROVISIONS; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

[03:40:07]

OUT OF THE ROOM. OKAY MOVING ON TO ADAM 16. MIKE ORDINANCE NUMBER 2498-20 TO 3 IN ORDER TO THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING AND RESTATING THE CITY'S LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE MORE SPECIFICALLY, AMENDING CHAPTER TWO ZONING DISTRICTS USES ALLOWED DENSITY INTENSITY. CHAPTER THREE SPECIAL ZONING CODES FOR THE CREEK DISTRICT AND CHAPTER 12. DEFINITIONS WRITING FOR SEVERABILITY, PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTING PROVISIONS PROVIDING FOR QUANTIFICATION PROVIDING FOR EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. ALL RIGHT. JESSICA SEYMOUR FOR THE RECORD AGAIN, UM , SAME GOALS AND OBJECTIVES ONLY A DIFFERENT PLACE AND SO ACTUALLY DIFFERENT GOALS, BUT SIMILAR OBJECTIVES ABOUT CREATING PREDICTABILITY FOR THE DISTRICT. UM AND THIS IS THE CREEK DISTRICT. I'M GONNA GO FOR ANYBODY WHO DOESN'T KNOW WHERE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE DISTRICT RUNNING ALONG COLORADO AVENUE RUNNING TO DIXIE HIGHWAY. UM AND IT'S BORDERED ON US ONE AND FLORIDA STREET. UM AT THE FIRST HEARING, WE REALLY HAD TWO MAIN COMMENTS THAT CAME FROM THE BOARD. ONE OF THEM WAS ABOUT ADDRESSING FORMULA BUSINESSES AND SOME OF THE JP CUT IF YOU PICK A LIVE LANGUAGE THERE, AND SOME OF THE HISTORIC APPLICATIONS OF THAT POLICY, SO THIS IS ACTUALLY OUTSIDE OF THE CREEK DISTRICT CODE. UM WE WERE ONLY BRINGING IT FORWARD BECAUSE IT MENTIONED AREAS THAT WITHIN THE CREEK DISTRICT, SO WE WANTED TO CLEAN UP THE LANGUAGE, SO IT WAS CONSISTENT WITH THE PROPOSED CODE. UM SO WE WENT AHEAD AND UPDATED THE MAP WITH OUR WITH WITH G. I S SO THAT IT CAN BE ADDED INTO, UM, FUTURE EFFORTS. IT'S MAPPED THAT WAY. UM ONE OF THE IMPORTANT PIECES THAT CAME OUT OF THAT LANGUAGE WHEN IT WAS BROUGHT BEFORE THE BOARD WAS THE , UM THE ORIGINAL LANGUAGE CALLED OUT FOR, UM, THIS DIMENSIONAL CRITERIA FOR FORMULA BUSINESSES AND THEN AGAIN FORMULA. BUSINESSES ARE DEFINED TERM WITHIN THE LDCS RIGHT NOW, UM, THAT CALL OUT PROPERTIES THAT ARE HAVE MULTIPLE LOCATIONS . IS IT REALLY THE SHORTHAND FOR A FORMULA? BUSINESS? UM MAY BE CALLED A CHAIN RESTAURANT OR A CHAIN CHAIN ORDINANCE. UM REALLY , WHERE THIS HAS BEEN APPLIED AT THE MOST STRICTEST SENSE IS IN OUR OLD DOWNTOWN DISTRICT, WHICH IS SHOWN IN THE MAP ON THE RIGHT. UM SO WHAT WE'RE PROPOSING OF DRAFTED OUT FOR THE BOARD TO REVIEW IS THAT THOSE DIMENSIONAL CRITERIA THAT ARE HIGHLIGHTED IN ORANGE, UM, RETAINED FOR THE OLD TOWN DOWN ALL DOWNTOWN DISTRICT. UM BUT THAT THEY DON'T APPLY TO THE CREEK DISTRICT OR SOME OF THE AREAS AREAS FURTHER TO THE WEST . UM IT WOULD STILL MAINTAIN, UM , THE MAJOR USE, UM, APPROVAL PROCESS, SO IT WOULD BE STILL BE SOMETHING THAT WOULD COME BEFORE THE BOARD AND HAVE TO HAVE A REQUEST FOR APPROVAL. THEY WOULD STILL HAVE TO MEET HIGHER STANDARDS FOR CREATING CONSISTENCY WITH THE COMMUNITY AND WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL CHARACTER AS WELL AS SIGNAGE, SO THOSE THINGS WILL REMAIN FOR THE ENTIRE FORMULA BUSINESS AREA. UM AND THEN WE ALSO RECOMMENDED STRIKING OUT WHAT TODAY ARE EXISTING, UM, C AND F AND THAT'S ONLY BECAUSE THEY ARE DUPLICATIVE OF THE LANGUAGE THAT'S STATED JUST BEFORE IT AND WE'RE ALSO RECOMMENDING THAT THIS AREA GET MAPPED AS PART OF THE RESOURCE THAT THE CITY HAS FOR APPLICANTS AND FOR THE RESIDENTS ON THEIR T. I S SO THAT IT'S EASILY TRACKED. UH UM, THE OTHER COMMENT THAT WE RECEIVED WAS ABOUT SOME LANGUAGE THAT ARE ACTUALLY EXISTS IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ABOUT HOW URBAN CODE UM URBAN DOWNTOWN DISTRICTS WERE, UM, TREATED ON A SUBDISTRICT BASIS. SO BECAUSE OF THE WAY THIS, UM THESE LDCS ARE BROUGHT FORWARD. WE'RE ONLY BRINGING FORWARD LDC CHANGES, WHICH ARE THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE. SO THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE'VE MET WITH STAFF ON AND WE'LL COME BACK TO THE BOARD ON HOW IT CAN BE RECTIFIED WITHIN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. UM THIS IS THE FOOTNOTE THAT WAS MENTIONED. UM, IT DOESN'T ACTUALLY LIST ARE NEW ZONING CATEGORIES, SO THIS FOOTNOTE DOESN'T APPLY TO OUR NEW CATEGORIES, BUT STAFF IS STILL GOING TO BRING BACK SOME CLARIFYING LANGUAGE SO THAT WHEN THERE'S A OPPORTUNITY AND PUTTING JODI TO ON THE SPOT, UM TO HELP CLARIFY THIS FOR, UM, IN A SUPPLICANT EFFORT IT ALMOST SEEMS LIKE YOU WOULD JUST TAKE OUT THE 70 30 THING. IT MAKES IT MORE COMPLICATED. EVEN HAVE THAT , IN THEIR PERCENTAGE IS THE FOOTNOTE. THEY DON'T KNOW THAT THEY'RE COMMUNICATING EFFECTIVELY POINT, BUT YOU BRING ESPECIALLY THE SUB DISTRICTS AND WHOLE AREA INTO NONCOMPLIANCE AS SOON AS YOU CREATE A SUBDISTRICT , RIGHT AND ANY OTHER THAT'S TRUE OF WHAT WHAT'S ON THE BOOKS TODAY, SO I THINK THAT THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN A DIFFERENT INTENTION AND SOME OF THAT LANGUAGE AND THAT'S AGAIN SOMETHING THAT STAFF WILL DO WE DO THAT IS THAT HOW DO WE IS THAT A COMPLAINT AMENDMENT? YEAH. YES, THAT'S A COMPLIMENT AMENDMENT. UM, AND THIS WAS

[03:45:02]

ADVERTISED AS JUST THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODES, SO WE HAD TO STAY WITHIN OUR RECOMMENDING.

ARE WE GOING TO CREATE AN ISSUE WHERE THESE SUB DISTRICTS BRING? AMENDED NONCOMPLIANCE, ASSUMING THEY BRING AN APPLICATION FOR TOMORROW BECAUSE THEY ACTUALLY AREN'T LISTED IN THAT TABLE SO THEY WOULDN'T ANYWAY, SO WE COULD JUST TAKE OUT 70. RIGHT RIGHT. I GOT IT. THANK YOU, AND THEN SOAKED AGAIN SO THAT THERE ISN'T CONFUSION FOR AN APPLICANT THAT COMES IN AND SEES THE URBAN CODE BEING MENTIONED. UM WE JUST MADE SURE THAT IN THE LDCS UNDER THE TABLE THREE AND THREE A THAT WE'VE ADDED THE FOOTNOTE THAT ALL OF OUR ZONING DISTRICTS THAT WE'VE ADDED TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE ARE LISTED. SO THAT THE DENSITY UM PROVISIONS ARE VERY CLEARLY COMMUNICATED WITHIN THE EMBASSIES. DO YOU THINK OF THAT? I JUST I WANTED TO BE CLEAR THAT THE INTENT OF THE BOARD IS THAT THE. WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT THE DENSITIES RIGHT NOW. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE USE THE WAY THAT FUTURE LAND USE SAYS IS THAT WITHIN EACH SUB DISTRICT, YOU CAN HAVE NO MORE THAN 70% COMMERCIAL. VERSUS NO MORE THAN 70% RESIDENTIAL. BUT IF YOU READ IT OUT OF CONTEXT, SOMEONE MIGHT SAY THAT EACH PARCEL CAN HAVE NO MORE THAN 70% WHICH MEANT THAT EVERYTHING HAS TO BE MIXED USE, WHICH IS NOT THE INTENT OR IF YOU READ IT, TOO RESTRICTIVE, LEE IF THE CREEK INDUSTRIAL COULD HAVE NO MORE THAN ONE OR THE OTHER. I JUST WANTED TO BE CLEAR THAT I DIDN'T BELIEVE THAT THE COMMISSION HAD ANY INTENTIONS THAT ANY OF THE CREEK DISTRICTS BE CAPPED AT 70 OR OR OR ANY USE FOR EITHER. HAVE WE ACHIEVED THIS? THAT WITH WHAT SHE'S DONE HERE? WE HAVEN'T. WE HAVEN'T DONE ANYTHING IN THE COM PLANTS SO THAT WILL COME FORWARD WHAT WE'VE IDENTIFIED, THOUGH, WITH THE FORM BASED CODE THE THERE'S TWO ISSUES WITHIN THE SO WE'RE USING AN EXISTING FUTURE LAND USE BECAUSE THAT ALREADY THAT EXISTING FUTURE LAND USE ALREADY ALLOWED FOR A MIX OF USES CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE WERE. OUR GOALS WERE RIGHT. UM THERE'S 22 ISSUES. ONE IS THIS FOOTNOTE NUMBER EIGHT IN THE COMP PLAN THAT CALLS OUT HONEST ANALYSIS ON A SUBDISTRICT BASIS. AND THAT'S ACTUALLY IN REFERENCE TO THE DWELLING UNITS, NOT THE PERCENTAGES. THEN THERE'S THE PERCENTAGES THAT YOU MENTIONED OVER HERE IN THIS COLUMN, TALKING ABOUT PERCENTAGE RESIDENTIAL AND PERCENTAGE NONRESIDENTIAL AND TO ECHO WHAT MR MORTALITY IS DESCRIBING. WE FELT THAT THE BOARD DIRECTION AT THE LAST MEETING WAS THAT WE DO NOT WANT TO RESTRICT. THESE NEW FUTURE LAND USES TO THE YOU KNOW, IT HAS TO BE 100% ROZENTAL . THERE HAS TO BE 100% COMMERCIAL. WHEN A NEW PROJECT COMES ON, IT WOULD BE ALLOWED FOR A MIX OF USES OF THE DENSITY PROVISION. THIS IS ON A PER PARCEL BASIS, NOT A SUBDISTRICT BASIS, RIGHT? SO I BELIEVE THAT THE CITY'S INTENTION OR OR APPLICATION HAS ALWAYS BEEN ON A PER PARCEL BASIS AS IT RELATES TO DENSITIES. BUT THAT FOOTNOTE THAT'S IN THE THAT'S IN THE TABLE OF USES OF DENSITIES INTENSITIES. AS IT SAYS IT'S THAT THAT IT SAYS 15 YEARS AN ACRE. SHALL BE INTERPRETED ON AN URBAN SUBDISTRICT BASIS WITHIN THE C R. A SO WHEN I READ IT IT MEANS TO ME THAT DENSITY EVERYWHERE ELSE. IS ON A PER PARCEL. BUT IN THE C R A IT'S GOING TO BE BASED UPON THE ENTIRE URBAN SUBDISTRICT. AND THEN, AS JESSICA POINTS OUT IT DOESN'T SPECIFICALLY RENT MENTIONED THESE DISTRICTS, BUT IT DOESN'T EXCLUDE THEM, IT SAYS , INCLUDING POP POP POP POP POP POP, BUT IT DOESN'T EXCLUDE. THEM OR IT MIGHT THING IS, I THINK OF THESE AS SUB DISTRICTS IN THE C R A. I MEAN, WE'RE CALLING HIMSELF DISTRICTS IN THE C R A SO IF THEY'RE NOT SUB DISTRICTS IF THEY'RE NOT URBAN SUB DISTRICTS IN THE C R A. WHAT ARE THEY? WELL THEY'RE AND THEIR ZONING CATEGORIES. BUT EVEN EVEN WITH THAT, I MEAN AGAIN. THESE TWO POLICIES, THE PERCENTAGES AND THE DENSITY POLICY THEY'RE BEING READ WITH WITH SOME THEY COULD BE, YOU KNOW, BROUGHT FORWARD WITH SOME CLARITY AND AGAIN, CLARIFYING IF WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SUB DISTRICTS OR ZONING CATEGORIES, AND THAT'S SOMETHING THAT HMM. I DON'T WANT TO TOTALLY DERAIL THIS. BUT IS THERE CAN WE MAKE SURE THAT WE WHEN WE AMEND THE COMPLAINT, WHICH WE HAVE TO DO ANYWAY, FOR THIS, WE CLEAN IT UP, DO YOU? WELL THE CLEAN THAT EVERYBODY TAKING OUT THAT IF WE COME BACK, I DON'T KNOW THAT WE ARE COMING. WE WERE DIRECTED TO COME BACK WITH AMENDMENT TO COMPLAIN. BUT IF IN FACT THE COMMISSION WANTED A DIRECTION TO AMEND THE COMPLAINT, WE COULD REMOVE THAT WE NEED TO HAVE A FURTHER DISCUSSION FROM THE COMMISSION AND DISCUSSED WHAT THE INTENTIONS ARE OF THE COMMISSION AS RELATES TO ALL OF IT AND

[03:50:03]

ADDRESS IT, BUT WE DO THAT, JUST SO WE'RE NOT KIND OF WHAT YOU KNOW THERE'S NOT LIABILITY HERE, SO THERE'S A DIFFERENT NOTIFICATION SO WE CAN'T JUST GO TONIGHT. RIGHT RIGHT. WELL, FIX . YEAH ATTENTION FOR SURE, RIGHT ? GONNA END UP TALKING ABOUT IT IN THE STRATEGIC PLAN AND, AS A RESULT, END UP WITH A DIRECTION AT THAT POINT THAT WOULD RESOLVE WOULD RESULT IN PROBABLY SOME COMPETENT AND IT'S ANYWAY, WHICH WE COULD ADDRESS WHEN THAT HAPPENS ABSOLUTELY, AND THAT THAT'S WHAT WE HAD, UM, CONTROL MEETING WHERE WE TALKED ABOUT THERE COULD BE SOME OTHER OPPORTUNITIES FOR THIS COULD BE CLEANED UP. UM AGAIN. WHAT WE COULD ADDRESS IS THAT IT'S UH, DENSITIES ARE IDENTIFIED CLEARLY HERE. UM AND THEN AGAIN, WE MADE SOME SIMILAR LANGUAGE. UM CORRECTIONS THROUGHOUT THE DOCUMENT AND WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO UNTIL IT'S UPLOADED THEIR OWN UNICODE IF IT'S APPROVED. MOTION APPROVED. OKAY WE HAVE WE HAVE A MOTION TO APPROVE IN A SECOND, ANY COMMENT FROM ANYONE? ANY PUBLIC COMMENT. WHO'S DAVE IN THE MOTION WAS BY COMMISSIONER COLLINS AND THE SECULAR BY COMMISSIONER CLARK. MARY MCDONALD YES, COMMISSIONER CARD.

YES ER BRUDER. YES COMMISSIONER RICH? YES, COLLINS. ALRIGHT NOW MOVING ON TO OUR LAST COUPLE ITEMS. WHOA! APPLIED BY. YES 17 TODD. LOOKS LIKE YOU'RE UP. THIS IS ORDINANCE NUMBER 2510-20 TO 3

[17. STUART AUTO VAULT, LLC., PETITION FOR VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION ON MONTEREY ROAD (RC): ORDINANCE No. 2510-2023; AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, ANNEXING A PARCEL OF LAND FRONTING SE MONTEREY ROAD, CONSISTING OF 0.34-ACRES, SAID PARCEL BEING MORE FULLY DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT “A” ATTACHED HERETO; PROVIDING DIRECTIONS TO THE CITY CLERK; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

NORTH OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, ANNEXING A PARCEL OF LAND FRONTING SOUTHEAST MONTEREY ROAD CONSISTING OF 30.34 ACRES, SAID PERSONAL BEING MORE FULLY DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT A ATTACHED HERE TO PROVIDING DIRECTIONS TO THE CITY CLERK PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES AND CONFLICT PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY. AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. OH GOOD EVENING, MAYOR MCDONALD AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION FOR THE RECORD. MY NAME IS JERRY COOLER DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR. TONIGHT I'M REPRESENTING AGENDA ITEMS 17, 18 AND 19. THE APPLICANT RED TAIL DESIGN SUBMITTED PETITIONS ON BEHALF OF STEWART AUDIBLE LLC. FOR A VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION TO INCORPORATE THE 0.34 ACRES FROM MARTIN COUNTY TO THE CITY OF STEWART JURISDICTION. A SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT TO ASSIGN A FUTURE LAND, USE CATEGORY OF COMMERCIAL AND ASSIGN A B FOUR LIMITED BUSINESS MANUFACTURING ZONING DESTINATION. FOR A PROJECT TO BE KNOWN AS STEWART AUTO BULB BEARING COMMERCE CENTER. THE PROPERTY CURRENTLY HAS A ITALIAN LAND USE AND ZONING DESIGNATION THE LAND USES IS GENERAL COMMERCIAL AND THE ZONING IS B ONE BUSINESS. THE FIRST ITEM LIBRARY PRESENTING IS AGENDA ITEM 17. THIS IS THE VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. THIS WILL BE THE FIRST READING. THE PROBLEM. THE PROPERTY WAS WAS PLACED A SIGN ON DETAIL IN THE CITY COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING AND POSTED ON THE PREMISES IN ADVERTISEMENT WAS DISPLAYED IN THE NEWSPAPER ON JANUARY 27 2023 ADVERTISING THIS PARTICULAR MEETING. OH ONE SECOND TO MIKE. THIS ISN'T QUASI JUDICIAL, IS IT? ANNEXATION IS NOT OKAY. THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT. OKAY. I JUST WANT TO DOUBLE CHECK, THOUGH. OKAY. SORRY ABOUT THAT LEGISLATIVE THE ACTUAL LOCATION OF THE THREE OF THE 30.34 ACRE SITE IS CURRENTLY VACANT AND IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF SOUTHEAST MONTEREY ROAD. THIS SITE IS BOUNDED BY THE CITY OF STEWART AND THE NORTHEAST, NORTHWEST, SOUTH AND ADJACENT TO THE PROPERTY. TO THIS PROPERTY TO THE COUNTY TO THE EAST. ON JANUARY, 12 2023, THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY, HELD A PUBLIC HEARING ON THIS ITEM THERE BEING NO PUBLIC COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC. THE WARD VOTED IN DMC TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO THE CITY COMMISSION FOR THE VOLUNTARY PETITION VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION PETITION. THIS PETITION CONFORMS TO THE CRITERIA SET FORTH IN SECTION 11.1 POINT 12 OF THE CITY OF STEWART LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.

CODE UH, FOR THE STATUES, AND IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICY OF THE CITY OF STEWART COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. AND STAFF RECOMMENDS THE CITY COMMISSION APPROVED THE VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION OF THE 0.34 ACRES OF LAND ON FIRST READING OF ORDINANCE NUMBER 25 10-2023.

OKAY. THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY COMMENTS OR MOTIONS? NO I JUST SEE THAT THEIR RESULTS FROM STAFF IN TERMS OF YOU KNOW, UH, WATER AND WASTEWATER AND TRAFFIC AND ALL THE OTHER POTENTIAL IMPACTS. WITH A SMALL THE SMALL, VOLUNTARY, UM ANNEXATION APPLICATION AND NO COME. NO COMMENTS FROM I THINK NO PRESENCE OF THE L P A AND PARTICULAR COMMENTS THEY

[03:55:01]

[18. STUART AUTO VAULT, LLC., PETITION FOR SMALL-SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT ON MONTEREY ROAD (RC): (THIS IS A SINGLE READING ITEM) ORDINANCE No. 2511-2023; AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT AS DEFINED IN F.S.§163.3187; AMENDING THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, FUTURE LAND USE MAP FOR AN APPROXIMATELY 0.34-ACRE PARCEL FROM THE FUTURE LAND USE OF GENERAL COMMERCIAL (COUNTY) TO THE FUTURE LAND USE OF COMMERCIAL (CITY); AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP; PROVIDING DIRECTIONS TO THE CITY CLERK; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

ON TO ITEM 18. STUART OUT ABOUT PETITION FOR SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ON MONTEREY ROAD, MIKE, BUT YOU READ THE ORDINANCE. THIS IS ORDINANCE 2511-20 TO 3 IN ORDER TO THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STEWART. SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT IS TO FIND IT IN FLORIDA STATUTE 163.3187 AMENDING THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, FUTURE LAND USE MAP FOR APPROXIMATELY 0.34 ACRE PARCEL FROM THE FUTURE LAND USE OF GENERAL COMMERCIAL, WHICH IS IN THE COUNTY TO THE FUTURE LAND USE OF COMMERCIAL IN THE CITY, AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PROVIDING DIRECTIONS TO THE CITY CLERK PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCE AND TEMPLATE, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND OTHER PURPOSES AND AS A POINT OF REFERENCE UPON ANNEXATION. YOU'RE NOT ACTUALLY AMENDING THE FUTURE. MOUNT LAND USE MAPS. YOU'RE AMENDING THE MAP, BUT IT'S NOT AN AMENDMENT OF THE FUTURE LAND USE. WE DON'T HAVE THE FUTURE MAN. THE FUTURE LAND USE THAT'S IN THE COUNTY.

IT LOSES ALL STATUS, SO YOU WERE REALLY ASSIGNING A FUTURE LAND USE. IT'S NOT SOMETHING YOU COULD DENY AND LEAVE. NO FUTURE LAND USE. OKAY, JODIE AGAIN. MY NAME IS JERRY KUGLER, DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR FOR THE RECORD. UM THIS IS, UM PRESENTING ITEM 18, WHICH IS THE SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT. THIS IS A SINGLE READING ITEM FOR ORDINANCE NUMBER 25 11-2023. AGAIN PUBLIC NOTICE WAS PROVIDED ON THE PROPERTY SIGN WAS DISPLAYED AND WAS PUBLISHED IN A NEWSPAPER ON JANUARY 23RD 2023 27. I DO APOLOGIZE. MRS THE SAME LOCATION IS 2.34 ACRES. FEATURE OF THIS PROPERTY CURRENTLY HAS A GENERAL COMMERCIAL COUNTY FUTURE LAND USE AS A NATION. AND THE APPLE IN ACCORDANCE TO THE CITY OF STEWART. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICY ONE POINT 87.5 PROPERTIES THAT ARE ANNEXED INTO THE CITY SHALL BE GIVEN THE CITY LAND USE DESIGNATION AS SOON AS POSSIBLE AFTER THE ANNEXATION IS FINALIZED. THE APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED THE PROPERTY BE ASSIGNED IF FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY OF COMMERCIAL WHICH IS CONSISTENT WITH THE ADJACENT SURROUNDING AREA. AGAIN THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY DID HEAR THIS PETITION ON JANUARY, 12 2023 HAS RECOMMENDED APPROVAL OF WRECKED RECOMMENDATION OF APPROVAL TO THE CITY COMMISSIONER FOR THE SMALL SCALE FUTURE LAND USE AMENDMENT. AND THIS PETITION CONFORMS TO THIS CRITERIA SET FORTH IN SECTION 11.1 POINT 07 OF THE CITY OF STEWART LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE BEFORE THE STATUES AND IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS OBJECTIVES IN THE POLICIES. OF THE CITY OF STEWART COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. STAFF RECOMMENDS THE CITY COMMISSIONER , SIGNING A FUTURE LAND USE CATEGORY OF COMMERCIAL FOR THE 0.34 ACRES OF LAND OF ORDINANCE NUMBER. 25 11-2023 AGAIN. THIS THIS PARTICULAR ITEM ONLY REQUIRES ONE READING OF THE OF THE ORDINANCE. ANY COMMENTS, QUESTIONS OR MOTIONS? EMOTIONAL PROOF. SECOND MOTION BY COMMISSIONER COLLINS SECONDED BY MR MAYOR OF ONE COMMENT. ON PAGE 4 40. MY NAME IS BACKWARDS. GOD THAT'S ALL THE TIME. I MEAN, THE MAYOR'S HAD TROUBLE WITH MY NAME TODAY AND AROUND. THEY'RE GETTING A SIGN THAT THAT'S RIGHT THIS WAY. I THINK IT'S BACKWARDS IN FRONT OF YOU. TROY CAN'T SEE THAT. YEAH. ANY PUBLIC COMMENT. DID YOU CALL THE ROLL? COMMISSIONER RICH. YES COMMISSIONER CLARK? YES COMMISSIONER COLLINS? YES FACE.

[04:00:03]

MAYOR BRUNER. YES. MCDONALD? YES. OKAY IN THE LAST ITEM. THE STEWARD OVERVOTE PETITION FOR

[19. STUART AUTO VAULT, LLC., PETITION FOR REZONE TO THE OFFICIAL ZONING ATLAS ON MONTEREY ROAD (RC): ORDINANCE No. 2512-2023; AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY’S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP; TO REZONE A 0.34-ACRE PARCEL; LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF SE MONTEREY ROAD; BEING MORE DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT “A” ATTACHED, FROM B-1 BUSINESS (COUNTY) ZONING DESIGNATION TO B-4 LIMITED BUSINESS/MANUFACTURING (CITY) ZONING DESIGNATION; PROVIDING DIRECTIONS TO THE CITY CLERK; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.]

REZONED TO THE OFFICIAL ZONING ATLAS MONTEREY ROAD. MIKE WOULD YOU READ THE TITLE? AND IS THIS ONE QUESTION? THIS IS A QUASI JUDICIAL BECAUSE IT IS A ZONING ASSIGNMENT TO THE PROPERTY. IT WOULD BE ORDINANCE TO 512-20 TO 3, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF STUART, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY'S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO REZONE 30.34 ACRE PARCEL LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF SOUTHEAST MONTEREY ROAD BEING MORALLY MORE DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT A ATTACHED FROM. FROM B ONE'S BUSINESS, BUT IT'S NOT REALLY ZONED ANYTHING COUNTY DESIGNATION TO BE FOUR LIMITED BUSINESS MANUFACTURING IN THE CITY ZONING DESIGNATION, PROVIDING DIRECTION TO THE CITY CLERK PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF ALL ORDINANCES AND CONFLICT, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE FOR OTHER PURPOSES. OKAY, INDEED , THE COMMISSIONERS HAVE ANY EX PARTY COMMUNICATIONS. AND ARE YOU HERE WITH AN OPEN MIND? I'LL START WITH COMMISSIONER RICH AND MOVED DOWN THE LINE. I MET WITH CITY MANAGER DIETS WITH REGARD TO THIS ISSUE. BUT I HAVE AN OPEN MIND. I HAVE DONE. HAVE NONE. I CAN'T REMEMBER ANY COMMUNICATIONS. I'M HERE WITH AN OPEN MIND. OKAY AND I AM HERE WITH AN OPEN MIND. I MET WITH THE APPLICANT AND HIS REPRESENTATIVES AND STAFF IN THE BASEMENT BREWED HERE WITH AN OPEN MIND. HAVE YOU MET WITH ANYONE? OKAY OKAY, SO LET'S SEE. JUST GOOD BEAR DIRECTOR CITY. TERRY, WOULD YOU PLEASE SWEAR IN ANY POTENTIAL WITNESSES? WELL, THOSE OF YOU GIVING TESTIMONY TONIGHT PLEASE STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. OH LOOK, JODY, SITTING OVER THERE. THAT'S MESSED UP. MAN CAN'T SEE HER.

BUT PLEASE STAY ON THE RIDGE RIGHT IN THE REGULAR REFLECT THAT THERE'S TWO PEOPLE. DO YOU SWEAR TO TELL THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH? NOTHING ABOUT THE JUICE RIGHT REGARD. AND THAT THE RECORD AFFECT BOTH AFFIRMATIVE TESTIFIED AFFIRMATIVELY. THANK YOU. OKAY AND JODI. IF YOU GO AHEAD AND PROVIDE A BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE AGENDA ITEM, INCLUDING THE LOCATION SIZE OF THE PROPERTY, CURRENT ZONING ZONING REQUEST LIST OF APPLICANTS REQUEST TO DEVIATE FROM THE LAND USE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS. THANK YOU. ONCE AGAIN. MY NAME IS JERRY CUTLER, THE DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR. UM I'M HERE PRESENTING ITEMS 19, WHICH IS A REASON TO THE OFFICIAL ZONING THAT LIST. THIS ITEM IS ON FIRST READING FOR TONIGHT, AND ITS ORDINANCE NUMBER 25 12.

THAT'S 2023. AGAIN SAME LOCATION IS 2.34 ACRES. THAT THIS IS THE EXISTING ZONING, WHICH IS A B ONE BUSINESS SIGN DESIGNATION THAT'S CURRENTLY IN THE COUNTY. AND THE APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED TO ASSIGN THE PROPERTY AS A B FOUR LIMITED BUSINESS MANUFACTURING ZONING DESTINATION WITHIN THE CITY. THESE ARE THE SURROUNDING PROPERTIES THAT ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE ZONING DESIGNATION BEING REQUESTED. AND AGAIN, YOUR LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY DID HEAR THIS ITEM ON JANUARY, 12 2023 HAS RECOMMENDED APPROVAL TO THE CITY OF COMMISSION TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP. ATLAS PETITION. AND THIS PETITION CONFORMS TO THE CRITERIA SET FORTH IN SECTION 11.2 POINT 00 OF THE STUART LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR THE STATUES , AND IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF THE CITY OF STEWART COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. STAFF RECOMMENDS THE CITY COMMISSION TO APPROVE AMENDING THE OFFICIALS ONLY MAP ALICE TO ASSIGN A B FOR LIMITED BUSINESS MANUFACTURING ZONING DESTINATION. OF THE THREE POINT OF THE 3.0.34 ACRES ON FIRST READING OF ORDINANCE NUMBER 25. 12-2023. OKAY AND THERE'S THE APPLICANT HAVE ANY PRESENTATION, TODD. THANK YOU, MADAM MAYOR, MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION FOR THE RECORD TADMUR WITH RED TAIL HERE TO REALLY SUPPORT JODI'S STAFF REPORT. EXCELLENT JOB AS ALWAYS, AND IT'S ALWAYS NICE TO SEE A FELLOW COLLEAGUE. THAT'S ACTUALLY DOWN HERE SO FROM FROM OUR HEARTS TO YOURS, WE APPRECIATE THE HELP AND SUPPORT THERE ANY QUESTIONS THAT WE CAN ANSWER. WE'D LOVE TO DO THAT. THIS IS OBVIOUSLY A SMALL PIECE OF A PART OF A LARGER PROJECT IN THE ADJACENT PROPERTIES. ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANTS? OKAY. LETS SEIZE. LET'S SEE.

THERE'S A VISUAL SEPARATION POSITION. I WISH TO OFFER ANY ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. I'M GUESSING NOW. UH PRESIDENTIAL EVIDENCES ENDED. UH, ANY PUBLIC COMMENT. DONE. OKAY YES, WE CAN , UH, DELIBERATE MAKING EMOTIONS. EMOTIONAL APPROVED. SECOND. WE HAVE EMOTION BY

[04:05:02]

COMMISSIONER COLIN'S SECOND BY COMMISSIONER CLARK. ANY COMMENTS FOR ME? THE COMMISSIONER'S SEEING NONE. ANY COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC ON THE MOTION? SAYING NO TO SAY WHAT YOU CALL THE ROLE VICE MAYOR BURNER. YES COMMISSIONER COLLINS? YES RICH? YES, MCDONALD'S YES, COMMISSIONER CLARK? YES? ALRIGHT AND THE LAST TWO ITEMS WERE REMOTE WHEN WE APPROVED THE AGENDA, SO MEETING ADJOURNED.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.

Feb 13, 2023 Regular City Commission Meeting

Link

Social

Embed

Download

Download Selected Item